Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
According to the Secretary General of the Norwegian Refugee Council, Jan Egeland, the situation in the DRC became much worse in 2016 and 2017 becoming a major moral and humanitarian challenge comparable to the wars in Syria and Yemen. Women and children are abused sexually and ‘abused in all possible manners.’ Apart for the conflict in North Kivu, violence had also increased in the Kasai region. The armed groups are after gold, diamonds, oil, and cobalt for the benefit of both local and overseas interests. In addition ethnic and cultural rivalries together with religious motives and the political crisis with postponed elections are also factors contribution to the crisis. He claimed that the situation in the DRC had become much worse claiming that "The big wars of the Congo that were really on top of the agenda 15 years ago are back and worsening".[42] [42] Al Jazeera News (9 March 2018). "UN: Two million children risk starvation in DRC." Al Jazeera News website, >Human Rights Watch said in 2017 that Joseph Kabila recruited former M23 fighters to put down country-wide protests over his refusal to step down from office at the end of his term. They claimed that ‘M-23 fighters patrolled the streets of Congo’s main cities, firing on or arresting protesters or anyone else deemed to be a threat to the president’.[43] In addition fighting erupted in Masisi between government forces and a powerful local warlord, General Delta. The United Nations mission in the DRC is its largest and most expensive peacekeeping effort, but it shut down five UN bases near Masisi in 2017, after the US led a push to cut costs.[44] Forced Recruitment of Congolese males into groups by Rwandan authorities. [43] Human Rights Watch, "DR Congo: Rebels Were Recruited to Crush Protests". Hrw.org. 4 December 2017. [44] The Guardian 'The wars will never stop' - millions flee bloodshed as Congo falls apart,’ Jason Burke Masisi, 3 Apr 2018, >In 2015 the US State Department Trafficking in Persons Report reported that: [45]‘In 2013, Rwandan government officials reportedly provided material and logistical support to the armed group M23, which operated in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) and forcibly and fraudulently recruited children and men; however, after its defeat in November 2013, there were no reports the government facilitated the recruitment of children to serve in the M23 after that date.[45] 2015 Trafficking in Persons Report- Rwanda; US State Department 27 July 2015, >In 2016 the US State Department Trafficking in Persons Report reported that:[46]‘During the reporting period, Burundian men and some children in Rwanda were recruited and used in armed groups; though some recruitment was reportedly voluntary, some were reportedly coerced through physical and verbal threats. Between May and September 2015, Burundian refugees residing in Mahama refugee camp in Rwanda were recruited into non-state armed groups supporting the Burundian opposition; Rwandan security forces charged to protect the camp population reportedly facilitated or tolerated the recruitment activity. Many refugees alleged that recruiters—including both Rwandan officials and other refugees—threatened, intimidated, harassed, and physically assaulted those who refused recruitment attempts. Most recruits were adult males, but in three verified cases, Burundian refugee children were also identified as recruits from Mahama refugee camp’ .…………[46] 2016 Trafficking in Persons Report- Rwanda; US State Department June 2016 >The 2018 the US State Department Trafficking in Persons Report[47] states that there were ‘no reports of forcible or coerced recruitment out of Mahama refugee camp by Rwandan government officials in 2017.’ In addition the report stated that ‘there were no credible reports of Rwandan government involvement in either the recruitment into armed groups or sexual exploitation of refugees, during the reporting period…..’[48]The applicant’s evidence. [47] 2018 Trafficking in Persons Report- Rwanda; US State Department June 2018 ibidThe applicant’s evidence was that he was born [in] Lubumbashi, DRC. He claims that he is of Tutsi ethnicity and a Catholic. He states that he has [siblings] and attended primaryschool [information deleted] in Lubumbashi, DRC.[49] [49] Statutory Declaration by [the applicant] dated 25 July 2018; AAT File 1702611 @ f57The applicant claims that the majority of the population in Lubumbashi, DRC are ethnic Katangais and that that there are few Tutsi’s in the Lubumbashi area. He says that he recalls being bullied and insulted by other students at school and people in the neighbourhood telling him that he and his family should go back to their country, Rwanda.[50][50] IbidIn or about 1996 when the applicant was about [age] years old, the first rebellion with Laurent Desitre Kabila commenced which was supported by the Rwandan government. The DRC government started saying that the Tutsi in DRC were for Rwanda and did not belong in DRC. In or about November or December 20996 the violence spread south from Kivu to Lubumbashi. As a result of the violence the applicant and his family moved to a friend’s house in Lubumbashi for a period of 3 to 4 months. After the rebellion, in about April or May 1997, they returned to their home and the applicant returned to school.[51] [51] IbidIn or about 1998, the applicant’s father was detained by the police. The DRC police visited the applicant’s home and made his family sit in the corner at gun point while they went through the house taking valuables. The applicant with his mother and [sibling] then went to live a friend or a month before being detained by the police [at a location] with other ethnic Tutsi’s.[52] The applicant’s father was also detained [at a location]. While the applicant and his family were in detention in or about 1999, his mother had his [sibling], [name deleted]. [52] OpCit @ f55In or about 1998 or 1999 the Red Cross commenced assisting people held in detention at [at a location]. In June 1999 the applicant and his family were resettled by the International Committee of the Red Cross to Kigali, Rwanda. The applicant and his family were provided refugee cards in DRC and their files transferred to Rwanda upon their arrival. The applicant and his family had relatives in Rwanda who had fled DRC in 1994 as a result of the Hutus militia. The applicant says that they arrived in Rwanda at a time that the country was recovering for the genocide. As a result for educated people, even though they were refugees, were educated and therefore able to find work. The applicant’s mother had a degree [and] obtained a job [in a named agency] in or about 2000. The applicant’s father worked [in an occupation]. The applicant states that he completed [his] education in Rwanda. The applicant attended [school for a number of years]. [He] was conferred a Bachelor [degree] from the [University]. The applicant’s parents together with his [siblings] continue to reside in Rwanda.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEApplicants Relevant Convention GroundsThe applicant submits that his claims fall within the scope of the refugee Convention by reason of his race as a Congolese Tutsi, membership of a social group, as a young Tutsi male and member of [Family D] and by reason of his imputed political opinion as a supporter of M23 and CNDP Tutsi rebellionsAs to the applicants membership of a social group it is necessary that he share a certain characteristics or elements which unites him with a particular group and enables them to be set apart from society at large. That is to say, not only must the applicant with his group exhibit some common element, it must unite them, making them a cognisable group within their society.[53] [53] Applicant A v MIEA (1997) 190 CLR 225 per Dawson J at 241, McHugh J at 264-266 and Gummow J at 285.In this case, the Tribunal accepts the applicant evidence and finds that he is a Congolese Tutsi and a member of [Family D]. As such the Tribunal accepts that as a member of the Congolese Tutsi and young Tutsi male he shares a common characteristic which can be differentiated from the community in general. As such, the Tribunal finds that the applicant is a member of a particular social group, namely a member of the Congolese Tutsi and young Tutsi male. Applicant’s well-founded fear. In Chan v MIEA[54] the Court held that ‘well-founded fear’ involves both a subjective and objective element. That is, the definition will be satisfied if an applicant can show genuine fear founded upon a ‘real chance’ of persecution based on a Convention reason. Justice Dawson noted that the phrase “well-founded fear of being persecuted...” contains both a subjective and an objective requirement. That is, there must be a state of mind (fear of being persecuted) and a basis (well-founded) for that fear.[55] [54] (1989) 169 CLR 379 at 396.[55] (1989) 169 CLR 379 at 396. See also MIEA v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at 263 per Brennan CJ, Toohey, McHugh and Gummow JJ.The subjective element of ‘well-founded fear’ concerns the state of mind of the applicant. That is, whether an applicant has a genuine fear is a question of fact. In this case based on the evidence of the applicant the Tribunal accepts that the applicant has a subjective fear of being harmed by M23 and the FARDC. To hold a ‘well found fear of persecution’ on an objective basis the applicant’s claims must be more than merely plausible or credible. In Chan v MIEA, Dawson J [56]stated:“Well-founded” must mean something more than plausible, for an applicant may have a plausible belief which may be demonstrated, upon facts unknown to him or her, to have no foundation.’[56] Chan v MIEA (1989) 169 CLR 379 per Dawson J at p.397In MIEA v Guo, the Court stated that: [57]‘Conjecture or surmise has no part to play in determining whether a fear is well‑founded. A fear is “well-founded” when there is a real substantial basis for it. As Chan shows, a substantial basis for a fear may exist even though there is far less than a 50 per cent chance that the object of the fear will eventuate. But no fear can be well-founded for the purpose of the Convention unless the evidence indicates a real ground for believing that the applicant for refugee status is at risk of persecution. A fear of persecution is not well-founded if it is merely assumed or if it is mere speculation.’[57] MIEA v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559 at 572; cf MIEA v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at 293.In this case, the applicant claims that he will be persecuted due to his race in the DRC. The applicants claims is that he and his family have been subjected to ongoing harassment and discrimination since the war between the DRC and Rwanda and that he is treated with suspicion and subjected to ongoing harm. The applicant claims that ethnic tensions have always been very high in DRC. The applicants evidence was supported by both [Mr A] and [Mr B]. The Tribunal accepts the applicant’s evidence that the ethnic tension towards the Congolese Tutsi’s remains very high in the DRC. Applicants claimed persecution in Rwanda In addition the applicant claims that he will be persecuted if he returns to Rwanda due to his refusal to affiliate with the Rwanda government and support M-23. In circumstances where the Tribunal has found that the applicant would not be returned to Rwanda, it is not necessary for the Tribunal to consider this claim. Applicant as a member of [Family D]. In addition the applicant claims to fear persecution by reason of his membership of a social group, being a member of the [Family D]. As referred to above the applicant’s [relative had connections to the] M-23 rebel group [information deleted].[58] [Information deleted].[59][58] [Source deleted].[59] [Source deleted].The Tribunal accepts that the applicant may experience some discrimination as a result of being a member of [Family D]. However, in circumstances where the M-23 troops surrendered on 7 November 2013, there have been no further reports of recruitment of troops by Rwandan authorities, [information deleted], the Tribunal does not accept that in and of its self that such discrimination will amount to persecution. Nevertheless, the Tribunal does accept that as a member of [Family D] his profile as a Congolese Tutsi and supporter of M-23 is enhanced and as such increasing his chance that he may be seriously harmed in the event he is returned to DRC. Applicant as a Congolese TutsiBased on the applicant’s oral evidence and the documentary evidence presented to the Tribunal, it accepts that the applicant was born in DRC and is an ethnic Tutsi. The applicant claims that he will be persecuted in the DRC by reason of the fact that he is a Congolese Tutsi. Both [Mr A] and [Mr B] supported the applicant’s evidence that as a Congolese Tutsi he will be persecuted in the DRC. The country information indicates that, some members of the general population in the DRC do not consider the Congolese Tutsis (also generally known as Banyamulenge) to be true Congolese. The Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada report dated 12 March 2013[60] noted that there is a deep hatred among the Congolese for 'Rwandophones,' especially those of Tutsi origin. It referred to the President of SHIKAMA who stated:[61]‘First, we suffered war and violence like members of the other communities-killings and other violations, forced displacement, exile, poverty, etc. Then we were classified by the rest of the 60 million Congolese who collectively identify us as the source of all their problems: accusations of all kinds, distrust, contempt, hatred, and sometimes even violence are all directed at the Tutsis. The war only worsens our situation and our condition. The war maintains this marginalization that people claim to be fighting against. Unfortunately, the allegiance of some of our brothers (including Congolese Hutus among others) in Rwanda reinforces the feeling among other communities that we are not sufficiently Congolese that we are conspiring against the Congo, and so on. Moreover, it is still impossible for ordinary people to differentiate between the instigators of these issues and the majority of ordinary Tutsis who often have nothing to do with political and military activities.’[60] Canada: Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada, Democratic Republic of Congo: The treatment of the Banyamulenge, or Congolese Tutsis, living in the provinces of North Kivu and South Kivu and in Kinshasa (2010-Feb. 2013), 12 March 2013, COD104321.FE, available at: 18 February 2019][61] ibidThe Canadian report notes that according to Minority Rights Group International (MRG), the population throughout much of the territory of both Kivus lives ‘in a state of permanent insecurity.’ It states that the Banyamulenge and other ethnic groups in the DRC are identified on the MRG's list of the people most under threat. The DRC is ranked as the country with the seventh highest level of risk risks of genocide...or other systemic violent repression.[62] [62] ibidAccording to Freedom House, ethnic discrimination, especially toward the Banyamulenge in South Kivu, is still "a major problem" in the DRC. According to MONUSCO, since the creation of the M23, there has been an increase in tension between the Banyamulenge, the Bembe and the Bafuliru in the Fizi territory in South Kivu. The President of SHIKAMA stated in his interview that the M-23 has caused increased resentment and rejection of the Congolese Tutsi community by other populations in the DRC[63] despite there being no members of the Banyamulenge in the M-23, and most of the Banyamulenge do not support the M23.[64] [63] OpCit per BurundiVision 14 Dec. 2012[64] Ibid. the article noted that corroborating information could not be found among the sources consulted by the Research Directorate.In a statement made on 15 September 1998, before the Sub-Committee on Africa, House International Relations Committee of the U.S. Congress, Susan E. Rice, Assistant Secretary for African Affairs,[65] explained that the Congolese Government has failed to resolve the crucial issue of the Banyamulenge citizenship, to ensure that ethnic Tutsis who have lived in the Congo for generations enjoy national rights and privileges. These failures have undermined regional security and contributed to the current perilous situation. From the available country information there appears to have been little progress by the DRC government to rectify this situation.[65] Canada: Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada, Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC): The Banyamulenge (Munyamulenge) ethnic group; whether members of this group are targeted by government authorities, 1 December 2000, RDC35883.F, available at: 20 February 2019.Based on the available country information the Tribunal accepts that as a Congolese Tutsi the applicant is at risk of being discriminated and harassed by the local population and is at risk of discrimination and harassment by local groups. The country information reports that recently there has been an escalation of violence arising out of the financial rewards, for both local and overseas parties, to be gained from the DRC’s natural resources together with the combination of ethnic and cultural rivalries with religious and political motives. [66] As a result the increased violence the chance of the applicant, as a Congolese Tutsi being seriously harmed has greatly increased in circumstances where the local population has limited transparency into political and economic reasons for the violence in the DRC.Applicant as a young Tutsi male. [66] Al Jazeera News (9 March 2018). "UN: Two million children risk starvation in DRC." Al Jazeera News website, type="1">The applicant claims that as a young Tutsi male there is a real chance that he will suffer serious harm. He says that as because he is male and relatively young that he will be seen as a person who is most likely to take up arms against the Congolese population by fighting for M-23 or some other militia group. It is also submitted that may militias operate in the applicant home area in DRC and that he would be at risk of recruitment as a young able body man.The Tribunal accepts that the forced recruitment for M-23 has ceased by the Rwanda authorities and as such does not accept that he is at risk of being recruited to fight for the M-23. However, the Tribunal notes that the former Congolese President, Joseph Kabila, after the demise of M-23 recruited its former fighters to put down country-wide protests over his refusal to step down from office at the end of his term. This resulted in M-23 fighters firing on or arresting local Congolese population deemed to have been a threat to the president.[67] As a result the local population sees the M-23 as having inflicted violence on them without necessarily understanding or appreciating the backing or motives for such actions. That is there is no distinction in the local mind between M-23 backed by the Rwandan government those members of the M-23 acting on the orders of Joseph Kabila. As such given that there has been an increase in violence over financial, ethnic and cultural issues in recent times, the Tribunal accepts that there is a real chance that, as a young Tutsi male, he will be accused of being an M-23 fighter and as such will suffer serious harm. Applicant’s imputed political opinion as supporter of M23 [67] Human Rights Watch, "DR Congo: Rebels Were Recruited to Crush Protests". Hrw.org. 4 December 2017. Finally, the applicant claims to fear harm in the DRC by reason of his imputed political opinion. He states that as a Congolese Tutsi and being a young male he will be imputed with the political opinion of being a member of the M-23 Rebel Group and CNDP Tutsi Rebellions. While the group has been forced out of the DRC, many members of M-23 remain in the country and have joined other militia who operate both in his home area and throughout the country. In addition members of the M-23 were recruited by Joseph Kabila to resist protests by the local population as a result of his failure to step down and to call a general election. As a result, the applicant claims that he is considered a traitor and would be subjected to harm by the local population and rival militia forces. The Tribunal accepts that the DRC continues to be subjected to militia attacks. The country information reports that the Allied Democratic Forces (ADF), an Islamist group based in Uganda but active in eastern DRC, Mai-Mai militia comprising a number of armed groups that originally formed to resist Rwandan invasions in the 1990s continue to clash with Congolese troops in the city of Beni in recent weeks.[68][68] The Guardian ‘Wave of rebel attacks leads to surge in DRC Ebola cases’ Jason Burke , Africa correspondent 25 October 2018,Last modified on Tue 6 Nov 2018, >In addition it is reports that rebels have attacked medical units assisting in the Ebola crisis, together with DRC army positions and abducted a dozen children aged between five and ten. While the reported attacks by rebel group appears to be opportunistic and random, the Tribunal does accept that as a result of being ethnic Tutsi, a young Tutsi male and a member of [Family D], he would be imputed with the political opinion of being a member of the M-23 and or the CNDP. As a result, on a cumulative basis, the risk of him being seriously harmed in an environment that is already subjected to militia attacks is increased. Therefore, the Tribunal finds that there is a real chance the applicant will be seriously harmed in the event that he is returned to DRC. As such, based on the available country information the Tribunal finds that there is a real chance the applicant will be seriously harmed by reasons of his race, as an ethnic Tutsi, his membership of a social group, as a young Tutsi male, and his imputed political opinion as a member of M-23. RelocationThe Congolese government of Kabila urged the "indigenous" population to fight not only the invading RPA ( Rwandan Patriotic Army ), but also the Congolese Tutsi civilians, the mostly affected being Banyamulenge.[69] Whule the Congolese Tutsi are primarily from the north east of the DRC, the action of the government and failure of the government to ensure that ethnic Tutsis enjoy national rights and privileges in the DRC means that it is not possible for the applicant to be relocated to another part of DRC. State Protection. [69] Mamdani, Mahmoud (2001). When Victims Become Killers: Colonialism, Nativism, and the Genocide in Rwanda. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-05821-0.While the Tribunal acknowledges there has been a change in government more recently in the DRC, it is noted that such change has not resulted in a deduction in violence within the DRC. The issue of Banyamulenge citizenship, to ensure that ethnic Tutsis who have lived in the Congo for generations enjoy national rights and privileges, has not been resolved. It continues to undermine regional security and contribute to the current perilous situation. The Police nationale congolaise (Congolese National Police) is the police throughout the territory of the Democratic Republic of the Congo. It was composed of between 110,000 and 150,000 officers as of 2010.[70] However, the police force is staffed by ex-soldiers and former rebels, riddled with corruption, poorly trained and lacking basic equipment and is generally viewed as more of a threat to the population than a guarantor of its security.[71] With a salary of barely US$30 a month, police in DRC often abuse their power by extorting money from civilians.[72][70] New laws for police reform in the DRC IRIN News. 2010, ibid[72] ibidAccordingly, based on the available country information the Tribunal is satisfied and finds that the applicant will not be able to access appropriate state protection in the DRC. Having considered the applicant’s claims singularly and cumulatively, the Tribunal finds that that there are substantial grounds for believing that, as a consequence of being removed from Australia to DRC, there is a real chance that the applicant will suffer serious harm.The Tribunal is therefore satisfied that the applicant does satisfy the criterion set out in s.36(2)(a) for a protection visa and as such he is a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees Convention. Applicant’s complementary protection claimThe applicant claims that, without conceding in any way his claims under the Refugee Convention, that the same factual matrix may invoke Australia’s protection obligations under complementary protection criteria pursuant to s.36(2)(aa) of the Act. Accordingly, the Tribunal has also considered the application of s.36(2)(aa) to the applicant’s circumstances. That is, the Tribunal has considered if the applicant faces a real risk of significant harm on the basis that he is an ethnic Tutsi, a young Tutsi male and by reason of his claimed imputed political opinion. For the reason set out above the Tribunal accepts that there is a real risk the applicant will suffer significant harm in the event he returns to DRC. Having considered his evidence and the available country information the Tribunal accepts his claims and finds that there is a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm pursuant to section 36(2A) of the Act by reason that he is an ethnic Tutsi, a young Tutsi male and as a result of his claimed imputed political opinion.At no stage did the applicant advance any other reason, in his written or oral claims that he is owed Australia’s protection obligations. The Tribunal therefore finds there are no more residual claims, including based on the applicant’s accepted circumstances, to be considered.Having regard to all the circumstances and findings above, considered individually and cumulatively, the Tribunal finds that there are grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to the DRC, there is a real risk he will suffer significant harm as required by s36(2)(aa).CONCLUSIONSFor the reasons given above, the Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant is a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (together, the Refugees Convention, or the Convention).Having concluded that the applicant does meet the refugee criterion in s.36(2)(a), the Tribunal has considered the alternative criterion in s.36(2)(aa) and is satisfied that the applicant is a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under s.36(2)(aa).DECISIONThe Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the applicant satisfies s.36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.Jason PennellMember