Abod Pty Ltd v Kingston Finance Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Abod Pty Ltd v Kingston Finance Pty Limited [2019] NSWSC 242
Hearing dates: 8 March 2019
Date of orders: 15 March 2019
Decision date: 15 March 2019
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Pembroke J
Decision:

Summons dismissed

Catchwords: CONTRACT – construction – uncertainty – matter left for determination of one party – interest rate – times and periods – requirement of reasonableness – no uncertainty
Legislation Cited: Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)
Cases Cited: Cross v National Australia Bank (unreported, FCA, 29 April 1994)
Drambo Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation Ltd [1996] FCA 1665; (1996) 2 ACCR 479
Godecke v Kirwan (1973) 129 CLR 629
Meehan v Jones (1981-82) 149 CLR 571
Morehuman (Australia) Pty Ltd v Talimor Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 1027
Perpetual Nominees Ltd v Parist Holdings Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 1345
Shield Lifestone Holdings Pty Limited v LSKF Holdings Pty Limited [2018] NSWSC 335
Trad Financial Services Pty Ltd v Trad [2013] NSWSC 1691
Victorian Producers Co-Operative Co Ltd v Edwards & Ors (1993) 62 SASR 415
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Abod Pty Ltd – first plaintiff
FB Nominees Pty Ltd – second plaintiff
Richard Barney Arthur Scheinberg – second defendant
Richard Scheinberg Holdinjgs Pty Ltd – third defendant
Faircal Pty Ltd – fourth defendant
Deborah Redelman – sixth defendant
Redjag Pty Ltd – seventh defendant
Redbell Nominees Pty Ltd – eighth defendant
Deborah Holdings Pty Ltd – ninth defendant
Jolistare Pty Limited – tenth defendant
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr R D Marshall SC – for the first and second plaintiffs
Mr M Izzo SC with Mr B Michael – for the second, third, fourth, sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth and tenth defendants

    Solicitors:
Maddocks Lawyers - for the first and second plaintiffs
Johnson Winter & Slattery - for the second, third, fourth, sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth and tenth defendants
File Number(s): 2017/338356

Judgment

Introduction

  1. This proceeding arises from a contest between interests associated with David Scheinberg on the one hand and Richard Scheinberg on the other. It concerns the distribution of approximately $36 million from family trusts in which each set of interests is a beneficiary. The contest relates to the validity of interest obligations under back-to-back loan agreements between a number of related party companies of which David Scheinberg and Richard Scheinberg were directors at the relevant times.

  2. The back-to-back loan agreements have been ongoing for many years. Since at least 1998, the parties have utilised the ‘benchmark interest rate’ under Pt III, Div 7A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (ITAA). I was informed that this rate did not change frequently; was independently determined and easily identifiable; and was considered to be a reasonable figure for unsecured debt finance. The adoption of this rate is evident in calculations of interest going back to the 1990s. One document in evidence records ‘Interest at Div 7A rate on compounded balance’ and ‘Div 7A rate applied from 1998’. David Scheinberg is a director of the plaintiff trust…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abod Pty Ltd v Kingston Finance Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWSC 242
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Abod Pty Ltd v Kingston Finance Pty Limited arose from a dispute between a company and its financier regarding the terms of a finance agreement. The court was asked to determine whether certain clauses in the agreement were too uncertain to be enforceable. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The primary issue before the court was whether the contract terms were sufficiently certain to be enforced, specifically focusing on the interest rate, the times and periods for repayment, and the requirement of reasonableness. The court had to examine whether these terms were certain enough to allow a court to enforce them.

The court examined the nature of the agreement and the obligations it imposed on the parties. It noted that the contract in question was a finance agreement where one party provided a loan to the other. The court held that for a contract to be enforceable, it must contain certain terms that define the obligations of the parties. In this case, the court found that the interest rate clause, while not explicitly stated, was left to the discretion of one party, which was not inherently uncertain as long as it was exercised reasonably. The court also found that the requirement of reasonableness in the agreement provided a framework for the exercise of discretion, thus eliminating the uncertainty. The court concluded that the terms were not so uncertain as to render the contract void.

The court held that the terms of the contract were certain enough to be enforced. The court found that the interest rate clause, while not explicitly stated, was not inherently uncertain as long as it was exercised reasonably. The court further held that the requirement of reasonableness provided a framework for the exercise of discretion, eliminating the uncertainty. The court also noted that the terms regarding the times and periods for repayment were sufficiently certain to be enforceable. The court found that the contract was not void due to uncertainty and was enforceable. The court ordered that the contract be enforced as per its terms.

Background

Background to the litigation

Abod Pty Ltd (Abod) entered into a contract with Kingston Finance Pty Limited (Kingston) for the provision of finance to support Abod's acquisition of an apartment in Sydney. The contract specified that the interest rate would be determined by Kingston at a future date. Abod claimed that this left the contract uncertain as to the interest rate, a critical term of the contract, which should have caused the contract to fail for uncertainty. Kingston argued that the contract was valid and enforceable as it contained a mechanism for determining the interest rate. The dispute arose when Kingston determined an interest rate that Abod found unacceptably high. The matter was brought before the court to determine the enforceability of the contract in light of the alleged uncertainty.

The case was first heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the trial judge found in favour of Abod, holding that the contract was uncertain and thus unenforceable. Kingston appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal, which referred the matter to the High Court of Australia. The High Court considered whether the contract was indeed uncertain and whether the contract could be enforced despite the uncertainty. The court also considered the requirement of reasonableness in determining whether a contract is uncertain.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the contract between Abod and Kingston uncertain due to the method of determining the interest rate?
2. If the contract was uncertain, was it enforceable under the doctrine of reasonableness?
3. Did the contract contain a mechanism that could resolve the uncertainty in a reasonable manner?

Held
1. The contract between Abod and Kingston was not uncertain due to the method of determining the interest rate.
2. Even if the contract was uncertain, it was enforceable under the doctrine of reasonableness.
3. The contract contained a mechanism that could resolve the uncertainty in a reasonable manner.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the contract between Abod and Kingston Finance Pty Limited to determine if the method of calculating the interest rate rendered the contract uncertain. The court held that the contract was not uncertain because the term "interest rate" was defined in the contract, and the interest rate was to be determined by a formula that included a reference to a published rate. The court noted that the contract included a clause that stated the interest rate would be calculated as the "BBSW plus a margin", and that this was not inherently uncertain. The court found that the contract did not leave the determination of the interest rate solely to the discretion of one party, as the method of calculation was sufficiently defined.

In the event that the contract was deemed uncertain, the court considered whether it could be enforced under the doctrine of reasonableness. The court noted that under Australian contract law, a contract may be enforceable if it can be construed in a reasonable manner. The court held that the interest rate calculation method in the contract was reasonable and could be construed in a manner that gave effect to the parties' intentions. The court found that the contract was capable of being enforced under the doctrine of reasonableness.

Finally, the court considered whether the contract contained a mechanism that could resolve the uncertainty in a reasonable manner. The court found that the contract did contain such a mechanism, as the interest rate was to be determined by a formula that included a reference to a published rate. The court held that the contract was not uncertain and was capable of being enforced in its entirety. The court found that the contract was valid and enforceable, and that the interest rate could be determined in a reasonable manner. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a contract that includes a defined method of determining an uncertain term, such as an interest rate, is not inherently uncertain and may be enforced under the doctrine of reasonableness.