1614931 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

1614931 (Refugee) [2021] AATA 4375 (22 September 2021)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1614931

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   Pakistan

MEMBER:Deputy President J.L Redfern PSM

DATE:22 September 2021

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicants protection visas.

Statement made on 22 September 2021 at 3:05 PM

CATCHWORDS

REFUGEE – Protection (Class XA) (Subclass 866) visa – Pakistan – application for protection – applicant fears harm from an alleged member of the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan –educated Sunni Muslim woman of Pashtun ethnicity – genuine fear but Tribunal not satisfied the fear well founded – lengthy period since threats made – consideration of whether serious or significant harm where societal discrimination – not satisfied protection obligations engaged – decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5(1), 5H, 5J, 5K, 5L, 5LA, 36(2)(a), 36(2)(aa), 36(2)(b), 36(2)(c), 65, 499
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2

CASES

1511103 (Refugee) [2017] AATA 2937
1700696 (Refugee) [2018] AATA 1878
1710719 (Refugee) [2021] AATA 3025
1712801 (Refugee) [2021] AATA 3078
1720890 (Refugee) [2019] AATA 5705
AIE15 v Minister for Immigration and Anor [2018] FCA 610
Chan Yee Kin v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1989) 169 CLR 379
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZQRB [2013] FCAFC 33
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Guo [1997] HCA 22
SZGHS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 1572
SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] HCA 34

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Country Information Report Pakistan, 20 February 2019
Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs, Ministerial Direction No.84, Consideration of Protection Visa applications, 24 June 2019

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependants.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse to grant the applicants’ protection visas under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. [The first named applicant] was born in [Year] and claims to be a citizen of Pakistan. [The second named applicant] is her husband. The third and fourth named applicants are their two children who are [age range] years old. The first named applicant arrived in Australia [in] January 2012 as a dependant of the second named applicant’s [Student] visa. In October 2012, she lodged an application for a [Student] visa, which was granted on 28 November 2012, and subsequently applied for a protection visa on 6 March 2015. The second, third and fourth named applicants were included in the protection application as secondary applicants.

  3. The first named applicant claims to fear harm from a person who lived in her village who she claims was a member of the Tehrik-e-Taliban…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1614931 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 4375
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for a Protection (Class XA) (Subclass 866) visa by a Pakistani national. The applicant claimed to fear harm upon return to Pakistan due to threats made by a member of the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP). The applicant, an educated Sunni Muslim woman of Pashtun ethnicity, alleged that the TTP member targeted her and her family due to her educational pursuits and a belief that she had reported him to the police. The dispute before the court was whether the applicant's fear of harm was well-founded and whether Australia's protection obligations were engaged.

The court was required to determine if the applicant had established a well-founded fear of persecution or significant harm if returned to Pakistan. This involved assessing the credibility of her claims, the nature and recency of the threats, and the general country information regarding the TTP's activities and the safety of educated women in Pakistan. Specifically, the court needed to consider whether the alleged threats, made over a decade prior, still posed a genuine risk of serious or significant harm, and whether societal discrimination against educated women constituted a basis for protection.

The court considered extensive country information, including a DFAT report, and the applicant's evidence. While accepting the applicant's genuine fear, the court was not satisfied that the fear was well-founded. The court noted the lengthy period since the alleged threats were made and the applicant's inability to identify the current whereabouts of the TTP member in question. Furthermore, the court found that while societal discrimination existed, it did not rise to the level of persecution or significant harm that would engage Australia's protection obligations. Consequently, the decision under review was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The most recent report from DFAT is the Country Information Report for Pakistan dated 20 February 2019 (DFAT Report). I have considered this report, together with other relevant country information, including country information provided by the applicant. I have also considered the Department guidelines to the extent that these are relevant to the consideration of the decision under review. Generally, these guidelines contain an analysis of the law, examples of how the law has been applied in various jurisdictions and guidelines to decision-makers on how the law is to be applied. There is little by way of policy and the guidelines were of limited assistance in the circumstances. My analysis of this country information and any relevant guidelines are set out later in these reasons. BACKGROUND AND SUMMARY OF CLAIMS The first named applicant was born in Pakistan in [Year] and is a national of Pakistan. She claims to be a Sunni Muslim by religion, of Pashtun ethnicity. She arrived in Australia as a dependant on the second named applicant’s [Student] visa and applied for a protection visa on 6 March 2015. In the first named applicant’s protection visa application, it is recorded that she fears returning to Pakistan because she is concerned that she and her family will be targeted by the TTP. In brief, the first named applicant is concerned that she will be targeted because of her interactions with a member of the TTP, [Mr A], who will target her and her family because of her role as an educated woman in the local village and his belief that she may have been responsible for reporting him to police. The first named applicant claims that [Mr A] arranged for someone from the TTP to target her and her family when they were living in Islamabad in 2010 and this remains a threat. This is one of the reasons that she and her family travelled to Australia in 2012. According to Departmental records the first named applicant was interviewed by an officer of the Department in July 2015. The interview was recorded, and the Tribunal was provided with a copy of the audio. The delegate included details of the interview in the decision record. The first named applicant’s claims are set out in the decision record of the delegate and can be summarised as follows:(1)The first named applicant is from [Village A], in the Swat District of the province previously known as North West Frontier province. She is one of [Number] children. Her father and one of her sisters are deceased. One of her brothers lives in [Country 1] and her mother and other siblings live in the Swat District. (2)While the first named applicant was in high school, [Mr A], her next-door neighbour at the time, was an active member of the TTP and was opposed to girls being educated, and prevented his sister from attending school. The first named applicant was close friends with his sister and defended her. [Mr A] would often yell at and abuse the first named applicant while she walked to school, for insulting Pashtun female culture. He slapped her at their local shops one day.(3)She enrolled in a college affiliated with [a University] soon after this incident. [Mr A] sent messages to all females in their village that they should always be accompanied by a male outside their homes and that women should wear the burqa. The first named applicant complied with this so she could attend her classes. After completing and obtaining a [Qualification 1] she undertook teaching of [school] students at [Workplace] in Swat. On the night she got the position, some rocks were thrown in her courtyard.(4)In her interview, the first named applicant stated that there was animosity between her family and the family of [Mr A] before she was born when a forebear of hers rejected a [A] family member as a suitable husband for his sister. It is also recorded in the decision record that the first named applicant said that she did not know the whereabouts of [Mr A] and he could be in Afghanistan, but she did not believe he had remained living in [Village A] because the army regularly knocked on the door of his family to check if he was there.(5)In 2003 to 2006 TTP extremists were taking hold in Swat, forcing people into religious madrasas instead of other schools. The first named applicant cancelled her enrolment in a [Qualification level] at this time. In December 2006, she left her teaching position and in January 2007, she started teaching children from her home as the children were afraid of attending schools.(6)[Mr A] and others fired guns and Kalashnikovs in the air at the first named applicant’s home and dragged her brother out of the house and beat him; he had critical injures. (7)In 2007, [she] did not feel safe and travelled to the house of her husband’s uncle in Rawalpindi. The first named applicant and her husband moved to Islamabad where both the third and fourth named applicants were born. In 2009 the first named applicant’s mother and siblings were relocated out of Swat under UNHCR arrangements. They have since returned.(8)In October 2010, an unregistered vehicle pulled over to where the first named applicant and her husband were sitting outside their home and a man asked if they knew [Mr A]. The man ran off shouting “we will kill you”. She believes her name is on the TTP hit list because they believe that she has given [Mr A]’s name to the army for what he did to her and her brother. She fears if she returns to Pakistan the TTP will kill her and her family as they identified her and her husband in Islamabad. She claims she cannot relocate as the TTP are in every city in Pakistan.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 2 December 2020, the first named applicant gave oral evidence at the hearing before me. The second named applicant also gave oral evidence. It was unnecessary to take further evidence from witnesses who had provided statements. Several of the witnesses’ statements provided related to the applicants’ education and employment or were not relevant to any determinative issues in dispute. I did not take evidence from two persons said to have been witnesses to the incident that occurred in 2010 because I accept the evidence in those statements. I also accept the truth of many of the first and second named applicants’ claims in relation to these matters. As already noted, the first named applicant gave further oral evidence on 27 August 2021. OUTLINE OF EVIDENCE The first named applicant provided to the Department information in support of her claims, including an undated written statement outlining her claims as set out above, various media articles and various documents and letters relating to her and her husband’s education and employment, statutory declarations of support from [Mr B], [Mr C] and [Mr D], and a letter of support from the [Union Council] signed by four officials, being school principals or head masters and the President of [an Organisation], Swat. The date of the letter is unclear. [Mr B] is the second named applicant’s father. He states that Pakistan faces a continuous surge of violence and that his son and family would be in extreme danger if they returned to Pakistan from the Taliban. [Mr C] and [Mr D] are the second named applicant’s brothers. [Mr C] stated that when he was in [Village A] in 2009 getting married, one of the villagers told him the Taliban were looking for the first and second named applicants. He stated that he was shocked about this. [Mr D] stated that [Mr C] and his father told him his brother and family were threatened and after October 2010 he and [Mr C] saved money so they could fund the family’s travel to Australia in 2012. [Mr D] was concerned that if the applicants returned to Pakistan, they would face attacks and death threats. These statutory declarations were dated March 2015. The letter of support from the [Union Council] noted that the first named applicant had been working as a teacher in [Workplace], Swat. There were problems with the Taliban in the Swat Valley at this time and it is stated that the first named applicant had been humiliated and threatened by the Taliban at this time and was forced to teach children privately, and then to move to Islamabad. In addition to the information provided to the Department, the first named applicant provided to the Tribunal documents said to be a ‘first information report’ and related legal documents, translated from Urdu into English, which she claims support her contentions about [Mr A]. She also provided the Tribunal with statements from her husband, mother in law and sister in law and statements from two nationals from Pakistan, [Mr E] and [Mr F], who the first named applicant claims were eyewitnesses to the threatening incident in Islamabad in 2010. The first named applicant provided updated letters of support about her education and letters relating to her children. I will not refer to this evidence in any detail because it is not relevant to the contentious issues.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In accordance with Ministerial Direction No.84,[1] made under s.499 of the Act, the Tribunal is required to take account of policy guidelines prepared by the Department - Procedures Advice Manual 3 ‘Refugee and humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines’ and Procedures Advice Manual 3 ‘Refugee and humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines’. The Tribunal must also take into account any relevant country information assessment prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) expressly for protection status determination purposes.[1] Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs, Ministerial Direction No.84 - Consideration of Protection Visa applications, 24 June 2019. The most recent report from DFAT is the Country Information Report for Pakistan dated 20 February 2019 (DFAT Report). I have considered this report, together with other relevant country information, including country information provided by the applicant. I have also considered the Department guidelines to the extent that these are relevant to the consideration of the decision under review. Generally, these guidelines contain an analysis of the law, examples of how the law has been applied in various jurisdictions and guidelines to decision-makers on how the law is to be applied. There is little by way of policy and the guidelines were of limited assistance in the circumstances. My analysis of this country information and any relevant guidelines are set out later in these reasons. BACKGROUND AND SUMMARY OF CLAIMS The first named applicant was born in Pakistan in [Year] and is a national of Pakistan. She claims to be a Sunni Muslim by religion, of Pashtun ethnicity. She arrived in Australia as a dependant on the second named applicant’s [Student] visa and applied for a protection visa on 6 March 2015. In the first named applicant’s protection visa application, it is recorded that she fears returning to Pakistan because she is concerned that she and her family will be targeted by the TTP. In brief, the first named applicant is concerned that she will be targeted because of her interactions with a member of the TTP, [Mr A], who will target her and her family because of her role as an educated woman in the local village and his belief that she may have been responsible for reporting him to police. The first named applicant claims that [Mr A] arranged for someone from the TTP to target her and her family when they were living in Islamabad in 2010 and this remains a threat. This is one of the reasons that she and her family travelled to Australia in 2012. According to Departmental records the first named applicant was interviewed by an officer of the Department in July 2015. The interview was recorded, and the Tribunal was provided with a copy of the audio. The delegate included details of the interview in the decision record. The first named applicant’s claims are set out in the decision record of the delegate and can be summarised as follows:(1)The first named applicant is from [Village A], in the Swat District of the province previously known as North West Frontier province. She is one of [Number] children. Her father and one of her sisters are deceased. One of her brothers lives in [Country 1] and her mother and other siblings live in the Swat District. (2)While the first named applicant was in high school, [Mr A], her next-door neighbour at the time, was an active member of the TTP and was opposed to girls being educated, and prevented his sister from attending school. The first named applicant was close friends with his sister and defended her. [Mr A] would often yell at and abuse the first named applicant while she walked to school, for insulting Pashtun female culture. He slapped her at their local shops one day.(3)She enrolled in a college affiliated with [a University] soon after this incident. [Mr A] sent messages to all females in their village that they should always be accompanied by a male outside their homes and that women should wear the burqa. The first named applicant complied with this so she could attend her classes. After completing and obtaining a [Qualification 1] she undertook teaching of [school] students at [Workplace] in Swat. On the night she got the position, some rocks were thrown in her courtyard.(4)In her interview, the first named applicant stated that there was animosity between her family and the family of [Mr A] before she was born when a forebear of hers rejected a [A] family member as a suitable husband for his sister. It is also recorded in the decision record that the first named applicant said that she did not know the whereabouts of [Mr A] and he could be in Afghanistan, but she did not believe he had remained living in [Village A] because the army regularly knocked on the door of his family to check if he was there.(5)In 2003 to 2006 TTP extremists were taking hold in Swat, forcing people into religious madrasas instead of other schools. The first named applicant cancelled her enrolment in a [Qualification level] at this time. In December 2006, she left her teaching position and in January 2007, she started teaching children from her home as the children were afraid of attending schools.(6)[Mr A] and others fired guns and Kalashnikovs in the air at the first named applicant’s home and dragged her brother out of the house and beat him; he had critical injures. (7)In 2007, [she] did not feel safe and travelled to the house of her husband’s uncle in Rawalpindi. The first named applicant and her husband moved to Islamabad where both the third and fourth named applicants were born. In 2009 the first named applicant’s mother and siblings were relocated out of Swat under UNHCR arrangements. They have since returned.(8)In October 2010, an unregistered vehicle pulled over to where the first named applicant and her husband were sitting outside their home and a man asked if they knew [Mr A]. The man ran off shouting “we will kill you”. She believes her name is on the TTP hit list because they believe that she has given [Mr A]’s name to the army for what he did to her and her brother. She fears if she returns to Pakistan the TTP will kill her and her family as they identified her and her husband in Islamabad. She claims she cannot relocate as the TTP are in every city in Pakistan.