2011397 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

2011397 (Refugee) [2024] AATA 3912 (29 June 2024)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REPRESENTATIVE:  Ms Noeline Harendran

CASE NUMBER:  2011397

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Sri Lanka

MEMBER:Deputy President J.L Redfern PSM

DATE:29 June 2024

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Protection visa.

Statement made on 29 June 2024 at 5.25pm

CATCHWORDS
REFUGEE – protection visa – Sri Lanka – separate, inter-related applications by brothers – irregular maritime arrival – applicant teen dependant of young adult brother – protection visa application refused and affirmed, then remitted by Federal Court – while judicial review in progress, minister lifted s 48B bar and applicant applied for safe haven visa – applicant’s two reviews and brother’s one heard together – ethnicity and political opinion – Tamil – father a senior member of LTTE, who disappeared, suspected kidnapped and presumed dead – applicants assisted with smuggling weapons and spying – questioning, harassment and threats to applicants and mother, attempted kidnapping of brother, and arrest of mother – late claims as stateless ‘gypsy’ caste originating in India and that all identity documentation not genuine – unregistered with limited access to schooling and government services, societal discrimination and mistreatment by authorities – circumstances of interviews, applications and statements –amendments to legislation after first application made have no practical effect for stateless applicants – attendance at commemorative events in Australia – mental health – wife and child who is claimed to be stateless – returned failed asylum seeker – late evidence and submissions, and conduct during hearings – dialect and interpretation – country information and expert evidence – citizenship – child of unknown parentage deemed to be citizen until contrary proven – opportunities to register after civil war ended – prevalence of false documents – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5(1), 5H(1)(a), 5J(1), 36(2)(a), (aa), (2A), 46A(2), 48A, 48B, 65, 91R, 91S, 423A, 424AA

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2

CASES

MIMA v Haji Ibrahim [2000] HCA 55; (2000) 204 CLR 1

SZTAL v MIBP [2017] HCA 34

SZUNZ v MIBP [2014] FCCA 2256; (2015) 230 FCR 272

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependants.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse to grant the applicant a Protection visa under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. [The applicant] first made an application for a protection visa on 20 September 2012. This application was refused. The former Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) conducted a review and affirmed the decision of the delegate. Following numerous applications for judicial review, the decision of the Tribunal was withdrawn and the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 2011397 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3912
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned separate, inter-related applications for protection visas by two brothers, who arrived in Australia as irregular maritime arrivals from Sri Lanka. The applicant was a teenage dependant of his young adult brother. The applications had a complex procedural history, including previous refusals, affirmations, and remissions by the Federal Court. While judicial review was ongoing, the Minister lifted the s 48B bar, allowing the applicant to apply for a Safe Haven Enterprise visa. The Tribunal heard the applicants' two reviews and the brother's one review together.

The core legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the applicants had a well-founded fear of persecution or a real risk of significant harm if returned to Sri Lanka, and whether they met the criteria for complementary protection. This involved assessing claims related to their Tamil ethnicity, political opinions stemming from their father's suspected LTTE links and subsequent disappearance, their alleged involvement in smuggling weapons and spying, and the resulting harassment, threats, and attempted kidnapping directed at them and their mother. Further issues included the applicants' late claims of statelessness due to their 'gypsy' caste, the genuineness of their identity documentation, societal discrimination, and the impact of legislative amendments on their stateless status. The Tribunal also considered the prevalence of false documents in Sri Lanka, the applicants' attendance at commemorative events in Australia, their mental health, and the circumstances of their interviews and submissions.

The Tribunal reasoned that a person outside their country of former habitual residence must demonstrate a well-founded fear of persecution or a real risk of significant harm to satisfy the relevant tests. It clarified that the correct approach is to consider the hypothetical possibility of what would happen if the applicants were to return, rather than whether they could physically return. The Tribunal noted that statelessness alone is insufficient to attract refugee status or complementary protection. In assessing the claims, the Tribunal considered the most recent DFAT report, a COISS report on the [Caste] community, and other country information. The Tribunal also took into account Ministerial Direction No. 84, the 'Refugee Law Guidelines', and the 'Complementary Protection Guidelines'. The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants rely on the most recent DFAT report and other country information and reports, the details which are set out later in these reasons.BACKGROUND [The applicants] left Sri Lanka by boat in early May 2012. They arrived in Australia as irregular maritime arrivals [in] May 2012. On arrival they were detained on Christmas Island then transferred to [City] where they were both interviewed by an immigration officer. The interviews were conducted on 16 June 2012 with the assistance of an interpreter in the Tamil language. According to the typewritten entry interviews, a copy of each brother’s national identity card and birth certificate were provided to the Department prior to the entry interview. At the time of interview, [the applicant’s brother] was [more than 18] years old, and [the applicant] was [less than 18] years old. Their city of birth was recorded as [Village 1], [District] in the Northwestern Province of Sri Lanka and their address was noted as [Division], [Village 1], [District] Northwestern Province. It was recorded that [the applicant’s brother] attended the [High School 1] from [Year] to [Year] with the primary level of schooling and [College 1] – [City] from [Year] to [Year] and [College 2] [District], from [Year] to [Year] for secondary schooling, with the final year in approximately May 2012 at [High School 2] to study A-levels. It was recorded in [the applicant’s brother]’s entry interview that he worked in [work sectors 1-3] from [Year] to May 2012 and in [work sector 4] up until May 2012. [The applicant] was listed as a family member in his care, and it was noted that [the applicant’s brother] had been financially responsible for his mother and siblings since his father had been kidnapped. In response to the question of why [the applicant’s brother] left Sri Lankan, it was noted that [the applicants] were the only two boys left in the family and they had tried to kidnap [the applicant’s brother]. It was noted that the CID would come to their house and ask about [the applicant’s brother]. It was difficult for his mother to take care of him and his brother and this is why they left. [The applicant’s brother] also told the interviewing officer that the ‘grease devils’ came to their house carrying guns and knives. His mother had organised for them to leave Sri Lanka by boat, but he did not know whether she had paid any money. In [the applicant]’s entry interview it is recorded that [the applicant’s brother] was his guardian. It was noted that the original national identity card and birth certificate was with his mother in Sri Lanka. It was also recorded that [the applicant] had attended secondary school from [Year] to [Year], being [Village 2] School], [Village 1] (given [the applicant]’s age at this time the reference to ‘secondary’ school may be a typographical error) and the [Location 1, Village 2] Tamil High School] from [Year] to 2012. His employment was recorded as [work sectors 1-3] and, in particular, working on a [workplace]. Like [the applicant’s brother], it was noted that he did odd jobs such as [job task]. The response to the question of why he had left Sri Lanka was consistent with the information provided by [the applicant’s brother] in his entry interview.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the end of the hearing, the applicants were directed to provide any further submissions by close of business on 24 June 2024. No directions had been made about the filing of further evidence. Despite these directions, further evidence was served after the last hearing and documents, and email submissions, were lodged on or after 24 June 2024.EVIDENCE Outline of evidence by [the applicant] The evidence before the Tribunal comprised a statutory declaration dated 20 September 2012 provided by [the applicant] in relation to his previous application for a protection visa, and statutory declarations dated 1 September 2023 and 8 January and 8 May and 17, 18 and 24 June 2024. [The applicant] also gave oral evidence at the hearings. Because of the changes in [the applicant]’s claims since 2012 and the claims of both applicants are said to corroborate each other’s claims, it is important to carefully examine the evidence that he has provided. In his statutory declaration of 20 September 2012, [the applicant] stated that he was a [Age]-year-old male born in [Village 1], [District] district, North-western province Sri Lanka. His ethnicity is Tamil and he is a Hindu. He travelled to Australia by boat with his older brother. His father is missing and his mother and [sister] are living in Sri Lanka. He left Sri Lanka in approximately May 2012 with his brother as his life was in danger at the hands of the Sri Lankan army, the CID and other members of the authorities. He came to Australia for the same reasons as his older brother did. His father was a fisherman and went missing along with other fishermen in their area in [Year] when they went to work. They did not return home. They have not heard from their father since then. He believed that because the war between the Sri Lankan Army and the LTTE was happening at that time, his father must have been taken by the CID or the Sri Lankan Army on suspicion that he was an LTTE member. This is what other villages were saying at the time. After his father went missing, they began to be harassed by the Sri Lankan Army and the CID. He was young at the time and could not remember anything, although, he did know that the CID and Sri Lankan Army continued to look for him and his brother. They would regularly come to their house to look for them. They were concerned that he and his brother will inform someone of what they did to his father. Because his brother was older than him, his brother had no option but to flee. If [the applicant] had stayed in Sri Lanka, he would have been pursued because he would then have been the oldest son present in the house at the time. The CID and the Sri Lankan Army would be angry that his brother had escaped. They had been harassing them on many instances and damaged their house. If he had stayed it would have been worse for him that is why he fled with his brother. He cannot relocate to another area of Sri Lanka as he would have to live in an Sinhalese area and people would know from his name and language that he was at Tamil and would inform on him. He was concerned that he would be harmed and mistreated by the Sri Lankan Army, the CID and the police and that he would be tortured and killed if he returned. This is because he is his father’s son. [The applicant] also raised concerns that he was a young Tamil male, and he believes that he will be targeted and suffer ongoing persecution.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A person outside the country of former habitual residence with no right to return must also have a well-founded fear of persecution or real risk of significant harm in order to satisfy the relevant tests. It is noted, and this is supported by the authorities, that the correct approach is to consider the hypothetical possibility of whether the applicant has a well-founded fear of being persecuted on the basis of what would happen if they were to return to their country of former habitual residence, not whether they could return there. As such, statelessness alone is not sufficient to attract refugee status or complementary protection.[4][4] Refer Refugee Law Guide, Chapter 2 and the authorities cited.Mandatory considerations In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.84, made under s 499 of the Act, the Tribunal has taken account of the ‘Refugee Law Guidelines’ and ‘Complementary Protection Guidelines’ prepared by the Department of Home Affairs, and country information assessments prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration. The most recent country information report prepared by DFAT is the report dated 2 May 2024 (the 2024 DFAT Report). Following new claims made by the applicants in relation to their [Caste] heritage, the Tribunal obtained a report from the Country of Origin Information Services Section (COISS) of the Department of Home Affairs dated 6 December 2023 (the COISS Report on the [Caste] community). This report relies on source documents, including academic articles published in journals, publicly available articles and online media articles. Both reports, and many of the articles, were provided to the applicants prior to the hearing. The applicants rely on the most recent DFAT report and other country information and reports, the details which are set out later in these reasons.BACKGROUND [The applicants] left Sri Lanka by boat in early May 2012. They arrived in Australia as irregular maritime arrivals [in] May 2012. On arrival they were detained on Christmas Island then transferred to [City] where they were both interviewed by an immigration officer. The interviews were conducted on 16 June 2012 with the assistance of an interpreter in the Tamil language. According to the typewritten entry interviews, a copy of each brother’s national identity card and birth certificate were provided to the Department prior to the entry interview. At the time of interview, [the applicant’s brother] was [more than 18] years old, and [the applicant] was [less than 18] years old. Their city of birth was recorded as [Village 1], [District] in the Northwestern Province of Sri Lanka and their address was noted as [Division], [Village 1], [District] Northwestern Province. It was recorded that [the applicant’s brother] attended the [High School 1] from [Year] to [Year] with the primary level of schooling and [College 1] – [City] from [Year] to [Year] and [College 2] [District], from [Year] to [Year] for secondary schooling, with the final year in approximately May 2012 at [High School 2] to study A-levels. It was recorded in [the applicant’s brother]’s entry interview that he worked in [work sectors 1-3] from [Year] to May 2012 and in [work sector 4] up until May 2012. [The applicant] was listed as a family member in his care, and it was noted that [the applicant’s brother] had been financially responsible for his mother and siblings since his father had been kidnapped. In response to the question of why [the applicant’s brother] left Sri Lankan, it was noted that [the applicants] were the only two boys left in the family and they had tried to kidnap [the applicant’s brother]. It was noted that the CID would come to their house and ask about [the applicant’s brother]. It was difficult for his mother to take care of him and his brother and this is why they left. [The applicant’s brother] also told the interviewing officer that the ‘grease devils’ came to their house carrying guns and knives. His mother had organised for them to leave Sri Lanka by boat, but he did not know whether she had paid any money.