Abacus Engineering Limited v John Cananzi and Cananzi Hydropneumatics

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

In the Matter of the Patents Act 1952

‑ and ‑

In the Matter of an Application for Restoration of Patent No. 494746 by ABACUS

ENGINEERING LIMITED

‑ and ‑

In the Matter of a Notice of Opposition thereto by JOHN CANANZI and CANANZI HYDROPNEUMATICS

‑ and ‑

In the Matter of an Objection to said Notice of Opposition.

DECISION OF AN ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS.
        An application under section 97 of the Act for the restoration of patent No. 494746 by Abacus Engineering Limited was advertised in the Official Journal on 4 November, 1982.   On 4 February, 1983 the Patent Office received what purported to be a Notice of Opposition from Cleary, Ross & Doherty, solicitors, acting on behalf of John Cananzi and Cananzi Hydropneumatics.   In a subsequent letter dated 16 February, 1983, Edwd. Waters & Sons, Patent Attorneys for Abacus Engineering Limited, informed the Commissioner that they objected to the alleged Notice of Opposition.   The relevant part of this letter reads as follows:

"It is our respectful submission that the letter of 4th February from Messrs. Cleary, Ross & Doherty which purports to be Notice of Opposition is not in substantial compliance with Form 12 in the First Schedule to the Patents Regulations.   In this respect, we simply draw attention to Regulation 90 which, whilst not insisting upon strict

compliance with the aforesaid Schedule, does clearly nonetheless call for substantial compliance.   If our sub‑

missions are to be upheld, and it is respectfully suggested that the Office cannot really do otherwise, then it necessarily follows that the Notice of Opposition of 4th February must in effect be treated as null and void and so the opposition accordingly quashed."

A hearing to determine the issue "that the Notice of Opposition of 4 February must be treated as null and void" took place in Canberra on 29 March, 1983.   Abacus Engineering Limited was represented by Mr. W. Dancer, Patent Attorney, of Edwd. Waters & Sons; Mr. G. Johnson, instructed by Cleary Ross & Doherty, solicitors, appeared on behalf of John Cananzi and Cananzi Hydro‑
pneumatics.
        The alleged Notice of Opposition which is the subject of the objection took the form of a letter, reproduced as follows:

"4th February, 1983

The Registrar of Patents,

Patents Sub‑office,

150 Lonsdale Street,

,3000

Dear Sir,

Re: Application for renewal of Patent No. 494746

We advise that we act on behalf of John Cananzi and Cananzi Hydropneumatics Pty Ltd both of 285 Somerset Road, Campbell‑ field.   Our clients wish to give notice of opposition to Application for the restoration of the abovementioned trade mark.   The grounds of the objection are as follows:

A.The omission to pay the prescribed fee was not unintentional;

B.Undue delay had occurred in the making and prosecution of the application for restoration;

C.The Restoration of the patent would be improper and would be injurious to the opponents and to the public;

D.The said letters patent are and were at the date of the Applications invalid.

We note that the appropriate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abacus Engineering Limited v John Cananzi and Cananzi Hydrop... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1983] APO 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Abacus Engineering Limited applied for the restoration of Patent No. 494746 under section 97 of the Patents Act 1952. John Cananzi and Cananzi Hydropneumatics opposed this application. The dispute reached the Assistant Commissioner of Patents, who was required to determine whether the Notice of Opposition submitted by Cananzi and Cananzi Hydropneumatics was valid and complied with the necessary legal requirements. The key legal issues involved were whether the Notice of Opposition was substantially compliant with the prescribed form and whether it was effectively delivered to the patent attorneys representing Abacus Engineering Limited.

The Assistant Commissioner examined the form and substance of the Notice of Opposition, noting several discrepancies from the prescribed Form 12. Despite these discrepancies, the Commissioner relied on previous judicial decisions that emphasised the importance of substantial compliance over strict adherence to prescribed forms. The Commissioner found that the Notice of Opposition was intended to be such and was recognisable as such by the Patent Office and the opposing party’s attorneys. The Commissioner also dismissed objections related to the form’s specific requirements, such as the absence of stated facts about the opponent's interest and the failure to serve a copy of the Notice on the opposing party’s attorneys. The Commissioner concluded that these issues did not render the Notice of Opposition null and void. The Commissioner awarded costs against Abacus Engineering Limited for their unsuccessful objection.

In summary, the Assistant Commissioner ruled that the Notice of Opposition was valid despite its non-compliance with certain formal requirements, provided it substantially communicated the intent to oppose. The decision underscored the principle of substantial compliance with procedural forms in patent opposition proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.