1927296 (Migration) [2021] AATA 5523 (18 February 2021)
DECISION RECORD
DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division
CASE NUMBER:1927296
MEMBER:Christopher Smolicz
DATE:18 February 2021
PLACE OF DECISION: Adelaide
DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision not to cancel the applicant’s Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa.
Statement made on 18 February 2021 at 3:28 pm
CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – cancellation – Return (Residence) (Class BB) visa – Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) – incorrect information in the visa application – previous application for refugee status – applicant known by another name – Forensic Facial Image Examination – false Amayesh registration card purchased in Iran – fear of persecution – treatment of Afghan refugees in Iran – decision under review set aside
Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 378 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information.
STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS
APPLICATION FOR REVIEW
This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel the applicant’s Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa under s.109(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).
Background
The applicant arrived in Australia [in] October 2010 as an Irregular Maritime Arrival (IMA). He identified himself as [applicant’s name], an Afghan national of Shia religion and Hazara ethnicity born on [DOB 1]. He claimed to be born stateless in Afghanistan, have not been known by other names and have not previously applied for refugee status or a protection visa. He has [number] children. Two of his children ([Child A] and [Child B]) were born to his second wife [Ms B] who died 14 years ago (in 1997) after giving birth to [Child B]. He provided his past addresses, employment history and family composition. He also claimed he fled Afghanistan for Iran with his family in 2010 after being threatened due to ongoing land disputes, and feared harm in Afghanistan by the Taliban as a Hazara Shia and being perceived as co-operating with the government.
On 26 October 2011 he was granted a Subclass 866 (Protection) visa. On 26 April 2019 he was granted a Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa.
A forensic facial comparison conducted by the Department of Home Affairs (the Department) disclosed that the applicant had applied on 10 October 2005 for a Refugee and Offshore Humanitarian (Subclass 202) – Global Special Humanitarian visa (GSH visa) from Iran using the identity of [Alias A] ([DOB 2]). The application included his wife and [children] and was sponsored by [Relative A] who was identified as the applicant’s [relative] and an Australian citizen. It contained different family composition. The applicant also claimed he left…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read 1927296 (Migration) and more:
The applicant sought review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel his Subclass 155 (Five Year Resident Return) visa under s.109(1) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth). The cancellation was based on allegations that the applicant had provided incorrect information in his visa applications, specifically concerning his identity and family composition, and had previously applied for a visa using a false identity. The applicant had arrived in Australia in 2010 as an Irregular Maritime Arrival and was subsequently granted a Subclass 866 (Protection) visa in 2011.
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were to determine the applicant's correct identity, the reasons for the provision of incorrect information in past applications, and whether the cancellation of his Subclass 155 visa was warranted. This involved assessing the credibility of the applicant's explanations for discrepancies in his personal details and family history provided across various visa applications, including a 2005 application for a Refugee and Offshore Humanitarian (Subclass 202) visa made from Iran under an alias.
The Tribunal found that while the applicant had provided incorrect information in his 2005 visa application, including details about his date of birth and family composition, this was largely due to the circumstances in Iran. The Tribunal accepted that the applicant, as an Afghan refugee in Iran, had purchased a fraudulent "Amayesh" registration card under a false name out of necessity due to the lack of a functioning asylum system and the risks of arbitrary arrest and detention faced by Afghan refugees. The Tribunal also accepted that the applicant's actions in providing false information in the 2005 application were influenced by unscrupulous migration agents in Iran and a genuine fear for his safety and the need to support his family. However, the Tribunal found the applicant's evidence regarding his relationship with a second wife and three children to be inconsistent and lacking credibility, concluding that he had falsely included these children in his Protection visa application. Despite these findings of non-compliance, the Tribunal considered the applicant's circumstances, including his persecution as a Hazara Shia in Afghanistan, the cultural importance of family, and his positive standing within the Hazara community in Australia.
The Tribunal set aside the decision under review. It found that while the applicant had provided incorrect information in the 2005 application, this was done under duress and necessity in Iran, and that his subsequent applications, particularly the 2011 Protection visa application, contained correct information regarding his identity and reasons for seeking protection. The Tribunal concluded that the non-compliance in the 2005 application should not lead to the cancellation of his Subclass 155 visa, given the context and the applicant's subsequent conduct.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to cancel the applicant’s Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa under s.109(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).Background The applicant arrived in Australia [in] October 2010 as an Irregular Maritime Arrival (IMA). He identified himself as [applicant’s name], an Afghan national of Shia religion and Hazara ethnicity born on [DOB 1]. He claimed to be born stateless in Afghanistan, have not been known by other names and have not previously applied for refugee status or a protection visa. He has [number] children. Two of his children ([Child A] and [Child B]) were born to his second wife [Ms B] who died 14 years ago (in 1997) after giving birth to [Child B]. He provided his past addresses, employment history and family composition. He also claimed he fled Afghanistan for Iran with his family in 2010 after being threatened due to ongoing land disputes, and feared harm in Afghanistan by the Taliban as a Hazara Shia and being perceived as co-operating with the government. On 26 October 2011 he was granted a Subclass 866 (Protection) visa. On 26 April 2019 he was granted a Subclass (155) (Five Year Resident Return) visa. A forensic facial comparison conducted by the Department of Home Affairs (the Department) disclosed that the applicant had applied on 10 October 2005 for a Refugee and Offshore Humanitarian (Subclass 202) – Global Special Humanitarian visa (GSH visa) from Iran using the identity of [Alias A] ([DOB 2]). The application included his wife and [children] and was sponsored by [Relative A] who was identified as the applicant’s [relative] and an Australian citizen. It contained different family composition. The applicant also claimed he left Afghanistan for Iran in 1980 with his family to avoid enlistment and being forced to fight against Afghanistan during the USSR occupation of Afghanistan, and his children were born in Iran. This GSH application was refused on 26 October 2005. Further, the Department’s records indicated that the applicant’s wife applied for a Subclass 202 visa on 17 February 2012 with the applicant as the sponsor, [number] children were listed as dependents, and this application was refused on 6 November 2013. Moreover, the Department’s record indicated that the applicant’s wife and [children] applied for a Partner Subclass 100 visa on 19 September 2012 sponsored by the applicant. On 10 March 2013 the Department requested DNA testing for the children. The applicant responded with a statement declaring that his second claimed marriage didn’t take place, and that [Child B], [Child A] and [Child C] were not his biological children but were orphans that they had been caring for. Integrity checks by the Department confirmed that the applicant fabricated the existence of a deceased second wife and provided a fraudulent death certificate to include these three children as dependents. The applicant withdrew the three children’s applications, and on 13 October 2013 the applicant’s wife and [other] children ([named]) were granted Subclass 100 visas.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
For these reasons, the Tribunal finds that there was non-compliance with s.101(b) by the applicant in the way described in the s.107 notice. Consideration of evidence and claims The applicant has applied for two visas using different identities and providing different evidence in support of each application. The Tribunal must first determine the applicant’s correct identity and why the applicant has provided incorrect information. This makes for a difficult decision. The Tribunal was provided with detailed submissions and country information by the applicant’s migration agent. At the hearing the applicant largely repeated the evidence he provided to the Department in response to the s.107 notice. The Tribunal finds that the applicant provided a credible explanation about his past persecution as a Hazara Shia in Afghanistan, his migration history, illegal status in Iran and the circumstances in which he applied for the GSH visa in 2005 in Iran using a false identity. The Tribunal finds this information was consistent with his Subclass 866 protection visa application. The Tribunal accepts the applicant provided correct information regarding his identity and reasons why he was seeking protection after he arrived in Australia in 2010 and applied for protection. The Tribunal finds that the incorrect information provided by the applicant relating to dates of birth and family composition contained in the 2005 GHS application were based on the Amayesh card which was issued to the applicant in the assumed identity of [Alias A] when he was living in Iran. The Tribunal was referred to the report published by Human Rights Watch (HRW) in 2013. The HRW report confirms that Iran is failing to provide newly arrived asylum seekers access to protection because a functioning asylum system does not exist in Iran and the authorities are subjecting many Afghans to a range of rights abuses including arbitrary arrests and detentions. The report confirms that it has become increasingly difficult for registered Afghan refugees in Iran to retain their refugee status. This has been particularly true since the introduction of periodic registration exercises in 2000 and the establishment of the Amayesh registration system in 2003. The report states that the vast majority of Afghans arriving in Iran since the registration exercise in 2003 have not been allowed to register for an Amayesh card. It is reported that in practice, Amayesh card holders face an increasingly complex and bureaucratic process with the Iranian authorities to retain their status, in which the smallest mistake can result in permanent loss of refugee status. It is reported that Amayesh card holders are regularly required to renew their cards. Since the original registration of several hundred thousand Afghans in 2003, there have been nine re-registration exercises with a different colour card provided each time. The cards, which refugees must pay for, are generally valid for one year. When a card expires the card holder is considered to be unlawfully present in Iran and may be deported. If a card holder fails to register for a new card as soon as the old one has expired, he or she becomes undocumented and is subject to deportation. It is reported that another problem is that Afghans being deported from Iran are given no opportunity to challenge their deportation, such as by explaining that they previously had refugee status but lost it through no fault of their own or that they were prevented from requesting asylum or protection.[2] [2] Human Rights Watch, Unwelcome Guests: Iran's Violation of Afghan Refugee and Migrant Rights, 20 November 2013, ISBN: 978-1-62313-0770, available at: >The Tribunal has had regard to the country information and finds that it is consistent with the applicant’s explanation about why he purchased Amayesh cards in an assumed name.The Tribunal also found the evidence of [Relative A] and [Witness A] to be credible. Both witnesses were born in Afghanistan and lived near the applicant’s home area in Ghazni Province and have known the applicant before he arrived in Australia. They have only known the applicant by the name [applicant’s name]. They know his wife and were able to name his biological children.[Relative A] told the Tribunal that he has known the applicant since he was a young child and they both come from the same tribe. In 2005 he travelled to Iran to get married and the applicant attended his wedding. When he was in Iran he was asked by a number of Afghan families to help them come to Australia because he was an Australian citizen. He was told that all he needed to do was sign some forms. He knew nothing about the visa process and had limited understanding of the English language. He did not turn his mind to the information that was contained in the forms but acted out of loyalty and support for his community. He was aware that the situation for Hazaras was not safe in Iran and agreed to help about five to six Afghan families (including the applicant) and signed a number of forms. He brought the forms back to Australia and lodged them with the Department. He was subsequently contacted by the Department and told the visa applications were refused. He thought that he did what was asked of him and had nothing further to do with the applications. The Tribunal has had regard to [Relative A’s] evidence and finds that it is consistent with the applicant’s explanation that many Afghan refugees were exploited and misled by agents in Iran about their ability to obtain a visa to Australia. The Tribunal accepts the applicant would have had no English language skills and no knowledge of the visa process when he was living in Iran. The Tribunal accepts the applicant would have been guided by the agents in Iran who told him to use the false identity and provided false information in the 2005 GSH application. The Tribunal accepts the agents would have completed visa application forms and the application had little prospects of success. The Tribunal also questioned the applicant about his marriages and family composition. The Tribunal found aspects of his evidence lacking in credibility. The Tribunal finds the applicant provided a family composition table in response to question 9 (Part B Form 866) indicating he had family unit members who were residing outside of Australia at the time of the Subclass 866 visa application. As for those who were included in the family composition, the applicant maintains all members were in fact part of his family unit, including [Ms B], [Child B], [Child A] and [Child C]. He claims [Ms B] was his deceased second wife. He married her in 1997 after her husband passed away as she was a widow with three children and needed support. He claims he had a Nikah with [Ms B] so he could take care of her and her children and married her out of compassion. He claims he supported [Child B], [Child A] and [Child C] as if they were his own children. When [Ms B] died, the three children continued to live with [Ms A] and his biological children. They lived with them up until [Ms A] and his biological children were granted the Partner (Subclass 309) visa and migrated to Australia. He claims he declared [Ms B], [Child B], [Child A] and [Child C] as part of his family unit. It was submitted the children only came into his life after the 2005 GSH application was lodged, which is why they were only declared in the Subclass 866 visa application, 2012 GSH application and partner visa application. The Tribunal does not accept the applicant’s evidence about his relationship with [Ms B] and why he included three orphan children in his Protection visa application. The Tribunal finds the applicant’s evidence inconsistent and lacking in credibility.First, the Tribunal notes the applicant claims he entered into a Nikah with [Ms B] in 1997 because she was a widow caring for three children ([Child B], [Child A] and [Child C]). According to information provided by the applicant in support of his Protection visa application he claims [Ms B] died in 1997 after she gave birth to [Child B]. When questioned at the hearing he claimed [Ms B] died in 2005 or 2006 about six months after they left Afghanistan. When the inconsistency was put to the applicant, he claims it must have been a translating error. The Tribunal notes that the applicant’s statement was prepared with the assistance of his migration agent and translated into English and the applicant has not previously sought to change his evidence. The Tribunal further notes, that according to information on the Department’s file ([deleted]) in Form 47SP [Application for migration to Australia by a partner] at page 7, question 58 the applicant declared that he was previously married to [Ms B] and they had two children together from the relationship. He also provided a death certificate for [Ms B].Second, the Tribunal notes the applicant did not declare [Child B], [Child A] and [Child C] in the offshore GSH visa application made in 2005. He claims this is because the children did not come into his life until after 2005 and that’s why he disclosed them in his Subclass 866 protection visa application. The Tribunal finds this inconsistent with the applicant’s evidence that he treated three children as his own after he entered into a Nikah with [Ms B] in 1997. The Tribunal also notes that according to his evidence his wife and children came to join him in Iran in 2001. Third, the Tribunal notes that the applicant only declared that [Child B], [Child A] and [Child C] were not his biological children after the Department requested DNA evidence. He did not volunteer this evidence. He subsequently withdrew the children from the applications the same day. On 12 March 2013 he provided a statement to the Department referring to the partner visa application. He wrote: I wish to state that some of the information provided in the previous document was not true or correct and I wish this document to set the record straight. I previously stated that I was the father of [number] children, all of whom were included in my application… I wish to advise that three of the claimed [children] were not in fact my biological children but orgphas who my family cared for… [Child B variant], [Child A] and [Child C variant]… I wish to advise these children are not intending to come to Australia and are no longer included in my application.He made no further applications to bring the three children to Australia. The applicant claims he did not know he could make an application to bring in his adopted children to Australia. The Tribunal has given the applicant’s explanation little weight and notes he was represented by a migration agent. The Tribunal finds the applicant’s action in withdrawing the children from the application seems inconsistent with his claims that the children were part of his family unit and he treated the children as his own. The Tribunal does not accept the applicant’s evidence about his relationship with [Ms B] or that he adopted [Child B], [Child A] and [Child C] and they were part of his family unit when he applied for the Protection visa in 2010. The Tribunal finds the applicant falsely included three children in the Protection visa application as members of his family unit. Should the visa be cancelled?As the Tribunal has decided that there was non-compliance in the way described in the notice given to the applicant under s.107 of the Act, it is necessary to consider whether the visa should be cancelled pursuant to s.109(1). Cancellation in this context is discretionary, as there are no mandatory cancellation circumstances prescribed under s.109(2). In exercising this power, the Tribunal must consider the applicant’s response (if any) to the s.107 notice about the non-compliance, and have regard to the following prescribed circumstances set out in r.2.41 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations): s.109(1)(b) and (c). The correct information: The Tribunal finds the applicant provided correct information about his identity and the reasons why he fears persecution in Afghanistan when he applied for the Subclass 866 protection visa.The Tribunal accepts his name is [applicant’s name], Afghan citizen born on [DOB 1] in [Village 2], Ghazni in Afghanistan. In support of this evidence the applicant has provided the Tribunal with a copy of his Afghan passport issued by the Afghan Embassy in Canberra in December 2019. The applicant is of Hazara ethnicity and Shia Muslim religion. The applicant has participated in the visa grant processes with the assistance of interpreters in the Hazaragi language and has the distinct visual features shared by Hazaras. He married [Ms A] in Afghanistan in 1983 and they have [number] children together, namely [names and dates of birth]. The Tribunal finds the applicant initially fled Afghanistan at the height of the Taliban power and resided in Iran from 1998. He was subsequently joined by his family in 2001. The Tribunal finds the applicant purchased an Amayesh card in the name [Alias A]. The Amayesh card contained the real [Alias A’s] name and date of birth among other details. The Tribunal finds that although the applicant held an Amayesh card he did not have a legal basis to reside in Iran because the card was not genuine. On 10 October 2005 the applicant applied for a Refugee and Offshore Humanitarian (Subclass 202) visa from Iran using the identity of [Alias A] ([DOB 2]). The visa was refused, and the family returned to Afghanistan in 2005. The applicant and his family were threatened by the Taliban who were killing Hazara people in Afghanistan. His family were also in danger because the Taliban perceived him to be working for the Afghan government. The family returned to Iran in 2010. The applicant was working in Iran illegally until he was caught by the Iranian authorities and deported to Afghanistan. He subsequently travelled to Quetta, Pakistan and made arrangements to come to Australia.The content of the genuine document (if any): This prescribed circumstance is not relevant in the present case because the s.107 notice relied solely on s.101, not on s.103 (relating to bogus documents).Whether the decision to grant a visa was based, wholly or partly, on incorrect information or a bogus document: The Tribunal finds that the applicant was granted a protection visa in 2011 because there was a real chance he would face significant harm from the Taliban in Afghanistan because of his Hazara race, his Shia religion and his imputed political opinion of being associated with the Afghan government and being anti-Taliban.The Tribunal finds however that had the applicant disclosed correct information, namely that he made an application in 2005 for an Offshore Humanitarian visa using a false identity this may have had an adverse impact on the grant of his Subclass 866 protection visa application when he arrived in Australia. The circumstances in which the non-compliance occurred: The Tribunal accepts the applicant arrived in Australia as an IMA because his life was in danger and he was escaping persecution. The applicant’s non-compliance needs to be seen against the background of the persecution faced by Hazara Shia Muslims in Afghanistan and the lack of a functioning asylum system in Iran. As detailed above HRW report that Afghan asylum seekers in Iran are subjected to a range of rights abuses including arbitrary arrest and detention. They face obstacles in obtaining genuine identity documents and often resort to securing false documents out of necessity and the need for survival. In this regard, the Tribunal is guided by the remarks of Justice O’Bryan’s in BOY19 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection[3] that: honesty and dishonesty are not moral absolutes, and the circumstances in which a lie has been told has a substantial bearing on any perceived moral deficiency. … The moral deficiency (if any) associated with a lie that is told by a person believing that the lie is necessary in order to save the person from abhorrent and unjustified threats to their safety is entirely different to the moral deficiency associated with a lie that is told for the purposes of personal enrichment.[4][3] [2019] FCA 574[4] Ibid at [71]The Tribunal also accepts that the applicant comes from an ethnic and religious minority group that continues to face persecution in Afghanistan. The Tribunal accepts that the applicant’s actions in providing false information were underpinned by a genuine fear of being sent back to Afghanistan and the need to continue to support his family. Country information confirms that family is the single most important aspect of life in Afghanistan. Afghan culture is very collectivistic and people generally put their family’s interests before their own. This means that family responsibilities tend to hold a greater importance than personal needs.[5] The essential role of the family and community networks in providing protection, opportunities and mobility in Afghanistan is well documented.[6] [5] ICG 2009, UNHCR 2010, Still Human Still Here 2012100. The Tribunal accepts that as an Afghan male arriving in Australia by boat the applicant would be subject to a level of cultural and family obligation to assist his family’s future travel to Australia. The Tribunal finds the applicant may have included names of the three children in his application to help other family members or members of his tribe escape persecution. As detailed above, the Tribunal also finds that if he had disclosed, that he had previously applied for a GSH visa in a false identity this may have prevented him from sponsoring his family to Australia.101. The Tribunal also finds the false information provided by the applicant in the 2005 GSH application needs to be seen in the context of the applicant’s background as a person with no formal education with no English language skills. The Tribunal notes that although the applicant was fully aware that his application contained false information, the Tribunal accepts the applicant’s evidence that he and many other Afghan asylum seekers were unduly influenced by unscrupulous “migration agents” in Iran who provided them with false migration advice. In the circumstances the Tribunal accepts that the applicant would have had very little control over what was included in the application.102. The present circumstances of the visa holder: The applicant is [age] years old. He claims he is not able to work due to a back injury and is in receipt of government payments. According to medical reports the applicant’s wife has [a medical condition] and is undergoing treatment. The Tribunal was informed that she was unable to attend the hearing due to her poor health. The Tribunal accepts that the applicant is providing support to his wife during this difficult time. The applicant also spends much of his time caring for his [grandchildren] with whom he has a close relationship. The Tribunal was provided with a number of positive reference letters from Afghan religious leaders and members of the community in Australia. The Tribunal accepts the applicant is an active and respected member of the Hazara community in Australia. 103. The subsequent behaviour of the visa holder concerning his or her obligations under Subdivision C of Division 3 of Part 2 of the Act: Subdivision C of Division 3 of Part 2 of the Act contains the obligations to fill in an application form or passenger card correctly, not to provide bogus documents, to notify of a change in circumstances where this makes an answer incorrect, and to provide particulars of incorrect answers.