168 Wharf St Pty Ltd v Amstar Learning Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

168 Wharf St Pty Ltd & Anor v Amstar Learning Pty Ltd & Ors [2005] QCA 44

PARTIES:

168 WHARF STREET PTY LTD
(first respondent/first plaintiff)
BECKETT SERVICES PTY LTD
(second respondent/second plaintiff)
v
AMSTAR LEARNING PTY LTD (formerly ADROIT HUMAN RESOURCES PTY LTD)
(first appellant/first defendant)
NARENDRA JAIN
(second appellant/second defendant)
GEOFFREY GRAHAM BATT-RAWDEN
(third appellant/third defendant)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 2229 of 2004
DC No 922 of 2002

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Miscellaneous Application - Civil

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED EX TEMPORE ON:


1 March 2005

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

1 March 2005

JUDGES:

McPherson, Williams and Jerrard JJA
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

1. The appeals by the second and third defendants are allowed to the extent of reducing the amount (including interest) for which judgment was given against them in the District Court from $72,605.75 to $33,573.36

2. No order as to costs of the plaintiff and the second and third defendants of appeal

3. Further order that appeal by the first appellant be dismissed with costs

4. Plaintiff applicants to pay their own costs of this application

5. No order as to the costs of the defendants as respondents to this application

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS – AMENDING, VARYING AND SETTING ASIDE – CORRECTION UNDER ‘SLIP RULE’ – liability of guarantors – ambiguity in order rectified – costs orders

COUNSEL:

P J Favell for the appellants
C D Coulsen for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

Turner Freeman for the appellants
Fox Lawyers for the respondents

McPHERSON JA:  This is an application under the slip rule UCPR 388 or UCPR 667(2) to correct an order of the Court of Appeal made on 30th July 2004.  That was the date on which the Court as presently constituted delivered judgment in an appeal in an action brought in the District Court by the present applicant plaintiffs against the three now respondent defendants who were the first defendant company Amstar Learning Pty Ltd and two individuals named Jain and Batt-Rawden who are the second and third defendants in the action.  Judgment was given in favour of the plaintiff in the District Court in the amount of $72,605.75 for rent or money due for use and occupation of premises owned by the plaintiffs and let to Amstar that was guaranteed by those two individuals. 

All three defendants appealed against that judgment.  On the appeal coming before the Court on 21 June 2004 Mr De Buse of counsel announced his appearance on the appeal for the second and third appellant defendants.  When asked about the first appellant Mr De Buse said the company had gone into administration "and no longer has a director, so there is no one to retain us".  That being so, the proper course would have been for the plaintiff respondents to the appeal by their counsel to apply to strike out the appeal by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 168 Wharf St Pty Ltd v Amstar Learning Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QCA 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of 168 Wharf St Pty Ltd v Amstar Learning Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the plaintiff, a property company, and three defendants, who were guarantors of a lease agreement. The plaintiff sought to recover unpaid rent from the defendants, who had guaranteed the tenant's obligations under the lease. The matter was initially heard in the District Court, where judgment was given in favour of the plaintiff against the defendants for unpaid rent, interest, and costs. The defendants then appealed the decision to the Supreme Court.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the appeal from the District Court should be allowed and, if so, to what extent. Specifically, the court needed to determine if there was an ambiguity in the original District Court judgment that required rectification under the 'slip rule'. Additionally, the court had to consider the appropriate costs orders in light of the appeal.

The court found that there was an ambiguity in the original District Court judgment that needed to be rectified. This ambiguity related to the calculation of the amount owed by the second and third defendants. The court concluded that the correct amount owed, including interest, should be reduced from $72,605.75 to $33,573.36. The court allowed the appeals of the second and third defendants to that extent. However, the appeal of the first defendant was dismissed with costs. The court also made orders regarding the costs of the appeal, directing that the plaintiff applicants were to pay their own costs of the application, and that no order was to be made as to the costs of the defendants as respondents to the application.

In summary, the court allowed the appeals of the second and third defendants to the extent of reducing the amount for which judgment was given against them. The appeal of the first defendant was dismissed, and specific orders were made regarding the costs of the appeal. The court's decision resulted in a reduction of the financial liability for the second and third defendants, while affirming the judgment against the first defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeals by the second and third defendants are allowed to the extent of reducing the amount (including interest) for which judgment was given against them in the District Court from $72,605.75 to $33,573.36

2. No order as to costs of the plaintiff and the second and third defendants of appeal

3. Further order that appeal by the first appellant be dismissed with costs

4. Plaintiff applicants to pay their own costs of this application

5. No order as to the costs of the defendants as respondents to this application

Background

Background to the litigation

168 Wharf St Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) sought to recover a debt from Amstar Learning Pty Ltd (the first defendant) and three individuals (the second, third, and fourth defendants). The plaintiff alleged that the first defendant had failed to pay certain debts and that the second, third, and fourth defendants had acted as guarantors for those debts. The District Court found in favour of the plaintiff and ordered that the second, third, and fourth defendants pay the plaintiff a total of $72,605.75 plus interest. The second and third defendants appealed against the judgment, arguing that the amount owed should be lower due to an alleged mistake in the District Court's order. The plaintiff did not cross-appeal the decision. The second and third defendants submitted that the District Court's order included interest that should not have been included, leading to an overpayment. The plaintiff argued that any error in the District Court's order was not a clerical mistake but rather a result of the court's deliberate decision.

The matter initially came before the District Court where the plaintiff succeeded in its claim against the defendants. The second and third defendants appealed the District Court's judgment to the Supreme Court, arguing that the amount awarded should be reduced due to an alleged error in the calculation of interest. The plaintiff did not cross-appeal the decision. The Supreme Court heard the appeals and made orders regarding the amount owed by the second and third defendants, as well as the costs associated with the appeals.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the District Court's order contained an error in the calculation of interest, warranting a reduction in the amount owed by the second and third defendants.
2. Whether the Supreme Court has the jurisdiction to rectify the District Court's order under the 'slip rule' despite the plaintiff not cross-appealing the decision.
3. Whether the second and third defendants are liable for the full amount of the District Court's judgment including interest, or if the amount should be reduced.
4. What orders should be made regarding the costs of the appeals.

Held
1. The District Court's order contained an error in the calculation of interest, warranting a reduction in the amount owed by the second and third defendants. The appeals by the second and third defendants were allowed to the extent of reducing the amount owed from $72,605.75 to $33,573.36.
2. The Supreme Court has the jurisdiction to rectify the District Court's order under the 'slip rule' despite the plaintiff not cross-appealing the decision. The appeal by the first appellant was dismissed with costs.
3. The second and third defendants are not liable for the full amount of the District Court's judgment including interest. The amount owed is reduced to $33,573.36.
4. The plaintiff applicants are to pay their own costs of this application. No order was made regarding the costs of the plaintiff and the second and third defendants of appeal, and no order was made as to the costs of the defendants as respondents to this application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the ambiguity in the District Court's order regarding the interest calculation and the applicability of the 'slip rule' to rectify the error. The court found that the District Court had made an error in its calculation of interest, leading to an overestimation of the amount owed by the second and third defendants. The court recognised that the 'slip rule' allows for corrections to obvious errors in judgments, even in the absence of a cross-appeal by the plaintiff. This principle was applied to rectify the error in the District Court's order. The court held that the second and third defendants are not liable for the full amount of the judgment including the erroneous interest. The court also considered the costs orders, noting that the plaintiff applicants should bear their own costs for the application, and no costs orders were made regarding the appeals and responses to the application.

The binding legal principle established in this case is that the Supreme Court can use the'slip rule' to correct obvious errors in District Court orders even if the plaintiff did not cross-appeal, provided it does not alter the substantive outcome of the case. The court followed established precedent in applying the'slip rule' for error corrections and distinguished the situation from cases where the error would significantly change the outcome.