Abbott Builders (Qld) Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Abbott Builders (Qld) Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2025] QCAT 144

PARTIES:

ABBOTT BUILDERS (QLD) PTY LTD

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NOS:

GAR367-19; GAR499-19; GAR003-20

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

28 April 2025

HEARING DATE:

20 January 2025

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Chapple

ORDERS:

1.   GAR367-19: The Direction to Rectify decision is amended as follows:

a.   For the conceded items, to omit direction items, DTR 15 and 52.

b.   For direction item, DTR 4, to read:

The installation of the James Hardie soffit is not consistent with the proper usage of the Inex Maxideck decking and the doorways onto the three decks are void of flashings.

2.   GAR499-19: The Unsatisfactory Work decision is amended as follows:

a.   For the conceded items, to omit the references to unsatisfactory rectification work in respect of direction items, DTR 13, 47 and 49.

b.   To omit the references to unsatisfactory rectification work in respect of direction items, DTR 1, 2, 9, 10, 14, 22, 26, 27, 30, 35, 39, 43 and 45.

3. GAR499-19: The Unsatisfactory Work decision in respect of direction item, DTR 23 is set aside, and the matter is returned to the QBCC for reconsideration with the direction that the property’s stormwater drainage system be reinspected to ascertain the existence of a second stormwater line at the time of the decision.

4.   GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision is amended as follows:

a.   For the conceded items, to omit scope of work items, SOW 8, 22, 23, 24 and 25.

b.   For SOW 3 in respect of direction item, DTR 4, to read:

·     Install flashing to the openings around the doorways onto the three decks in accordance with Clauses 2.2.2 and 3.5.3.6 of the National Construction Code.

·     In relation to the three decks:

o   Remove the James Hardie soffit.

o   Install perforated steel sheeting on the underside of the decking in accordance with the construction contract.

o   Apply rust-resistant paint to the steel joists supporting the decking in accordance with the corrosion protection requirements of the National Construction Code.

c.   To omit SOW 7 in respect of direction item, DTR 14.

d.   To omit SOW 12 in respect of direction item, DTR 24.

5.   GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision for SOW 5 in respect of direction item, DTR 10 is confirmed.

6. GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision for SOW 11 in respect of direction item, DTR 23 is set aside, and the matter is returned to the QBCC for reconsideration with the direction that the property’s stormwater drainage system be reassessed to ascertain the existence of a second stormwater line at the time of the decision.

7.   GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision for SOW 17 in respect of direction item, DTR 39 is confirmed.

8.   GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision for SOW 19 in respect of direction item, DTR 43 is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abbott Builders (Qld) Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Cons... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCAT 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Abbott Builders (Qld) Pty Ltd brought applications for review of decisions of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) regarding directions to rectify, unsatisfactory work, and scope of works. The QBCC had issued a direction to rectify for certain items of unsatisfactory work and a scope of works decision in relation to the construction of a residential building. Abbott contested the decisions, arguing that certain aspects of the QBCC's findings were incorrect or not supported by evidence. The QBCC conceded certain items, but contested the remainder of the review applications. The key legal issues the court needed to decide related to whether the decks were Class 1a or Class 10a buildings under the National Construction Code, and whether the QBCC's decisions regarding the direction to rectify, unsatisfactory work, and scope of works were supported by evidence and reasonable.

The court found that the decks were Class 10a buildings, not Class 1a as the QBCC had argued. The court accepted Abbott's evidence that the Inex Maxideck product used for the decking was intended for external use and was only moisture resistant, not waterproof. The QBCC had not provided sufficient evidence to rebut Abbott's evidence on this point. The court also found that the QBCC's decisions regarding the direction to rectify, unsatisfactory work, and scope of works were not fully supported by evidence in certain respects. The court amended and set aside parts of the QBCC's decisions and returned certain matters to the QBCC for reconsideration.

The final orders of the court were to amend and set aside parts of the QBCC's direction to rectify, unsatisfactory work, and scope of works decisions, and to return certain matters to the QBCC for reconsideration with directions to reassess the property's stormwater drainage system.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. GAR367-19: The Direction to Rectify decision is amended as follows:

a. For the conceded items, to omit direction items, DTR 15 and 52.

b. For direction item, DTR 4, to read:

The installation of the James Hardie soffit is not consistent with the proper usage of the Inex Maxideck decking and the doorways onto the three decks are void of flashings.

2. GAR499-19: The Unsatisfactory Work decision is amended as follows:

a. For the conceded items, to omit the references to unsatisfactory rectification work in respect of direction items, DTR 13, 47 and 49.

b. To omit the references to unsatisfactory rectification work in respect of direction items, DTR 1, 2, 9, 10, 14, 22, 26, 27, 30, 35, 39, 43 and 45.

3. GAR499-19: The Unsatisfactory Work decision in respect of direction item, DTR 23 is set aside, and the matter is returned to the QBCC for reconsideration with the direction that the property’s stormwater drainage system be reinspected to ascertain the existence of a second stormwater line at the time of the decision.

4. GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision is amended as follows:

a. For the conceded items, to omit scope of work items, SOW 8, 22, 23, 24 and 25.

b. For SOW 3 in respect of direction item, DTR 4, to read:

· Install flashing to the openings around the doorways onto the three decks in accordance with Clauses 2.2.2 and 3.5.3.6 of the National Construction Code.

· In relation to the three decks:

o Remove the James Hardie soffit.

o Install perforated steel sheeting on the underside of the decking in accordance with the construction contract.

o Apply rust-resistant paint to the steel joists supporting the decking in accordance with the corrosion protection requirements of the National Construction Code.

c. To omit SOW 7 in respect of direction item, DTR 14.

d. To omit SOW 12 in respect of direction item, DTR 24.

5. GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision for SOW 5 in respect of direction item, DTR 10 is confirmed.

6. GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision for SOW 11 in respect of direction item, DTR 23 is set aside, and the matter is returned to the QBCC for reconsideration with the direction that the property’s stormwater drainage system be reassessed to ascertain the existence of a second stormwater line at the time of the decision.

7. GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision for SOW 17 in respect of direction item, DTR 39 is confirmed.

8. GAR003-20: The Scope of Works decision for SOW 19 in respect of direction item, DTR 43 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I note the following items have been conceded by the QBCC:(a)The DTR decision in respect of DTR 15 and 52.(b)The USW decision relating to unsatisfactory work in respect of DTR 13, 47 and 49.(c)The SOW decision relating to SOW 8, 22, 23, 24 and 25.Statements of evidence Mr Wayne Steven Abbott is a director of Abbott, and Mr Ron Paterson is a project manager employed by Abbott. Mr John Reeve is a director of Professional Certification Group and a level 2 building certifier retained by Abbott to assess the certification requirements for the construction of the new home at the property. Mr Andrew Stephen Kirby is a senior building inspector employed by the QBCC who was allocated responsibility for assisting in these applications in December 2024. The original investigation was conducted by another building inspector for the QBCC, Mr Robert Murphy, who left the employ of the QBCC in mid-2023. In respect of each of the review applications, Abbott relies on the following statements of evidence:GAR367-19: DTR decision(a)Statement of evidence of Wayne Steven Abbott dated 17 April 2023 (‘SOE: DTR Abbott’).(b)Statement of evidence of Ron Paterson dated 17 April 2023 (‘SOE: DTR Paterson 1’).(c)Statement of evidence of Ron Paterson dated 12 March 2024 (‘SOE: DTR Paterson 2’).(d)Statement of evidence of John Reeve 19 April 2024 (‘SOE: DTR Reeve’).GAR499-19: USW decision(e)Statement of evidence of Wayne Steven Abbott dated 17 April 2023 (‘SOE: USW Abbott’).(f)Statement of evidence of Ron Paterson dated 17 April 2023 (‘SOE: USW Paterson’).GAR003-20: SOW decision(g)Statement of evidence of Wayne Steven Abbott dated 17 April 2023 (‘SOE: SOW Abbott’).(h)Statement of evidence of Ron Paterson dated 17 April 2023 (‘SOE: SOW Paterson’).All applications(i)Statement of evidence of Ron Paterson dated 16 January 2025 (‘SOE: ALL Paterson’). In respect of all of the review applications, the QBCC relies on the statement of evidence of Andrew Stephen Kirby dated 10 January 2025 (‘SOE: QBCC Kirby’).Consideration I am assisted by the parties’ submissions as follows:(a)Written Submissions of the Applicant dated 17 January 2025.(b)Commission’s Outline of Submissions dated17 January 2025.(c)Applicant’s Further Submissions on Bedroom 2 Wall dated 31 January 2025.(d)Commission’s Post-Hearing Submissions dated 31 January 2025.DTR 4: DTR + SOW 3 decisions The DTR decision described the item 4 defect as follows:The construction detail of the decks, the installation of the decking material and openings to all 3 external decks are defective and not in compliance with the National Construction Code 2016 Volume 2 – Clauses P2.2.2 & 3.5.3.6, in that the openings onto the decks (doorways) are void of flashings, deck substrate (Inex-Maxideck) is allowing moisture to penetrate the decks which has resulted in the deterioration of the building elements. The SOW decision described the item 3 scope of works as follows:·Allow to disassemble all decks, reuse balustrading, joist where applicable.·Remove sliding doors that open onto decks and supply and install a compliant flashing/sub-sill to openings – reinstall sliding doors.·Reinstate/construct decks as per working drawings ensuring compliant stepdown at openings and adequate fall is achieved.·Supply and install Maxideck as per manufacturers recommendations.·Reinstall balustrading.·Paint and make good all affected surfaces.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In respect of all of the review applications, the QBCC relies on the statement of evidence of Andrew Stephen Kirby dated 10 January 2025 (‘SOE: QBCC Kirby’).Consideration I am assisted by the parties’ submissions as follows:(a)Written Submissions of the Applicant dated 17 January 2025.(b)Commission’s Outline of Submissions dated17 January 2025.(c)Applicant’s Further Submissions on Bedroom 2 Wall dated 31 January 2025.(d)Commission’s Post-Hearing Submissions dated 31 January 2025.DTR 4: DTR + SOW 3 decisions The DTR decision described the item 4 defect as follows:The construction detail of the decks, the installation of the decking material and openings to all 3 external decks are defective and not in compliance with the National Construction Code 2016 Volume 2 – Clauses P2.2.2 & 3.5.3.6, in that the openings onto the decks (doorways) are void of flashings, deck substrate (Inex-Maxideck) is allowing moisture to penetrate the decks which has resulted in the deterioration of the building elements. The SOW decision described the item 3 scope of works as follows:·Allow to disassemble all decks, reuse balustrading, joist where applicable.·Remove sliding doors that open onto decks and supply and install a compliant flashing/sub-sill to openings – reinstall sliding doors.·Reinstate/construct decks as per working drawings ensuring compliant stepdown at openings and adequate fall is achieved.·Supply and install Maxideck as per manufacturers recommendations.·Reinstall balustrading.·Paint and make good all affected surfaces. At the outset, I note the QBCC’s post-hearing submissions in relation to this issue. I consider the issue of whether the decks are Class 1a or Class 10a buildings is a threshold issue of fact I am required to determine by reference to the National Construction Code and other relevant publicly available documents, an analysis of which is set out in these reasons. It was open to the QBCC to include in its post-hearing submissions further submissions supporting their claims regarding the building classification of the decks. I do not consider the issue to be a matter of opinion, for example, of Mr Reeve, and therefore do not accept the QBCC has been disadvantaged in any way by not having the opportunity to cross-examine Mr Reeve. I reject the QBCC’s submission that the Tribunal ought to give no weight to Abbott’s submission about the building class of the decks. I summarise Abbott’s evidence as follows:(a)Prior to entering into the construction contract, the homeowner stipulated to Mr Paterson the installation of Inex Maxideck for the decking on all three decks, a product the homeowner had researched for this purpose.[13][13]SOE: ALL Paterson, para 4a.(b)Inex Maxideck is made up of 2700 mm x 600 mm sheeting of a composite fibro with a woodgrain stain-like finish depending on the chosen paint colour. The sheeting interlocks and an inex bond sealant is used to seal the joints when used in wet areas.[14][14]Ibid.(c)The Maxideck product is intended to be external and to deal with exposure to weather. The manufacturer’s product and installation guides state that the product is water resistant not waterproof. The product has since been withdrawn from the market.[15][15]SOE: DTR Paterson 2, para 14.(d)Abbott subcontracted a carpenter to install the Maxideck product and provided the relevant installation manual to them. The carpenter had not seen or used the product before.[16](e)While on site during the fixing stage of the contract, Mr Paterson received a verbal request from the homeowner that the underside of the deck be sheeted with a 4.5 mm James Hardie soffit, a fibre-reinforced cement sheet painted on-site, to match the office area adjacent to the large front deck, for a more appealing finish than the perforated steel sheeting specified in the specifications. The soffit material did not change the use of the under-croft area. Mr Paterson had no reason to believe the installation of the soffit material would negatively impact the Inex Maxideck.[17] (f)The soffit material and installation were a variation, though there was no additional documentation.[18](g)The provision in the specifications for perforated steel sheeting on the underside of the deck meant that the steel joists supporting the deck would not be enclosed and would require rust-resistant paint to comply with the corrosion protection requirements of the National Construction Code. As a result of the homeowner’s requested variation to the soffit material, the steel joists were enclosed and the National Construction Code 2016 – Building Code of Australia (‘the NCC’) requirements did not apply.[19](h)In relation to the QBCC site report noting a slight step down from the finished floor level to deck level (approx. 10-15 mm) when working drawings specify 40 mm, Mr Abbott and Mr Paterson were present when, during inspection, the QBCC inspector did not measure the step down. In Mr Abbott’s presence, Mr Paterson measured the step down at 40 mm. The homeowner has acknowledged a 30-40 mm step down. There is no Australian Standard requirement for a step down, however Mr Abbott and Mr Paterson acknowledge that it is good building practice.[20](i)In relation to the DTR defect that the doorways onto the decks are void of flashings, water ingress into the dwelling is not the issue. There has been no water ingress into the dwelling or any such complaint.[21] The dwelling is fully sealed and there is a gap between the dwelling and the decking such that there can be no water ingress caused by the absence of flashing on the door. The water issue relates to the soffit beneath the Inex Maxideck, in that it is the recess between the decking and the soffit that is alleged to be accumulating moisture.[22](j)The water damage only relates to the rear deck evidenced by small amounts of mould on the underside of the soffit.[23](k)The use of Maxideck prevents a waterproof membrane from being installed. In accordance with the Australian Standard for waterproofing of external decks, AS 4654.2-2012, a decking material would need to be installed under the Maxideck and waterproofed, however, the fixing of the Maxideck would penetrate the waterproof membrane, thus allowing water to penetrate the enclosed soffit. As the Maxideck is only moisture resistant, the soffit needs to be removed.[24](l)The soffit should be removed in accordance with Mr Reeve’s advice and the steel members should be treated in accordance with the NCC coating to external steel. This would enable the Inex Maxideck product to remain and would eliminate the water into the patio ceiling. This would have achieved the desired outcome without the enormous expense that would be incurred by removing and reinstalling all of the decking.[25][16]SOE: ALL Paterson, para 4c.[17]Ibid, para 16; SOE: ALL Paterson, paras 4b, 4e.[18]SOE: ALL Paterson, para 4f.[19]SOE: ALL Paterson, paras 12b, 12c.[20]SOE: DTR Abbott, paras 17-20; SOE: DTR Paterson 1, paras 15-18.[21]SOE: DTR Abbott, paras 15, 16; SOE: DTR Paterson 1, paras 13, 14.[22]Ibid, paras 7, 8.[23]Ibid, para 10a.[24]SOE: DTR Reeve, paras 9, 10.[25]SOE: ALL Paterson, para 9.