1838192 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

1838192 (Refugee) [2019] AATA 6555 (31 July 2019)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1838192

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Pakistan

MEMBER:Brendan Darcy

DATE:31 July 2019

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the applicant satisfies s.36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.

STATEMENT MADE ON 31 JULY 2019 AT 2:25PM

CATCHWORDS
REFUGEE – protection visa – Pakistan – Federal Court remittal – ethnicity – Turi Pashtun – religion – Shia Muslim – fears persecution by Taliban – real chance of serious harm – unreasonable to relocate within home country – state protection severely compromised – limited education – credibility issues – inconsistent evidence – decision under review remitted


LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5, 36, 65, 499
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2


CASES
Kopalapillai v MIMA (1998) 86 FCR 547
MIEA v Guo & Anor (1997) 191 CLR 559
MIMA v Respondents S152/2003 (2004) 222 CLR 1
Randhawa v MILGEA (1994) 52 FCR 437
SZATV v MIAC (2007) 233 CLR 18

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse to grant the applicant a Protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicant, who claims to be a citizen of Pakistan, applied for the visa on 8 November 2012 and the delegate refused to grant the visa on 3 September 2012.

  3. The applicant applied to the former Migration Review Tribunal – Refugee Review Tribunal for review (case number 1313370) and on 24 January 2014 the delegate’s decision to refuse the visa application was affirmed by the Tribunal (differently constituted).

  4. The applicant sought review by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCCA) and on 31 October 2017 his application was dismissed by the Court.

  5. The applicant sought review by the Federal Court of Australia and on 6 December 2018 the first Tribunal’s decision was set aside by the Court.  A consent order made on that date indicates the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error regarding findings about relocation.

  6. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 30 July 2019 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal hearing was conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the Pashto and English languages.

  7. The applicant was represented in relation to the review by his registered migration agent.

    CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

  8. The criteria for a protection visa are set out in s.36 of the Act and Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). An applicant for the visa must meet one of the alternative criteria in s.36(2)(a), (aa), (b), or (c). That is, the applicant is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1838192 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 6555
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a Pakistani national claiming to be an ethnic Turi Pashtun and a Shia Muslim, sought a protection visa. The dispute concerned whether the applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race and religion, and whether Australia owed him protection obligations under the *Refugee Convention*. The matter came before the Tribunal for reconsideration of a delegate's decision.

The Tribunal was required to determine if the applicant met the criteria for a protection visa under s.36(2)(a) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth), specifically whether he was a refugee as defined by Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees. This involved assessing whether the applicant had a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race or religion, and whether he was unable or unwilling to avail himself of the protection of Pakistan due to such fear. The Tribunal also considered whether it would be unreasonable for the applicant to relocate within Pakistan to avoid persecution.

The Tribunal found that the applicant's claims regarding his ethnicity as a Turi Pashtun and his religion as a Shia Muslim were accepted. It concluded that state protection in Pakistan was severely compromised due to factors including tribal justice systems, corruption, lack of resources, and the ongoing extremist threat. The Tribunal was satisfied that the applicant faced a real chance of serious harm based on this combination of ethnicity and religion if he returned to his home area in Kurram District. Furthermore, it determined that relocation to other parts of Pakistan would not be reasonable, as he would still face an appreciable risk of persecution. Consequently, the Tribunal found that the applicant satisfied the refugee criteria and was owed protection obligations under the Convention.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Background The applicant claimed to be born on 20 February 1989 in [village 1], Parachinar in Kurram Agency in Pakistan. The applicant claims to be a citizen of Pakistan. He claims to be an ethnic Pashtun and a follower of the Shia Muslim religion. The applicant claimed on Form 866B that he was unmarried and his family consisted of his mother and father and [a number of] siblings. On 23 July 2019 the applicant’s representative emailed the Tribunal claiming the applicant is now married to [a] woman from his home village of [Village 1], and that his [sibling] [was] killed in Rawalpindi in 2018.[1] The applicant arrived on Christmas Island [August] 2012 as an unauthorised maritime arrival. Since his arrival in Australia the applicant has held [numerous] Bridging E visas (WE-050), the most recent of which ceased on 12 August 2015. The applicant has not been granted any further visas.[1] AAT file 1838192 f.49 The applicant’s claims were detailed in a statutory declaration dated 2 November 2012 accompanying Form 866C.[2] His claims may be summarised as follows:·In Pakistan his life was in danger because the Taliban are targeting Shias;·In 2011 he was kidnapped by the Taliban while travelling to Peshawar;·As a member of the Turi tribe and a Shia he fears harm from the Pashtun Sunni community; and·The authorities in Pakistan cannot protect him because they cannot control the Taliban.[2] Department file [specified] The applicant’s following identity documents were provided to the Department:·ID card;[3]·Pakistani driving licence;[4]·Provisional certificate 2009 [College];[5]·Secondary school [certificate];[6]·Secondary school [certificate];[7]·Secondary school [certificate];[8]·Copy of prior Pakistani passport;[9]·Pakistani character certificate;[10]·Pakistani police clearance certificate;[11] and·Domicile certificate.[12][3] Department file [specified][4] Department file [specified][5] Department file [specified][6] Department file [specified][7] Department file [specified][8] Department file [specified][9] Department file [specified][10] Department file [specified][11] Department file [specified][12] Department file [specified] A copy of the delegate’s decision was submitted to the Tribunal. The delegate accepted that the applicant is a Pashtun, a Turi tribesman from Kurram Agency and a Shia Muslim. The delegate did not accept that the applicant was kidnapped and detained by the Taliban in 2011.[13] While accepting that there is an ongoing risk of harm to the applicant on the basis of his religion as a Shia Muslim in the Kurram Agency, FATA (Federally Administered Tribal Areas) and that he could not access adequate state protection with FATA,[14] the delegate was satisfied that the applicant could relocate within Pakistan and concluded that he is not owed protection obligations.[15] The delegate found that the applicant’s claims that he would be persecuted for his Turi race or for departing Pakistan to be supported.[16][13] AAT file 1313370 f.23[14] AAT file 1313370 f.19[15] AAT file 1313370 f.14-13[16] AAT file 1313370 f.19

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant was represented in relation to the review by his registered migration agent. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The criteria for a protection visa are set out in s.36 of the Act and Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). An applicant for the visa must meet one of the alternative criteria in s.36(2)(a), (aa), (b), or (c). That is, the applicant is either a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under the ‘refugee’ criterion, or on other ‘complementary protection’ grounds, or is a member of the same family unit as such a person and that person holds a protection visa of the same class. Section 36(2)(a) provides that a criterion for a protection visa is that the applicant for the visa is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations under the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (together, the Refugees Convention, or the Convention). Australia is a party to the Refugees Convention and generally speaking, has protection obligations in respect of people who are refugees as defined in Article 1 of the Convention. Article 1A(2) relevantly defines a refugee as any person who:owing to well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country; or who, not having a nationality and being outside the country of his former habitual residence, is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to return to it. If a person is found not to meet the refugee criterion in s.36(2)(a), he or she may nevertheless meet the criteria for the grant of a protection visa if he or she is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection obligations because the Minister has substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to a receiving country, there is a real risk that he or she will suffer significant harm: s.36(2)(aa) (‘the complementary protection criterion’). In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.56, made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal is required to take account of PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines and PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines and any country information assessment prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.CLAIMS FOR CONSIDERATION For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter be remitted for reconsideration. Background The applicant claimed to be born on 20 February 1989 in [village 1], Parachinar in Kurram Agency in Pakistan.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The information about Turis and the applicant’s accepted religious affiliation and practices as a Shia Muslim strongly indicates that state protection is severely compromised in Pakistan due to the predominance in some regions of tribal justice systems, systemic corruption of security and political agencies, an endemic lack of resources for security personnel and the nature of the ongoing extremist threat despite the authorities’ more targeting terrorist groups in Pakistan, such as the TTP. Security for Shia Muslims throughout Pakistan has improved but remains fragile. The Tribunal accepts that police and security forces in Pakistan are ill-equipped to protect Turi Pashtun citizens who are targeted by extremists and others, and that Turi Pashtuns are generally more conspicuous by their religion as Shias and aspects of their ethnicity, such as their accents, than other Shia Pakistanis who are targeted by fundamentalist Sunni militants that hold eliminationist views towards all Shia Muslims. Furthermore, successful prosecution rates are low, which leads to a perception that extremist attackers enjoy immunity from justice, due to resource deficiencies and corruption throughout Pakistan. The level of state protection throughout Pakistan available to the applicant is accordingly not at a level which citizens are entitled to expect according to international standards. Conclusion The Tribunal accepts the applicant has a real chance of serious harm based on his ethnicity as a Turi Pashtun and based on the related Convention based on the applicant’s religion given belonging to the Shia branch of the Islamic religion, if he were to return to his home area of Kurram District in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Having considered the available country information, the Tribunal finds that that it would be unreasonable for the applicant to relocate to any other part of his country of nationality as the applicant will face an appreciable risk of persecution based on the essential and significant reason that the applicant is a Turi Pashtun who is a Shia Muslim. The Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant is unable to avail himself of state protection from persecution in anywhere within Pakistan and that it is not reasonable for him to relocate to other parts of Pakistan to avoid the risk of Convention based persecution that he faces. In conclusion, the Tribunal finds that the applicant satisfies the refugee criteria as the applicant has a real chance of serious harm for the essential and significant reasons based on a combination of his ethnicity and religion, if he were to return anywhere within his country of nationality. The applicant’s fear of persecution is well-founded and he is a refugee who satisfies the criteria under the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees. Accordingly the applicant satisfies s.36(2)(a) of the Act. There is no evidence before the Tribunal to suggest that the applicant has the right to enter and reside in any safe third country for the purposes of s.36(3) of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.56, made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal is required to take account of PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines and PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines and any country information assessment prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.CLAIMS FOR CONSIDERATION For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter be remitted for reconsideration. Background The applicant claimed to be born on 20 February 1989 in [village 1], Parachinar in Kurram Agency in Pakistan. The applicant claims to be a citizen of Pakistan. He claims to be an ethnic Pashtun and a follower of the Shia Muslim religion. The applicant claimed on Form 866B that he was unmarried and his family consisted of his mother and father and [a number of] siblings. On 23 July 2019 the applicant’s representative emailed the Tribunal claiming the applicant is now married to [a] woman from his home village of [Village 1], and that his [sibling] [was] killed in Rawalpindi in 2018.[1] The applicant arrived on Christmas Island [August] 2012 as an unauthorised maritime arrival. Since his arrival in Australia the applicant has held [numerous] Bridging E visas (WE-050), the most recent of which ceased on 12 August 2015. The applicant has not been granted any further visas.[1] AAT file 1838192 f.49 The applicant’s claims were detailed in a statutory declaration dated 2 November 2012 accompanying Form 866C.[2] His claims may be summarised as follows:·In Pakistan his life was in danger because the Taliban are targeting Shias;·In 2011 he was kidnapped by the Taliban while travelling to Peshawar;·As a member of the Turi tribe and a Shia he fears harm from the Pashtun Sunni community; and·The authorities in Pakistan cannot protect him because they cannot control the Taliban.[2] Department file [specified] The applicant’s following identity documents were provided to the Department:·ID card;[3]·Pakistani driving licence;[4]·Provisional certificate 2009 [College];[5]·Secondary school [certificate];[6]·Secondary school [certificate];[7]·Secondary school [certificate];[8]·Copy of prior Pakistani passport;[9]·Pakistani character certificate;[10]·Pakistani police clearance certificate;[11] and·Domicile certificate.[12][3] Department file [specified][4] Department file [specified][5] Department file [specified][6] Department file [specified][7] Department file [specified][8] Department file [specified][9] Department file [specified][10] Department file [specified][11] Department file [specified][12] Department file [specified] A copy of the delegate’s decision was submitted to the Tribunal. The delegate accepted that the applicant is a Pashtun, a Turi tribesman from Kurram Agency and a Shia Muslim. The delegate did not accept that the applicant was kidnapped and detained by the Taliban in 2011.[13] While accepting that there is an ongoing risk of harm to the applicant on the basis of his religion as a Shia Muslim in the Kurram Agency, FATA (Federally Administered Tribal Areas) and that he could not access adequate state protection with FATA,[14] the delegate was satisfied that the applicant could relocate within Pakistan and concluded that he is not owed protection obligations.[15] The delegate found that the applicant’s claims that he would be persecuted for his Turi race or for departing Pakistan to be supported.[16][13] AAT file 1313370 f.23[14] AAT file 1313370 f.19[15] AAT file 1313370 f.14-13[16] AAT file 1313370 f.19