210 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Ellinson & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE
COMMON LAW DIVISION
PROPERTY LIST

S ECI 2022 05081

BETWEEN:

210 HAWTHORN ROAD PTY LTD Plaintiff
v 
MEGAN ELLINSON & ORS
(according to the attached Schedule)
Defendants

---

JUDGE:

Ierodiaconou AsJ

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

28 and 29 November 2023

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

28 February 2024

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

210 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Ellinson & Ors

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2024] VSC 61

---

REAL PROPERTY — Application to modify a restrictive covenant — Application to modify a restrictive covenant preventing more than one dwelling on the land to permit up to five dwellings on the land — Where applicant seeks to make comparison with construction plans that are yet to commence —Where applicant seeks to make comparison with local council approved construction plans versus proposed construction plans — Where applicant’s plans are contingent on financial circumstances — Where amenity of the covenant relates to density of neighbourhood — Significance of a cul-de-sac off an arterial road with tram route and commercial shopping strip — Plaintiff fails to establish that modification to the restrictive covenant will not cause substantial injury to the beneficiaries of the covenant — Hermez v Karahan [2012] VSC 443 —Prowse v Johnstone [2012] VSC 4 — Vrakas v Registrar of Titles [2008] VSC 281 — Jiang v Monaygon Pty Ltd [2017] VSC 591 — 196 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Duszniak [2020] VSC 235 — Jeshing Property Management Pty Ltd & Bao v Yang & Ors [2023] VSCA 185 —Property Law Act 1958 (Vic) s 84(1)(c).

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr M Townsend of counsel S & K Planning Lawyers
The First Defendant  Mr D Epstein of counsel
The Second Defendant in person 
Third Defendant  No appearance
The Fourth Defendant in person

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Summary.............................................................................................................................................. 1

Evidence............................................................................................................................................... 1

The covenant and the subject land................................................................................................. 4

Plaintiff’s plans for the subject land........................................................................................... 9

Plaintiff’s submissions................................................................................................................... 11

Defendants’ submissions............................................................................................................... 16

Applicable principles...................................................................................................................... 20

How should the comparative assessment be undertaken?...................................................... 22

Has the plaintiff established there will be no substantial injury if the covenant is modified? 24

Conclusion......................................................................................................................................... 34

HER HONOUR:

  1. The plaintiff, 210 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd, is the registered proprietor of 1A Walworth Avenue, Caulfield North (the ‘subject land’).  The subject land is a large residential block on the corner of Walworth Avenue and Hawthorn Road.

  1. The plaintiff seeks the modification of a restrictive covenant on the subject land. The covenant restricts the number of dwellings to one private dwelling house (the ‘covenant’). There is currently a single dwelling on the subject land. The plaintiff intends to build five dwellings on the land as part of a larger development spanning neighbouring lots of land owned by the plaintiff on Hawthorn Road. The plaintiff’s application is made pursuant to s 84(1)(c) of the Property Law Act 1958 (the ‘Act’). 

  1. Initially, eight parties lodged their objection to the proposed modification of the covenant and were joined as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 210 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Ellinson & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] VSC 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Victoria, the case of 210 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Ellinson & Ors involved an application by the plaintiff to modify a restrictive covenant that limited the number of dwellings on the property to one. The defendant opposed the application, arguing that any alteration to the covenant would cause substantial injury to the covenant beneficiaries. The primary focus of the dispute was whether the proposed modification, which would allow up to five dwellings, would harm the covenant's purpose of maintaining neighbourhood density and amenity.

The central legal issues revolved around the assessment of whether the proposed modification to the restrictive covenant would substantially injure the beneficiaries. The court needed to consider the nature of the covenant, the proposed changes, and their potential impact on the surrounding area's character and residents. The plaintiff's arguments hinged on the comparison between the local council's approved construction plans and the proposed construction plans, which were yet to commence. Additionally, the court had to evaluate the relevance of a cul-de-sac off an arterial road with a tram route and commercial shopping strip to the covenant's purpose.

The Supreme Court held that the plaintiff had not demonstrated that the modification to the restrictive covenant would not cause substantial injury to the beneficiaries. The court found that the proposed increase in the number of dwellings would significantly affect the neighbourhood's density and character, which were central to the covenant's purpose. The plaintiff's comparison to the council-approved plans did not adequately address the potential impact of the proposed construction, particularly as it was contingent on future financial circumstances. The court relied on several precedents, including Hermez v Karahan, Prowse v Johnstone, Vrakas v Registrar of Titles, Jiang v Monaygon Pty Ltd, and 196 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Duszniak, which underscored the importance of preserving the covenant's intended benefits. The decision also considered Jeshing Property Management Pty Ltd & Bao v Yang & Ors, which further highlighted the criteria for modifying restrictive covenants under the Property Law Act 1958 (Vic) s 84(1)(c).

The court dismissed the plaintiff's application to modify the restrictive covenant. It was ordered that the covenant remain in its original form, preventing more than one dwelling on the property. The court's ruling emphasised the need to protect the covenant's purpose, particularly in a neighbourhood with specific character and density considerations.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established