Abram v A.V. Jennings Ltd No. Scciv-02-488

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

DAVID ABRAMS & ANOR v A V JENNINGS

[2002] SASC 417

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Mullighan and Besanko JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:          I would dismiss the appeal.  I agree with the reasons given by Besanko J.  There is nothing that I wish to add to his reasons.

  2. MULLIGHAN J:               I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by Besanko J.

  3. BESANKO J:         This is an appeal from a decision of a Judge of the District Court.

  4. The plaintiff brought an action against the defendants for damages for the wrongful repudiation of a building contract dated 11 November 1998.  The Judge held that the defendants had repudiated the contract in April 1999, that the plaintiff had accepted the repudiation and that the plaintiff had suffered loss and damage as a result of the defendants’ conduct.  He entered judgment in favour of the plaintiff against the defendants in the sum of $39,447.50 plus interest.

  5. The defendants appeal to this Court.  The first defendant is Mr David Abram and the second defendant is Abram Admin. Services Pty Ltd.  The defendants put three principal arguments on the appeal.

  6. First, the defendants submitted that the Judge erred in holding that both defendants were parties to the contract.  They submitted that the Judge should have held that the contract was between the plaintiff and Abram Admin. Services Pty Ltd.  Mr Abram was not a party to the contract and he was not liable in damages to the plaintiff.

  7. Secondly, the defendants submitted that the contract was subject to the defendants obtaining finance.  Under the contract, if they did not obtain finance they had the right to cancel the contract.  The Judge erred in finding that the condition relating to finance had been satisfied.  The Judge should have found the condition had not been satisfied and the defendants had the right, which they exercised, to cancel the contract for non-fulfilment of the condition relating to finance.

  8. Thirdly, and in the alternative to the second argument, the defendants submitted that the contract contained a provision which gave the defendants the right to terminate the contract in the event that the plaintiff encountered subsurface obstructions in the course of carrying out the early stages of the contract.  The contract provided that if the defendants exercised the right to terminate the contract for this reason then the plaintiff’s claim was limited to certain items of loss specified in clause 9.2 of the contract.  The defendants submitted that the Judge erred in failing to hold that the defendants had exercised the right to terminate the contract under this clause.  The Judge noted that the loss under clause 9.2 was $18,644.08.

    The Facts and the Judge’s Findings

  9. The relevant events occurred between October 1998 and April 1999 and the following statement of the facts relates to that period.

  10. The plaintiff is a large building company operating in South Australia.  It has display homes located throughout the State.  Prospective purchasers inspect the homes and then enter into…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abram v A.V. Jennings Ltd No. Scciv-02-488 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 417
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Abram v A.V. Jennings Ltd involved a dispute between the plaintiff, Mr David Abram, who was acting on behalf of Abram Admin. Services Pty Ltd, and the defendant, A.V. Jennings Ltd, a building company. The primary issue at hand was whether the defendants had the right to terminate the contract and the implications of such a termination under the terms of the agreement. This case was heard in the Supreme Court.

The legal issues that the court needed to address included whether the defendants had valid grounds to terminate the contract, particularly in light of subsurface obstructions encountered by the plaintiff during the early stages of the contract. Additionally, the court had to determine if the defendants had correctly exercised their right to terminate the contract and if the plaintiff's claim for damages was correctly assessed according to the terms stipulated in clause 9.2 of the contract. The court also had to consider whether the repudiation of the contract by the defendants was valid and whether the plaintiff had accepted this repudiation.

In its reasoning, the court examined the terms of the contract and the conduct of the parties involved. The court found that the defendants' letter dated 1 April 1999 constituted a clear repudiation of the contract, which was accepted by the plaintiff. The court also noted that the defendants had not correctly exercised their right to terminate the contract under the specified clause. The court determined that the defendants' actions did not align with the conditions set out in the contract for termination due to subsurface obstructions. Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal, finding that the plaintiff's claim for damages should not have been limited to the amount specified in clause 9.2.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal brought by the defendants, A.V. Jennings Ltd, was to be dismissed. The court did not find merit in any of the arguments presented by the defendants, thereby upholding the plaintiff's right to seek full compensation for the losses incurred as a result of the contract termination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thirdly, and in the alternative to the second argument, the defendants submitted that the contract contained a provision which gave the defendants the right to terminate the contract in the event that the plaintiff encountered subsurface obstructions in the course of carrying out the early stages of the contract. The contract provided that if the defendants exercised the right to terminate the contract for this reason then the plaintiff’s claim was limited to certain items of loss specified in clause 9.2 of the contract. The defendants submitted that the Judge erred in failing to hold that the defendants had exercised the right to terminate the contract under this clause. The Judge noted that the loss under clause 9.2 was $18,644.08.The Facts and the Judge’s Findings The relevant events occurred between October 1998 and April 1999 and the following statement of the facts relates to that period. The plaintiff is a large building company operating in South Australia. It has display homes located throughout the State. Prospective purchasers inspect the homes and then enter into negotiations with the plaintiff. A contract is signed based on standard plans and specifications with such variations as are agreed between the parties. Preliminaries to construction, such as the obtaining of relevant approvals, including building approval, are then sought and obtained. Once these matters are attended to, construction commences. Throughout the process the parties may agree to variations to the contract. Between October 1998 and April 1999, Mr David Abram represented himself and Abram Admin. Services Pty Ltd. He had contact with a number of employees of the plaintiff who represented the plaintiff at various stages of the process. Mr Brian Chant, a salesman employed by the plaintiff, had contact with the defendants in October and November 1998. He is no longer employed by the plaintiff. He was not called as a witness by the plaintiff. No explanation was provided for his absence from the witness box. Mr Robert Howarth, a customer service officer employed by the plaintiff, had contact with the defendants from approximately the date upon which the contract was signed (11 November 1998) to the commencement of work on site in March 1999. He was called as a witness by the plaintiff and the Judge found that he presented in a very honest and straightforward way. Ms Marina Mendolia, a customer service officer employed by the plaintiff, had contact with the defendants in March and April 1999. She was called as a witness by the plaintiff and the Judge found that she also presented in a very honest and straightforward way. Mr Abram is an accountant who practises in the Salisbury area. He is married to Mrs Debbie Abram and at the relevant time they lived at 6 Brackenmoor Close, Hillbank. At the relevant time, Mr Abram was the sole director and sole company secretary of Abram Admin. Services Pty Ltd. That company was the trustee of Abram Admin. Services Trust. The trust carries on what Mr Abram described as a service trust operation for his professional practice.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that the letter from the defendants dated 1 April 1999 constituted a repudiation of the contract which was accepted by the plaintiff.Conclusion In my opinion, all of the arguments raised on the appeal fail and the appeal should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.