Acn148 877 525 Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

ACN148 877 525 Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission  [2022] QCAT 72

PARTIES: ACN148 877 525 PTY LTD

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR090-18

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

8 March 2022

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

A/ Senior Member Traves

ORDERS:

1.   The application filed by the respondent seeking an order that the proceedings be struck out or dismissed is refused.

2.   The named applicant is amended by substituting ACN148 877 525 Pty Ltd with Lee Anthony Crocker and Dene Ward Crocker.

3.   The application be listed for a Directions Hearing on a date and time to be advised.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where amended scope of works decision issued to directors of deregistered company – where application for review made in the Tribunal – whether application made by company or by directors in their individual capacity – if application made as individuals, whether directors have standing under s 87 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) – whether directors “affected by a reviewable decision” – whether application for review should be struck out under s 47 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 71, s 71A(6), s 86, s 86F, s 87, s 111C

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 47

China First Pty Ltd v Mount Isa Mines Ltd & ors [2018] QCA 350.

Col Jenkins & Associates v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 117
Crocker v QBCC [2017] QCAT 304
Hall v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2020] QCAT 379
McCrystal v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2018] QCAT 207
Namour v Queensland Building Services Authority [2014] QCA 72

Re Octaviar Administration Pty Ltd (in liq) (2013) 94 ACSR 612

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicants:

Self-represented

Respondent:

QBCC Legal Branch

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The substantive proceedings concern an application for review of a decision by the QBCC on 1 March 2018 to issue a scope of works to be undertaken under the statutory insurance scheme to rectify or complete tribunal work.

  2. On 8 October 2020, the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) filed an application to dismiss the review application (strike out application).

  3. On 5 November 2020 the Tribunal made directions which amended the name of the applicant in the proceedings to ACN148 977 525 Pty Ltd (formerly Build (Qld) Pty Ltd) and called for submissions in relation to the strike out application.

  4. On 5 November 2020 Lee Crocker and Dene Crocker (the Crockers) filed an Application for miscellaneous matters seeking, among other things, that the named applicant in the matter be amended to Lee Crocker and Dene Crocker (application to amend name).

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Acn148 877 525 Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Constructio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCAT 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Acn148 877 525 Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission, the applicant, Acn148 877 525 Pty Ltd, a company that had previously operated under the name Build (Qld) Pty Ltd, and its directors, Lee Crocker and Dene Crocker, sought to challenge a decision made by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) regarding the scope of works for a home renovation project. The QBCC, in response, filed a strike out application arguing that the applicant company was deregistered and thus incapable of bringing legal proceedings, and that the individual directors did not have standing to challenge the decision as they were not the building contractors. The central legal issues in this case revolved around the validity of the review application given the deregistration of the company, the standing of the individual directors to challenge the QBCC's decision, and whether the application was misconceived.

The court considered the statutory provisions under the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 and the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1999. It found that while a deregistered company cannot maintain legal proceedings, the application for review appeared to be made by the individual directors, Lee Crocker and Dene Crocker, in addition to the company. The court examined the scope of review of a scope of works decision, which is limited to determining the reasonable and necessary rectification works, and concluded that the directors, as individuals, did not have standing to challenge the decision as they were not the building contractors. However, the court determined that the application was not entirely misconceived as it was made by the individual directors who were affected by the QBCC's decision.

The court dismissed the QBCC's strike out application and allowed the review to proceed, finding that the application was not frivolous, vexatious or misconceived. The court held that the directors had standing to challenge the decision as affected persons under the QBCC Act and that the review application was not invalidly commenced. The decision highlights the importance of correctly identifying the applicant in legal proceedings and the limitations on the standing of individual directors to challenge decisions of the QBCC in certain circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The matter before me is the strike out application. In considering that application I will address the issue of the proper identity of the applicant which, although directly raised by the application of 5 November 2020 which has been withdrawn, is also relevant to the strike out application.Relevant background On 22 August 2012 the owner entered into a contract with Build Restore Pty Ltd for home renovations. Lee Crocker was a director of Build Restore Pty Ltd from 28 April 2004 to 11 January 2013. Dene Crocker was a director of Build Restore Pty Ltd from 28 April 2004 to 27 August 2017. On 30 November 2013 the original contract was assigned to Build (Qld) Pty Ltd to complete the work. On 4 August 2016 the QBCC cancelled Build (Qld) Pty Ltd’s licence at their request. On 12 December 2016 Build (Qld) Pty Ltd changed its name to ACN 148 877 525 Pty Ltd. On 8 October 2016 a Notice of Practical Completion was issued to the owner and contractor by the architect. On 5 April 2017 the owner lodged a complaint form with the QBCC. On 11 June 2017 ACN 148 877 525 Pty Ltd (formerly Build (Qld) Pty Ltd) was deregistered by ASIC (reason s 601AB). Its former director (at the time of deregistration) was Dene Crocker who was director from 1 October 2016 to 11 June 2017. Lee Crocker was a former director from 19 December 2008 to 18 May 2014. On 7 March 2018 the Crockers received notification of an amended scope of works decision dated 1 March 2018 (the decision). The decision letter was addressed to Build (Qld) Pty Ltd and began “Dear Directors”. On 13 March 2018 an application for review of the decision was filed in the Tribunal. On 13 June 2018 the matter was adjourned pending the outcome of other Tribunal and court proceedings. The owner’s claim was progressed internally by the QBCC and the QBCC approved an insurance claim for $121, 112.83 in May 2019. On 17 May 2019 Lee Crocker received a letter from the QBCC stating that a claim had been made, as previously advised on 1 March 2018, and that the amount of $121, 112.83 had been approved. Under the heading “How this will affect you” the letter states: Under s 71 of the QBCC Act, the QBCC is entitled to recover the amount paid on the claim from you or your company…The strike out application In summary, the QBCC seeks an order striking out the review application pursuant to s 47 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act) on the following bases:(a)ACN148 877 525 Pty Ltd (formerly Build (Qld) Pty Ltd) ceased to exist on 11 June 2017. Legal proceedings cannot be commenced or maintained for or against a deregistered company.(b)Lee Crocker and Dene Crocker do not have standing to review the decision about a scope of works dated 1 March 2018, as neither Lee Crocker nor Dene Crocker were the ‘building contractor’ for the relevant work;(c)Neither Lee Crocker and Dene Crocker are an “affected person” in relation to the decision about a scope of works; and(d)The review application is misconceived and should be dismissed.The Crockers’ response

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view, in these circumstances and viewed objectively, the application was made by Lee Crocker and Dene Crocker and, perhaps, erroneously, by the company.Did the directors have standing to apply for review of the amended scope of works decision? I accept that the building contractor for the relevant building work was the former company. I also accept that the Crockers are separate from the company and have no time been the building contractor. Section 87 of the QBCC Act provides that:A person affected by a reviewable decision of the commission may apply, as provided under the QCAT Act, to the tribunal for a review of the decision. It is necessary to:(a)Identify the legal effect and operation of the reviewable decision; and(b)Determine whether the applicant is affected by that decision.[4][4]McCrystal v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2018] QCAT 207 at [42]. The scope of works decision is one decision in a series of decisions statutorily required by the QBCC Act. It is made after a decision to give a direction to rectify and after a decision to allow a statutory insurance claim in respect of work not rectified or completed. Both of these decisions are also reviewable. It has been held that the review of a scope of works decision is limited to asking what rectification works are reasonable and necessary given the nature of the rectification work to be undertaken.[5] It is not broadened by decisions made before, or after it, to include considerations, for example, of whether the work was defective, whether a claim should have been allowed under the statutory insurance scheme or whether the building contractor is liable, ultimately, for the insurance debt, being a person “through whose fault the claim arose”.[5]Col Jenkins & Associates v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 117 at [25]; Hall v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2020] QCAT 379 at [21]-[30] where it is said that the more accurate test is the ‘reasonable cost of necessary works’ as per the wording of clause 4.2 of the statutory insurance policy. The purpose of the scope of works decision is to outline a programme of works which is reasonable and necessary to rectify identified defects. It may also extend to consideration of whether the relevant programme of works is a reasonable cost effective method of rectifying the identified defects.[6][6]Hall v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2020] QCAT 379. The scope of review of a scope of works decision is accordingly, narrow. I accept the submissions of the QBCC that it is a decision which serves to particularise the programme of work necessary to rectify building work in circumstances where it has already been determined that such work is defective and is work for which a claim by a consumer may be allowed under the statutory insurance scheme. The nature of the decision to be made when reviewing a scope of works decision informs the consideration of whether a person is affected by the decision and therefore has standing to apply for review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In summary, they submit:(a)The decision is reviewable under s 86 of the QBCC Act.(b)The application is not prohibited by s 86F of the QBCC Act.(c)The Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the decision under s 87 of the QBCC Act.(d)The applicants are “affected persons” within the meaning of s 87 of the QBCC Act by sections 71 and 111C of the QBCC Act and due to adverse listings on the Licensee Register maintained by the QBCC.(e)The respondent’s application for dismissal is misconceived and not made out.(f)There is a prima facie matter to be heard in the review.Consideration The Tribunal has the power pursuant to s 47 of the QCAT Act to dismiss a proceeding if the Tribunal considers it is frivolous, vexatious or misconceived, lacking in substance or otherwise an abuse of process. The QBCC rely on the grounds that the proceeding is misconceived and lacking in substance and was not validly commenced. It is generally accepted in the Tribunal that to dismiss a matter without a hearing taking place is a serious step and one which should not be taken unless a clear case has been make out to support a dismissal.[1][1]Rita Commisso Enterprises Pty Ltd v The Body Corporate for Acacia Lodge Hostel [2013] QCAT 342 at [2]-[3]. I accept that proceedings for or against a deregistered company are a nullity and that it would be necessary, if the company was the proper applicant in this review, for the company to be reinstated in order for any proceedings to continue.[2][2]Stergiou v City Bank Savings Ltd [2005] ACTA 15 at [25]; Lomas v Veescorp Pty Ltd [2011] QCATA 290. I accept that the company, ACN 148 877 525 Pty Ltd (formerly Build (Qld) Pty Ltd) was deregistered by ASIC on 11 June 2017 and that it ceased to exist as a legal entity from that date. The QBCC made its decision, relevantly, the decision about the amended scope of works, on 1 March 2018 and by its letter of 8 March 2018 purported to notify the then deregistered company, and directors, of that decision. On 13 March 2018 an application for review of the decision made on 1 March 2018 was made. The application form under the heading Part A Applicant’s details provided:NameMr Lee Anthony & Dene Ward CrockerCompany/Partnership/otherACN 148 877 525 Pty Ltd (formerly Build Qld Pty Ltd) I accept that a review proceeding may not be commenced or maintained by a deregistered company. The effect of s 601AD of the Corporations Law is that a company ceases to exist on deregistration. It is also settled that a deregistered company cannot institute legal proceedings and that proceedings purportedly instituted by it are a nullity.[3] I accept that if I find the review proceeding was commenced in the name of the company, that it was not validly commenced.[3]Kingston Futures Pty Ltd v Waterhouse [2013] 1 QdR 507 at [19].Was the application for review made by the company? The answer is not entirely clear. Ordinarily, the company would be the applicant. But here, the company was deregistered. Moreover, the Crocker’s names appeared under the heading “Applicant”.