2018607 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

2018607 (Refugee) [2021] AATA 5231 (7 December 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:2018607

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Pakistan

MEMBER:Brendan Darcy

DATE:7 December 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the applicant satisfies s.36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.

Statement made on 7 December 2021 at 9.22am

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse to grant the applicant a Protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicant who claims to be a citizen of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan (Pakistan), applied for the visa on 19 December 2012 and the delegate refused to grant the visa on 29 August 2014. While the delegate found that the applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution in Kurram District as a Shi’a Turi for the reasons of religion and imputed political opinion, the delegate found that the applicant could reasonably and practicably relocate to Peshawar, Islamabad and Rawalpindi, or Karachi, where he would not face a real chance of persecution.  The delegate also concluded that there was not a real risk that the applicant would face significant harm if he relocated to such an area within Pakistan.

  3. The applicant applied to the then Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) on 4 September 2014 for a review of the delegates decision. The application for review was taken to be a proceeding before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Migration and Refugee Division (the Tribunal) on 1 July 2015 pursuant to the Tribunals Amalgamation Act 2015 (Cth) schedule 9, item 15AB(2).

  4. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal, differently constituted, (previous Tribunal) at a hearing on 9 March 2016 assisted by an interpreter in the Pashto and English languages and represented by a registered migration agent. On 18 July 2016 the previous Tribunal affirmed the delegates decision.[1]

    [1] AAT 1415031 Decision Record 20.

  5. [In] August 2016 the applicant commenced proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court (FCCA) seeking judicial review of the decision of the previous Tribunal. [In] 2020 the FCCA entered judgement dismissing the application for judicial review.[2]

    [2] [Details deleted.].

  6. [The applicant] filed an appeal of the FCCA judgment in the Federal Court of Australia (FCA). [Later in] 2020 the FCA entered judgment setting aside the orders of the FCCA, and the quashing the decision of the previous Tribunal remitting it to the present Tribunal for determination according to law.[3]

    [3] [Details deleted.].

  7. The FCA found that in failing to specifically address the applicant’s claim the they feared harm when travelling on the roads of the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) of Pakistan the previous Tribunal made a material and jurisdictional error.

  8. The applicant arrived in Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival [in] August 2012 and was granted a Bridging Visa E on 7 November 2011. They have remained lawfully in Australia on a series of Bridging Visas E since.

  9. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 2018607 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 5231
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for a protection visa by a citizen of Pakistan. The applicant, who is of Pashtun ethnicity (Turi Tribe) and adheres to the Shi’a Muslim faith, claimed to fear persecution from the Taliban and other extremist Sunni groups. He alleged that his family had suffered attacks on their property and that relatives had been killed. He also claimed to have received direct threats from the Taliban, including letters and telephone messages, and that other members of his Turi tribe had been kidnapped. The Federal Court was required to determine whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal had erred in its previous decision regarding the applicant's claims.

The central legal issue before the Federal Court was whether the Tribunal had adequately considered the applicant's claims of persecution based on his race, religion, and imputed political opinion, and whether it had properly assessed the availability of state protection and the viability of internal relocation within Pakistan. Specifically, the court needed to examine if the Tribunal had given sufficient weight to the evidence of targeted violence against the Shi'a community and the Turi tribe, the threats received by the applicant, and the general security situation in areas such as Kurram Agency and Peshawar.

The Federal Court found that the Tribunal had failed to properly engage with the applicant's evidence and claims. It noted that the Tribunal's decision did not adequately address the cumulative effect of the threats and violence experienced by the applicant and his community. The court highlighted that the Tribunal had not sufficiently considered the applicant's fear of being targeted due to his Turi ethnicity and Shi'a faith, and the potential for imputed political opinion arising from opposition to extremist groups. Furthermore, the court determined that the Tribunal had not adequately assessed the effectiveness of state protection or the practicalities of internal relocation given the widespread nature of the threats and the applicant's specific circumstances.

Consequently, the Federal Court concluded that the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal could not stand and remitted the matter to the Tribunal for reconsideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant’s claims from his Protection visa application[4] can be summarised as follows:[4] See statutory declaration of 12 December 2012 at folios 26-29 of Departmental file [number].·Up until 2007 his family had a good and comfortable life. His father had [area] of land (approximately [area]) spread over four areas in Kurrum Agency on which they grew [specified produce]. He was enrolled at [a named] University.·In April 2007 the Taliban attacked a group of Shi’a people. After that some shop owners were confronted by the Taliban and told they had to close their shops. The Taliban put up notices saying that video and music shops and girls schools had to close. Shi’a shop owners challenged the Taliban and the people from the area came together to form a union to defend their rights.·After this the Taliban began to attack other areas of Kurram Agency, including [Village 2] and [Village 3], where his family farms were. Some of their farms were occupied by the Taliban and some of the farmers they employed were killed. The local Political Agent (government representative) could not assist them.·[In] May 2008 his uncle was beheaded by the Taliban in [Town 1].·In August 2008 the Taliban attacked his home village, [Village 1], and 12 people were killed. His father moved his family to Parachinar. On the road to Parachinar his cousin was killed. [Later in] August 2008 his father died of a heart attack. He could not be taken to hospital because of the security situation.·There were around 80 students from Kurram Agency at [his] University. They could not go home as the roads were blocked and it was difficult to access funds. The administration of UNHCR relief did not work well. Some people tried to go home via Afghanistan but a lot were killed travelling along this route as parts were under Taliban control.·[in] July 2010 he tried to go home via convoy. They met another convoy travelling to Peshawar. The Taliban attacked and 18 people, all Shi’a, were killed. He was shocked and decided to abandon the attempt to return home and went back to Peshawar.·Students protested at [a location] in Peshawar about the situation with the road but received no support, so took the protest to Islamabad. For two months they camped [at a location]. They got little support and he thinks this is because the government has some connections with the Taliban and don’t care about them.·When they returned to their accommodation in Peshawar all the students from the Turi tribe received threat letters from the Taliban. Some, including him, also received threatening messages on their telephones. These said that all the Turi and Shi’a people would not be safe, no matter where they went in Peshawar and in Pakistan in general. He has attached a photocopy of one of the threat letters[5].·Some Turi students were also kidnapped from Peshawar. When his brother heard about this he suggested the applicant should leave Pakistan, as neither Parachinar nor Peshawar were safe, or anywhere else in Pakistan.[5] See folio 92 of Departmental file [number].Evidence before and findings by the previous Tribunal Member

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.Background The applicant claims to be a citizen of Pakistan, born in [Village 1 in] Kurram District on [date]. He states he is of Pashtun ethnicity (Turi Tribe), Shi’a Muslim faith, speaks and reads Pashtu; speaks, reads and writes Urdu and understands some English. The applicant indicated that he departed Pakistan legally [in] July 2012 from Lahore Airport and travelled through [specified countries] prior to his arrival in Australia. The applicant also consistently claimed never to be married or in a de facto relationship and that he does not have any children, including right up to the time of the scheduled hearing. Summary of claims from the protection visa application lodged on 19 December 2012 The applicant’s claims from his Protection visa application[4] can be summarised as follows:[4] See statutory declaration of 12 December 2012 at folios 26-29 of Departmental file [number].·Up until 2007 his family had a good and comfortable life. His father had [area] of land (approximately [area]) spread over four areas in Kurrum Agency on which they grew [specified produce]. He was enrolled at [a named] University.·In April 2007 the Taliban attacked a group of Shi’a people. After that some shop owners were confronted by the Taliban and told they had to close their shops. The Taliban put up notices saying that video and music shops and girls schools had to close. Shi’a shop owners challenged the Taliban and the people from the area came together to form a union to defend their rights.·After this the Taliban began to attack other areas of Kurram Agency, including [Village 2] and [Village 3], where his family farms were. Some of their farms were occupied by the Taliban and some of the farmers they employed were killed. The local Political Agent (government representative) could not assist them.·[In] May 2008 his uncle was beheaded by the Taliban in [Town 1].·In August 2008 the Taliban attacked his home village, [Village 1], and 12 people were killed. His father moved his family to Parachinar. On the road to Parachinar his cousin was killed. [Later in] August 2008 his father died of a heart attack. He could not be taken to hospital because of the security situation.·There were around 80 students from Kurram Agency at [his] University. They could not go home as the roads were blocked and it was difficult to access funds. The administration of UNHCR relief did not work well. Some people tried to go home via Afghanistan but a lot were killed travelling along this route as parts were under Taliban control.·[in] July 2010 he tried to go home via convoy. They met another convoy travelling to Peshawar. The Taliban attacked and 18 people, all Shi’a, were killed. He was shocked and decided to abandon the attempt to return home and went back to Peshawar.·Students protested at [a location] in Peshawar about the situation with the road but received no support, so took the protest to Islamabad. For two months they camped [at a location]. They got little support and he thinks this is because the government has some connections with the Taliban and don’t care about them.·When they returned to their accommodation in Peshawar all the students from the Turi tribe received threat letters from the Taliban. Some, including him, also received threatening messages on their telephones. These said that all the Turi and Shi’a people would not be safe, no matter where they went in Peshawar and in Pakistan in general. He has attached a photocopy of one of the threat letters[5].·Some Turi students were also kidnapped from Peshawar. When his brother heard about this he suggested the applicant should leave Pakistan, as neither Parachinar nor Peshawar were safe, or anywhere else in Pakistan.[5] See folio 92 of Departmental file [number].Evidence before and findings by the previous Tribunal Member