196 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Duszniak

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

PROPERTY LIST

S ECI 2018 01724

196 HAWTHORN ROAD PTY LTD Plaintiff
v
KRYSTYNA DUSZNIAK & ORS
(according to the attached schedule)
Defendants

---

JUDGE:

Lansdowne AsJ

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

15 August 2019; further submissions to 24 September 2019.

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

1 May 2020

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

196 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Duszniak

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2020] VSC 235

---

REAL PROPERTY – Restrictive covenant – Preliminary questions relating to proper construction of covenant – Not to erect any building other than one private dwelling house of stated minimum cost without the consent in writing of the transferor – Transferor now deceased – Whether power to consent applied only to cost restriction – Whether restrictions became absolute or spent on death of the transferor – Principles of construction considered – Barport Pty Ltd v Baum [2019] VSCA 167 – Admissibility of evidence of the existence and content of other covenants imposed by the transferor in relation to the purpose of the restrictions – Westfield Management Limited v Perpetual Trustee Company Limited (2007) 233 CLR 528; Prowse v Johnston & Ors [2012] VSC 4; Suhr v Michelmore [2013] VSC 284; Clare v Bedelis [2016] VSC 381 – Consideration of previous decisions – Bell v Norman C. AshtonLtd (1956) 7 P & CR 359; In Re Beechwood Homes Ltd application [1994] 2 EGLR 178; Briggs v McCusker [1996] 2 EGLR 197; Crest Nicholson Residential (South) Ltd v McAllister [2003] All ER 46; Margerison v Bates [2008] 3 EGLR 165; Churchill v Temple [2011] 1 EGLR 73; Woodhouse v Woodhouse [2010] UKUT 235 (LC) – Restrictions held to become absolute on death of transferor – Property Law Act 1958 (Vic) s 84(2).

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr M Townsend Tisher Liner FC Law
For the First, Second and Third Defendant Ms T Acreman
For the Sixth and Seventh Defendants Mr Harold Shafer, by leave

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction........................................................................................................................................ 1

The Covenant...................................................................................................................................... 2

Legal principles.................................................................................................................................. 6

Submissions...................................................................................................................................... 16

Issues.................................................................................................................................................. 20

Consideration.................................................................................................................................... 21

Plaintiff’s evidence...................................................................................................................... 22

A conditional contract or a dispensing power?...................................................................... 24

Does the dispensing power apply to the single dwelling restriction?................................ 25

Effect of Ms Langdon’s death.................................................................................................... 26

Textual indications............................................................................................................ 27

Purpose of the Covenant.................................................................................................. 29

Evidence of other covenants............................................................................................ 31

Consideration of other aspects of context...................................................................... 40

Previous decisions............................................................................................................. 42

Australian cases................................................................................................................. 43

English authorities............................................................................................................. 46

Conclusion and orders.................................................................................................................... 51

HER HONOUR:

Introduction

  1. The plaintiff is the registered proprietor of two parcels of adjoining land, at 196 and 198 Hawthorn Road, Caulfield North.  The plaintiff already holds a planning permit to construct seven apartments on 196 Hawthorn Road, but now wishes to construct an apartment building across the two parcels, containing 16 apartments.  A potential barrier to that endeavour is the covenant on the title to the land at 198 Hawthorn Road (‘Land’), which may contain a single dwelling restriction.  In this proceeding, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 196 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Duszniak and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] VSC 235
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Victoria, the case of 196 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd v Duszniak was heard. The plaintiff, 196 Hawthorn Road Pty Ltd, sought a declaration that a restrictive covenant in relation to the defendant's property had become absolute, and therefore enforceable, following the death of the transferor. The covenant in question prohibited the erection of any building other than a private dwelling house of a stated minimum cost, without the written consent of the transferor. The defendant, Duszniak, argued that the power to consent was limited to the cost restriction and that the restrictions should be deemed spent following the transferor's death. The court was required to determine the proper construction of the covenant and whether it became absolute or spent on the transferor's death.

The court examined the principles of construction and the relevant case law. It considered the authorities which suggested that the power to consent was limited to the cost restriction, and those which indicated that restrictions become absolute on the transferor's death. The court also examined the admissibility of evidence of other covenants imposed by the transferor and whether it was relevant to the purpose of the restrictions. The court had to balance the competing principles of construction and determine whether the restrictions had become absolute or had lapsed on the transferor's death.

The court held that the restrictions had become absolute on the transferor's death. It found that the power to consent was not limited to the cost restriction and that the restrictions applied to the entire prohibition on the erection of any building other than a private dwelling house of a stated minimum cost. The court considered the relevant provisions of the Property Law Act 1958 (Vic) and concluded that the restrictions were not spent but had become absolute and enforceable against the defendant. The court's reasoning was based on a detailed analysis of the language of the covenant, the principles of construction, and the relevant case law.

The court made a declaration that the restrictive covenant had become absolute on the death of the transferor and was enforceable against the defendant. The court also made orders for costs and directed the parties to bear their own costs of the proceedings. The decision provides useful guidance on the construction of restrictive covenants and the effect of the death of the transferor on their enforceability.