1720890 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

1720890 (Refugee) [2019] AATA 5705 (13 March 2019)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1720890

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Pakistan

MEMBER:Roslyn Smidt

DATE:13 March 2019

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicants Protection visas.

Statement made on 13 March 2019 at 2:33pm

CATCHWORDS
REFUGEE – protection visa – Pakistan – Federal Court remittal – particular social group – middle management staff of specified company – role in retrenchment of employees – failed asylum seeker – religion – Barelvi – Shia surname – Islamic dress code for women – hijab – race – Muhajir – political opinion – anti-Taliban – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 36, 65

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse to grant the applicants Protection visas under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. [The first-named applicant] (applicant A), his wife [the fourth-named applicant] (applicant B) and their two children, who are citizens of Pakistan, applied for the visas on 4 June 2013. The delegate refused to grant the visas on 10 December 2013. This decision was upheld by a differently constituted Tribunal on 15 August 2014. That decision was appealed by the applicants and [in] July 2017 the Federal Court found that the previous Tribunal had failed to give applicant B a fair opportunity to be heard and, as a result applicant A was also denied a fair hearing, in breach of s.425. The decision was remitted for reconsideration.

  3. The applicants appeared before the Tribunal on 23 January 2019 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal hearing was conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the Urdu and English languages.

  4. The applicants were represented in relation to the review by their registered migration agent.

    THE RELEVANT LAW

  5. The criteria for a Protection visa are set out in s.36 of the Act and Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). An applicant for the visa must meet one of the alternative criteria in s.36(2)(a), (aa) (b), or (c). That is, the applicant is either a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under the ‘refugee’ criterion, or on other ‘complementary protection’ grounds, or is a member of the same family unit as such a person and that person holds a Protection visa of the same class.

  6. Section 36(2)(a) provides that a criterion for a Protection visa is that the applicant for the visa is a non-citizen in Australia in respect of whom the Minister is satisfied Australia has protection…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1720890 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 5705
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, a couple and their two children, sought protection visas based on claims of persecution in Pakistan. Applicant A alleged he was at risk due to his role in the management of a company during a strike and subsequent dismissals, his Muhajir ethnicity, his Barelvi Islamic faith, his Shia surname, and imputed anti-Taliban political opinions. Applicant B claimed similar risks due to her association with Applicant A, her Shia surname, her Barelvi religion, and her perceived non-conformity with Islamic norms, particularly regarding dress. The case was heard by Roslyn Smidt.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the applicants faced a real chance of suffering serious or significant harm amounting to persecution in Pakistan for reasons of race (Muhajir ethnicity), religion (Barelvi faith), political opinion (anti-Taliban), or membership of a particular social group. Specifically, the court had to determine if Applicant A's role in company dismissals, his Muhajir background, his Barelvi faith, his Shia surname, or his imputed anti-Taliban views placed him or his family at risk. Additionally, the court considered Applicant B's claims regarding her dress and perceived liberal views, and the potential risks to the children, including abduction and educational disruption.

The court found that Applicant A was not personally of adverse interest to anyone due to his limited involvement in the 2011 dismissals, nor did his Muhajir ethnicity, Barelvi religion, or Shia surname exacerbate any risks. Evidence indicated that while ethnic violence occurred in Karachi, it primarily involved political groups, and the overall violence had declined. The court was not satisfied that the applicants faced a real chance of serious discrimination or harm due to their ethnicity or religion, noting that Barelvis were not generally at risk merely for their faith. Similarly, the court found no real chance of harm due to Applicant A's Shia surname, as he was not Shia and sectarian violence against Shias was low. The court also dismissed claims related to anti-Taliban political views, finding no evidence that the applicants had been involved in such activities or would be targeted by extremist groups. Applicant B's claims regarding her dress and perceived liberal views were also rejected, as evidence suggested middle-class women in urban areas could dress in Western fashion without significant problems, and she had not experienced issues in the past. The court concluded that the children were not at a real risk of serious harm, including abduction or denial of education, as these claims were not supported by credible evidence.

Ultimately, the court affirmed the decision not to grant the applicants Protection visas, finding that none of them faced a real chance of suffering serious harm amounting to persecution for any of the reasons outlined in the Refugees Convention, nor a real risk of suffering significant harm as defined in the Migration Act. Consequently, the applicants did not satisfy the criteria for a Protection visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.56, made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal is required to take account of PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines and PAM3 Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines and any country information assessment prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) expressly for protection status determination purposes, to the extent that they are relevant to the decision under consideration.BACKGROUND Applicant A is a [age]-year-old man of Sunni Islamic faith from Karachi in Pakistan. He belongs to the Barelvi sect and is of Muhajir background. He completed a [qualification] in [year]. From [year] to [year] he worked for a firm of [Industry 1]. From [year] until his departure from Pakistan he worked for [Company 1]. Applicant B is applicant A’s wife. She is [age] years old and also belongs to the Sunni Islamic Barelvi sect, is of Muhajir background and shares her husband surname. She attended university and holds qualifications in [discipline]. She has never worked outside the home. The applicants’ [age] year old son and [age] year old daughter are included in this application. The applicants obtained visitor visas on 7 July 2012 and arrived in Australia [in] May 2013. SUMMARY OF CLAIMS Applicant A claims that he is at risk of being physically harmed or killed on return to Pakistan mainly because of his role or perceived role supporting the management of [Company 1] (now [changed name to Company 2]) during a prolonged strike by retrenched workers in 2011. He claims that his background as a Muhajir who follows the Barelvi branch of Sunni Islam increases his risk of harm from these people. He also claims that he faces discrimination in areas such as employment because of his Muhajir background and that he is at risk of harm because while he follows Sunni Islam his surname more commonly associated with Shia Muslims. Applicant A claims that as a result of these issues he is at risk of serious or significant harm for reasons of his Muhajir background (race), his Barelvi religion, his anti-Taliban political opinion or imputed opinion and his membership of the particular social groups of middle management staff of [Company 1], failed asylum seekers from the Barelvi community in Pakistan and people holding views against the Taliban’s religious and political ideologies. Applicant B claims that she is also at risk of being physically harmed or killed on return to Pakistan by the people targeting applicant A because of his role in supporting the management of [Company 1] following the 2011 dismissals and because of her Shia surname, Muhajir ethnicity and Barelvi religion. Finally, she claims that she would be at risk of harm from extremists if she returned to Pakistan because she does not conform to Islamic norms, in particular with regard to how she dresses. Applicants A and B claim that their children are also at risk of harm because of applicant A’s work for [Company 1]. It has also been claimed that their son may be at risk of harm because he spoke on [radio] in Australia and that their daughter would suffer because of rules imposed by the Taliban and might be prevented from attending school.CONSIDERATION OF THE APPLICANTS’ CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEClaims relating to applicant A’s employment at [Company 1] and involvement in the 2011 dismissals

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Applicants A and B claim that their children are also at risk of harm because of applicant A’s work for [Company 1]. It has also been claimed that their son may be at risk of harm because he spoke on [radio] in Australia and that their daughter would suffer because of rules imposed by the Taliban and might be prevented from attending school.CONSIDERATION OF THE APPLICANTS’ CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEClaims relating to applicant A’s employment at [Company 1] and involvement in the 2011 dismissals [Company 1] is a large, privately owned [company] in Karachi. It currently has [number of] employees.[1] According to reports [number of] mostly lower level [Company 1] employees were offered redundancies in December 2010. Only about [a number] took up the offer. The remaining employees were dismissed [in] January 2011 and replaced by contractors. The dismissed employees were reinstated [later in] January 2011 following strong pressure from unions and the local government. However, they were placed in a ‘surplus pool’, with the apparent intention of retrenching them a later date. After a period of relative calm there was a period of renewed strikes, demonstrations and some attacks on company property. The dismissed workers were supported by a number of unions linked with a range of groups including Islamists such as Jamaat-e-Islami and some socialist organisations. [1] This overview is based on reports and articles provided by the applicants and other reports including [sources deleted]. The extent of the violence in 2011 and the reasons for it are somewhat unclear. Some of the continuing protests and violence appear to have been at least in part a response to blackouts in the city, which the company and the workers accused each other of creating. It appears that there was an attack of some kind on [Company 1] offices following the dismissals [in] January 2011 and that further blockades or attacks occurred in May and June 2011. It appears that the protests and violence related to the 2011 dismissals largely ceased in mid-2011, although a January 2014 article provided by the applicants indicates that a sit-in protest was held at that time. Strikes and protests against [Company 1] for other reasons have also occurred since 2011. Applicant A told the Department and the previous Tribunal that he was of particular interest to the unionists and other protesters because he of his middle-management position in the company, his involvement or perceived involvement in the planning and implementation of the redundancies and his activities during the strike, including the use of his home as an alternative office when the protests made it impossible to enter the company office. He also claimed that one of the factors involved in the company’s decision to make some workers redundant was discovery of theft of [company asset] by powerful people linked to unions. He said that he was instrumental in uncovering this theft and as a result the unions were angry with him when the workers were dismissed. Finally, he claimed that he had been promoted despite union objections, which also contributed to his problems following the dismissals at [Company 1].

Decision

Reasons for decision

By way of context, Muhajirs are Urdu-speaking immigrants, many of whom relocated from India at the time of partition and comprise about 7.5 per cent of the population of Pakistan. According to the 2017 census, the ethnic Muhajir Urdu-speaking community forms slightly less than 45 per cent of Karachi's present population of 20 to 24 million people and constitutes the bulk of Karachi's middle class.[2] [2] <>It is generally accepted that Karachi is a violent city.[3] This violence is related to crime, politics, ethnicity and religion and frequently involves elements of all of these factors as many political groups are tied to particular ethnic or religious groups and are often involved in criminal acts. Tensions between Muhajirs and Pashtuns have sometimes descended into violence. However this has mostly involved the armed wings of major political parties, including the Muhajir-based Muttahida Qaumi Movement and appears to have had limited impact on ordinary citizens. [3] DFAT Country Information Report Pakistan 1 September 2017 and 20 February 2019 and; and UK Home Office Country Policy and Information Note Pakistan: Security and humanitarian situation, including fear of militant groups, January 2019In September 2017 DFAT noted that overall violence in the city has fallen significantly in recent years largely because of a highly visible presence of the federal paramilitary police force and assessed overall risk of violence in Karachi at that time as moderate, particularly once the size of the city population is taken into account. According to sources cited in a UK Home Office report issued in January 2019, this continued to be the situation in 2018. A report issued by DFAT in February 2019 provided a similar overview.According to DFAT around 75 per cent of Pakistanis are Sunni Muslims and 60 per cent of Sunni Muslims adhere to the Barelvi school. Barelvis are generally less orthodox and conservative in their interpretation of Islam than Deobandis, the other major Sunni school in Pakistan. Members of the latter group are more likely to join militant groups. Many Barelvi Sunnis in Pakistan venerate Sufi saints and shrines, which are common targets for sectarian attacks. The applicants have provided evidence which suggests there has been some conflict between Deobandis and Barelvis. However, the evidence does not suggest that Barelvis are generally at risk of harm because of their faith in Karachi. The previous Tribunal advised the applicants that while he was aware that violence was a problem in Karachi it mostly involved political parties and associated criminal gangs or rival sectarian groups. He noted that Muhajirs make up a significant proportion of the population of Karachi and that applicant A did not belong to any political groups. He also noted that the majority of Sunni Muslims follow the Barelvi school and that while there had been attacks on some Barelvi shrines, considered in the context of the Barelvi population of Karachi the chance that they would be victims of such an attack were remote. He also noted that while applicant A had a Shia surname, he was not a Shia and did not attend Shia religious celebrations. He observed that it appeared that there was no more than a remote chance that the applicants would experience serious harm because of their Muhajir ethnicity, their Barelvi religion or applicant A’s Shia surname in Karachi.In response, the applicants said that they feared harm because of applicant A’s employment at [Company 1] and said that they had mentioned the other issues as factors which they believed would exacerbate his risk of harm. They agreed that there was only a remote chance that they would be harmed because they were Barelvi Muslims.With regard to the more general issue of crime and violence, applicant A said that he had been held up and his mobile phone had been stolen on several occasions, but neither applicant claimed to have experienced serious harm in the past because of their religion or ethnicity or the general violence in Pakistan. At the hearing on 23 January 2019 the applicants confirmed that they had never belonged to any political party or any other groups or organisations which are involved with political or religious matters. They said that they were not very religious. They sometimes pray, but rarely attend Mosque. Applicant A confirmed his education and employment history. Applicant B confirmed that she had obtained tertiary qualifications, but had never worked outside the home. She said that she had never felt comfortable about working and after she was married there was no need for her to seek employment.I asked the applicants about any problems they had faced in Pakistan because of their Muhajir background. Applicant A said that Pashtun-dominated unions within [Company 1] pressured the company not to promote him and other Urdu-speaking people and as a result he did not receive promotions which he deserved and when he was finally promoted this upset the unions. I asked if he had experienced any other problems because of his Muhajir background. He spoke in general terms about discrimination faced by Muhajirs, but said that he had not personally experienced any other problems. Later in the hearing, he said that he feared he would have difficulty finding employment if he returned to Pakistan in part because of his Muhajir background. I asked the applicants if they had experienced any problems because they are Barelvis. They said that they had not. I asked applicant A if he had experienced any problems in Pakistan because his surname appeared to be Shia. He said that he had not experienced any problems, but after the 2011 dismissals the unionists would check the identity of people at the [Company 1] office and they would be treated differently according to their background. He said that while this had not happened to him in the past it might in the future. I advised applicant A that according to DFAT Shia in Pakistan face a low risk of sectarian violence and that sectarian violence in Karachi was currently relatively low. He responded that Shias can face discrimination anywhere in Pakistan.I asked the applicants if they had experienced any other problems in Pakistan. Applicant A spoke about the general violence in Karachi and said that he had been a victim of theft on several occasions. Applicant B said that she had not experienced any problems, but she was often fearful.Consideration of claims and evidence relating to the applicants’ Muhajir background, Barelvi faith, applicant A’s Shia surname and general violenceAs discussed above, I do not accept that applicant A was personally of adverse interest to anyone because of his limited involvement in the 2011 dismissals or any other reason linked to his employment at [Company 1]. It follows that I do not accept that his Muhajir ethnicity or his Barelvi religion or his Shia surname exacerbated these problems or would increase the possibility that he would be harmed for reasons linked to his past employment if he returned to Pakistan.With regard to the issue of discrimination against Muhajirs, there is nothing in the evidence before me which suggests that applicant A or any member of his family faced serious discrimination or harm prior to their departure from Pakistan because of their ethnicity. Applicant A completed a [number]-year tertiary qualification and was employed in a relatively senior position appropriate to his skills. Applicant B also completed university studies, but chose not to work. According to applicant B’s evidence at the hearing on 23 January 2019 they lived in a wealthy area. I am unaware of any evidence which suggests that Muhajirs in Karachi face serious discrimination in employment or any other aspect of life. In these circumstances I am not satisfied there is a real chance that applicant A or any member of his family would face discrimination amounting to serious or significant harm on return to Pakistan because of their ethnicity.I have also considered the possibility that the applicants’ might be victims of violence in Karachi because of their Muhajir ethnicity. While it is certainly true that ethnic violence has been a problem in Karachi, it is clear from the evidence that much of this involves people in political parties or other groups competing with each other and that the level of violence has declined significantly in recent years. While it may be that applicant A has been a victim of crime in the past there is no credible evidence before me which suggests that he or any other member of his family has been a victim of ethnic violence in Pakistan because of their Muhajir background. I also note that, according to his statutory declaration dated 11 August 2014 he lived in a [specified] area which was the safest area of the city. In these circumstances I am not satisfied that any of the applicants faces a real chance of experiencing serious harm as a result of ethnic violence against Muhajirs in Pakistan.After considering all of the relevant evidence I am not satisfied that applicant A or applicant B or their children face a real chance of suffering serious or significant harm for reasons of their Muhajir ethnicity if they return to Pakistan within the reasonably foreseeable future.With regard to the fact that the applicants follow the Barelvi school of Sunni Islam, the applicants do not claim to have faced problems of any kind prior to their departure from Pakistan because they are Barelvis and confirmed to the previous Tribunal that there was only a remote chance that they would face harm on return to Pakistan for this reason. While I acknowledge that Barelvis have been amongst those who have been victims of sectarian or extremist violence, I am unaware of any evidence which suggests that Barelvis are generally at risk of harm merely because of their religion. On the evidence before me I am not satisfied that the applicants face a real chance of suffering serious or significant harm on return to Pakistan because of their religion.With regard to the applicants’ Shia surname, there is no suggestion that any of them has experienced any problems in the past because their name. According to DFAT there is a low level of violence against Shias in Pakistan, mostly involving attacking Shia places of worship, public celebrations or prominent individuals. The applicants are not Shias and there is no suggestion that they would participate in Shia religious events. In these circumstances I do not accept that there is a real chance that they would suffer serious harm on return to Pakistan because of their surname. The applicants’ status as failed asylum seekers of Barelvi religionIt has been submitted that the applicants would be at risk of harm on return to Pakistan because of their membership of the particular social group of Barelvi failed asylum seekers. As discussed above, the applicant confirmed to the previous Tribunal that there was only a remote chance that they would suffer harm on return to Pakistan because of their Barelvi religion and at the hearing on 23 January 2019 confirmed that they had not faced any problems in Pakistan because of their Barelvi religion. The previous Tribunal also advised the applicants of advice from DFAT which indicated that there was no more than a remote chance that they would experience harm in Pakistan because they had lived in Australia and applied unsuccessfully for protection. In essence the applicants said these were factors which would contribute to them being harmed by people targeting applicant A because of his work at [Company 1].At the hearing on 23 January 2019 I observed that it appeared unlikely that anyone would be aware that they had applied for protection and reminded them of the DFAT advice regarding failed asylum seekers. In response they said that they did not fear harm on return to Pakistan because they had applied for protection in Australia. I am not convinced that failed asylum seekers of Barelvi religion constitute a particular social group in Pakistan, but in any event on the evidence currently before me I am not satisfied that the applicants face a real chance of experiencing serious or significant harm on return to Pakistan because they are Barelvis who applied unsuccessfully for protection in Australia.Claims related to anti-Taliban political viewsIn submissions to the Department and the previous Tribunal the applicants claimed that they would be at risk of harm on return to Pakistan because they would be viewed as opponents of the Taliban and other extremist groups. While most of these submissions were linked to applicant A’s involvement in the 2011 dismissals, it was also submitted that they would be at risk of harm because extremists harass liberal-minded Pakistanis who are perceived to hold Western values or seen to be opposed to the orthodox views held by Islamists. The previous Tribunal advised the applicants that country information indicated that the prime targets of extremists such as the Taliban were government, those involved in law enforcement and their political rivals and it appeared that there was only a remote risk of them suffering serious harm at the hands of extremists. The applicants did not disagree with this, but said that they would suffer serious harm from the Taliban because of applicant A’s work for [Company 1] and the way in which he was perceived by the labour unions. At the hearing on 23 January 2019 I noted that applicant A had previously claimed that he would be at risk of harm if he returned to Pakistan because he opposed the Taliban’s extremist religious and political ideologies. I advised him that I accepted that he opposed these views and ideologies, but observed that it was my understanding that many Pakistanis held similar views, including some people in positions of power and that government had taken action against extremist groups involved in violent activities. I observed that he did not appear to have been involved in any anti-Taliban or anti-extremist activities in Pakistan or to have experienced problems with the Taliban or other extremists prior to leaving Pakistan and it was therefore difficult to accept that these views could cause him problems if he returned to Pakistan. He said that everything was related to his work and his support of the privatisation of [Company 1]. He said that extremists support the unions and oppose privatisation as it was against Islam and they would seek to harm him for that reason.Consideration of claims related to anti-Taliban political viewsAs discussed above, while I accept that dismissed workers and their supporters shouted threats at applicant A when he came and went from the [Company 1] office in 2011, I do not accept that he was of adverse particular or continuing interest to the Taliban or anyone else for this or any other reason prior to his departure from Pakistan in mid-2013. There is nothing in the evidence currently before me which suggests that any of the applicants would be of adverse interest to the Taliban or any other extremist group if they returned to Pakistan now. I am not satisfied that there is a real chance that any of the applicants would face serious or significant harm on return to Pakistan because they hold or would be perceived to hold anti-Taliban or anti-extremist views or because they belong to a particular social group of people who oppose the Taliban.Applicant B’s claims relating to her views on Islam and her genderIn a written submission provided following her interview with the delegate applicant B claims for the first time that she would be at risk of harm because she is very social and moderate and does not adhere to Islamic rules, in particular she wore jeans and did not wear hijab. She said that she feared that the extremists who were targeting applicant A would target her for that reason, apparently as part of their campaign against applicant A.The previous Tribunal advised applicant B of evidence that many women did not wear hijab, although most women drape a scarf about their shoulders in public which can be pulled over the head if needed. According to the evidence while failure to dress appropriately in certain areas or circumstances could result in some harassment, failure to wear hijab was unlikely to cause problems for most women, particularly if they were part of a community which behaved in a similar fashion. Applicant B said that many women dressed as she did in Pakistan, but she and applicant A also stated that there were many extremists in Pakistan and applicant B’s manner of dress could cause problems, particularly in the context of the threats against applicant A because of his work at [Company 1]. At the hearing on 23 January 2019 I noted that applicant B had claimed that she feared harm if she returned to Pakistan because she did not follow Islamic traditions and values, but observed that she did not appear to have experienced problems for that reason in the past. She said that she had not faced any problems in the past because she used to dress appropriately according to the situation. I asked why she would not be able to do this if she returned to Pakistan. She said that after living in Australia she had become more liberal and Westernised and she would not wear a headscarf even in areas where this was appropriate. She also said that after six years in Australia people might think that she was a Christian. I asked if applicant B would behave differently in any other way after living in Australia. She said that she would not be able to go out because she is fearful. I noted that she had previously stated that she sometimes wore jeans and generally went without a headscarf and that she had spoken about moving freely in her local area, taking her children to and from school and walking in the local area with her daughter and she did not appear to have experienced problems because of this. I observed that it appeared that she could continue to do so if she returned to Pakistan. Applicant B said her fears were related to the problems she and her family had faced because of applicant A’s problems with extremists, not the way in which she dressed.I reminded applicant B of DFAT’s advice regarding Western influences and observed that middle-class women were not generally at risk of harm because of their gender or because they dressed in a Western fashion. Applicant B said that this applied to upper-class people and added that her sister-in-law had not visited Pakistan for many years because of security concerns. I advised applicant B that I was aware that women in Pakistan sometimes faced problems because of their gender, particularly if they came from a poorer community. However, it was also my understanding the middle-class women had greater opportunities in areas such as education and employment, and this appeared to be her situation. I also advised her that, according to DFAT, with the exception of people involved in education, there was only a low chance of women in Pakistan being attacked by extremists because of their gender. Applicant B said that her father would not send her to a co-educational school and also said that actors and women who dressed improperly on television had been attacked. I told her that I accepted that this occurred, but the people involved were prominent public figures, which was not her situation.Consideration of applicant B’s claims As noted above, applicant B stated at the hearing that her fears related primarily to problems associated with applicant A’s employment at [Company 1] and indicated that she was not fearful of harm because of the manner in which she dressed or intended to dress. Nevertheless, I have considered whether her dress or other aspects of her behaviour would cause her problems if she returned to Pakistan.It is clear from the evidence that middle-class women living in middle-class communities in large urban areas often dress in a Western fashion and do not face significant problems because of this. Prior to leaving Pakistan applicant B dressed in a Western fashion without experiencing problems. She claims that after spending over five years in Australia she had become more liberal and Westernised and would behave differently on return. However, the only change specifically mentioned was her claim that while in the past she dressed appropriately for the circumstances, she would not wear a headscarf on any occasion if she returned to Pakistan. 100. According to the evidence most Pakistani women, including those who dress in a Western fashion and do not cover their heads do this as a matter of routine and convenience. There is nothing in the evidence which suggests that applicant B has ever been involved in actively promoting women’s rights such that she would insist on going bareheaded or dressed in a manner likely to cause her significant problems in order to make a political statement and I do not accept she would dress in an inappropriate manner or refuse to pull a scarf over her hair if she was in an area where not doing so might result in her being chastised or harassed. 101. After considering all of the relevant evidence, I am not satisfied that applicant A faces a real chance of experiencing serious or significant harm on return to Pakistan because of the way she dresses or for any other reason linked directly or indirectly to her gender.102. I have also considered the claim that applicant A might be believed to be a Christian because she has spent time in Australia or because of the way she dresses. However, as discussed at the hearing, it is not uncommon for middle-class Pakistanis to dress and behave in a “Western” manner. I am unaware of any evidence which suggests that Pakistani women (or men) would be suspected of converting to Christianity merely because they have spent time in Australia and I do not accept that applicant B faces a real chance of suffering serious or significant harm on return to Pakistan because she would be suspected of converting to Christianity.Claims relating to the applicants’ children103. In written submissions to the Tribunal the applicants claimed that their son was at risk of harm on return to Pakistan because he had become a star on [radio] in Australia and also said that they feared their children might be abducted if they returned to their homeland. When asked about these claims at the hearing applicant A said that his son had been on [radio] speaking the Urdu language on one occasion and while it might not be likely that this would cause him problems on return to Pakistan, he could be at risk of abduction. He added that his family had been targeted in the past and said that he would not send his children to school if he returned to Pakistan. I advised the applicants that while I was aware that crime was a problem in Pakistan it was not my understanding that the problems were such that there was a real chance his children would be kidnapped. The applicants said that their children would be under mental stress if they returned to Pakistan because they were not accustomed to living in a situation where there were guards at school and other security issues.104. In written submissions to the Tribunal the applicant said that their daughter would suffer if she returned to Pakistan because she would not be able to cope with the rules imposed by the Taliban and she might be prevented from attending school. At the hearing I advised the applicants that it was not my understanding that middle-class girls in urban areas such as Karachi were likely to face these problems. Applicant A said while she might not face these problems immediately, she could do so in future.105. Submissions provided on 4 February 2019 argued that there was a strong likelihood that the applicants children would be kidnapped if they returned to Pakistan and that would face problems attending school.Consideration of claims relating to the applicants’ children106. As discussed above, I do not accept that applicant A faces a real chance of suffering serious or significant harm for any reason linked to his employment. It follows that I do not accept that his children face a real chance of experiencing serious harm for this reason.107. I accept that the applicants’ children might face some relatively minor issues readjusting to life in Pakistan after spending over five years in Australia, but there is nothing in the evidence before me which suggests that they would be kidnapped or denied the right to attend school or experience other serious problems and I am not satisfied that there is a real chance that either of them would experience serious or significant harm for any reason if they return to Pakistan now or in the reasonably foreseeable future.Claims regarding other difficulties on return108. The applicants claim they will have nothing if they return to Pakistan because they had abandoned their home and applicant A left his job and would have difficulty finding a job because of his age, Muhajir ethnicity and limited qualifications. 109. I accept that having given up their rented home and applicant A’s employment and spending over five years in Australia they may face some difficulties re-establishing themselves and adjusting to life in Pakistan. However, I do not accept that their Muhajir background would have any impact on their treatment or prospects on return (see also above) and there is no credible evidence before me which suggests that they face a real chance of suffering serious harm for any of the reasons in the Refugees Convention or that there is a real risk that they would suffer significant harm as defined in the Migration Act because of their decision to leave Pakistan or their time in Australia.CONCLUSIONS 110. After considering the applicants’ claims singly and cumulatively, I am not satisfied that any of them faces a real chance of suffering serious harm amounting to persecution for any of the reasons in the Refugees Convention. Therefore I am not satisfied that any of them has a well-founded fear of persecution in Pakistan now or in the reasonably foreseeable future.111. After considering the applicants’ claims singly and cumulatively, I am not satisfied that any of them faces a real risk of suffering significant harm on return to Pakistan. Therefore, I am not satisfied that there are substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicants being removed from Australia to Pakistan, there is a real risk that any of them will suffer significant harm.112. For the reasons given above the Tribunal is not satisfied that any of the applicants is a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations. Therefore the applicants do not satisfy the criterion set out in s.36(2)(a) or (aa) for a Protection visa. It follows that they are also unable to satisfy the criterion set out in s.36(2)(b) or (c). As they do not satisfy the criteria for a Protection visa, they cannot be granted the visa.DECISION113. The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicants Protection visas.Roslyn SmidtMember

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established