Decision
Reasons for decision
A search of the husbands name on the internet showed that he had been listed as attending a [conference] in [Country 5] in March 2018.[31] Both the applicant and her husband denied that he attend a conference in [Country 5]. Given that the information on the website was unrelated to the business of the [Organisation 1] and the list of attendees appeared at best dubious and in any absence of evidence that he in fact did attend the conference, the Tribunal accepts that the applicants evidence that her husband did not attend the conferences in [Country 4] and [Country 5]. [31] >The department received a copy of the husband passport on [date] 2016 via email. The delegate noted that the issuing date of the passport was [date]2015. It was asserted by the applicant and her husband[32] that an acquaintance of the husband arranged his passport and had it backdated to avoid detection upon his departure for the DRC.[33][32] Statement of [Mr A] dated 16 August 2018 paragraph 8[33] Ibid; Delegates decision dated 12 December 2016 @ p.8The country information suggests that obtain a passport with a backdated issuing date is not too difficult in the DRC. According to Documents d'identité, a report from a May 2004 joint mission to the DRC by the Commissioner General for Refugees and Stateless Persons (Commissariat général aux réfugiés et apatrides, CGRA), the French Office for the Protection of Refugees and Stateless Persons (Office français de protection des réfugiés et apatrides, OFPRA) and the Swiss Federal Office for Refugees (Office federal des réfugiés, ODR), Congolese passports are generally obtained by corrupt means with the official procedure through the ministry of foreign affairs being ‘often circumvented’ [34]The country information states that four photos and approximately $150 is enough to obtain a passport under the name of your choice from the ministry. More money can get you more stamps. An established false passport will help you obtain an authentic passport (the same is true for diplomatic passports). An authentic passport is not necessarily an accurate representation of reality, in that a person may obtain an authentic document and then switch the photograph or change the name.[35][34] UNHCR, refworld, Last Updated: Tuesday, 11 December 2018, 09:02 GMT IbidAs a result, based on the country information, the Tribunal accepts that it would be possible for the applicant’s husband to have obtained a passport with a backdated issuing date through an acquaintance within the ministry as claimed.Finally, the delegate referred to the fact that the applicant’s husband passport contained a [Country 2] visa dated [December] 2018. The delegate did not accept that after he was released from detention in December 2015 he could arranged a passport and obtained a [Country 2] visa prior by 18 December 2015. Despite the applicants evidence that her husband was keeping a lower profile before leaving DRC, the delegate found it incongruous that he did resume contact with his wife and family prior to leaving for [Country 2] in April 2016. The Tribunal accepts that, given the applicant’s husband was not freed from detention until December 2015; it would be difficult for him to obtain a passport and [Country 2] visa prior to [date] December 2015. It also accepts that it does appear incongruous he did not resume contact with his wife earlier. However, the Tribunal is not able to make any finding in relation to these matters. Nevertheless, it does observe that by not contacting his wife or leaving DRC earlier the applicant’s husband appears to only added to the applicant’s and their children’s difficulties as asylum seekers in Australia. In any event, while there does appear to be some doubt about the applicant’s husband’s evidence, particularly in relation to his passport, it is not relevant to her claim for a protection visa. Applicants Relevant Convention GroundsThe applicant submits that her claims fall within the scope of the refugee Convention by reason of her membership of a social group specifically women from the DRC and employees of NGO’s from the DRC and by reason of her imputed political opinion.As to the applicants membership of a social group it is necessary that she share a certain characteristic or element which unites her with a particular group which enables them to be set apart from society at large. That is to say, not only must the applicant with her group exhibit some common element, it must unite them, making them a cognisable group within their society.[36] [36] Applicant A v MIEA (1997) 190 CLR 225 per Dawson J at 241, McHugh J at 264-266 and Gummow J at 285.In this case, the applicant’s evidence is that she does not fear being persecuted in the DRC by reason of being a women, but rather because she is an employee of a NGO, namely [Organisation 1]. The Tribunal accepts that applicant’s submission that as an employee of an NGO, she shares a common characteristic which can be differentiated from the community in general. As such, the Tribunal finds that the applicant is a member of a particular social group that is being an employee of an NGO in DRC, namely the [Organisation 1]. Applicant’s well-founded fear. In Chan v MIEA[37] the Court held that ‘well-founded fear’ involves both a subjective and objective element. That is, the definition will be satisfied if an applicant can show genuine fear founded upon a ‘real chance’ of persecution for a Convention stipulated reason. Justice Dawson stated in Chan’s case:The phrase “well-founded fear of being persecuted...” contains both a subjective and an objective requirement. There must be a state of mind - fear of being persecuted - and a basis - well-founded - for that fear.[38] [37] (1989) 169 CLR 379 at 396.[38] (1989) 169 CLR 379 at 396. See also MIEA v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at 263 per Brennan CJ, Toohey, McHugh and Gummow JJ.The subjective element of ‘well-founded fear’ concerns the state of mind of the applicant. That is, whether an applicant has a genuine fear is a question of fact. In this case based on the evidence of the applicant the Tribunal accepts that the applicant has a subjective fear of being harmed by the Taliban in the event he is returned to Pakistan. To hold a ‘well found fear of persecution’ on an objective basis the applicant’s claims must be more than merely plausible or credible. In Chan v MIEA, Dawson J [39]stated:“Well-founded” must mean something more than plausible, for an applicant may have a plausible belief which may be demonstrated, upon facts unknown to him or her, to have no foundation.’[39] Chan v MIEA (1989) 169 CLR 379 per Dawson J at p.397In MIEA v Guo, the Court stated that: [40]‘Conjecture or surmise has no part to play in determining whether a fear is well‑founded. A fear is “well-founded” when there is a real substantial basis for it. As Chan shows, a substantial basis for a fear may exist even though there is far less than a 50 per cent chance that the object of the fear will eventuate. But no fear can be well-founded for the purpose of the Convention unless the evidence indicates a real ground for believing that the applicant for refugee status is at risk of persecution. A fear of persecution is not well-founded if it is merely assumed or if it is mere speculation.’[40] MIEA v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559 at 572; cf MIEA v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at 293.In this case, the applicant claims that as a result of her work with [Organisation 1] she became aware of many instances where women had been harmed by prominent male members of the community in order to intimidate and coerce them. She claims that in or about 2011 she began to receive threatening phone call demanding that she stop assisting [Organisation 1]. Nevertheless she continued her work assisting those vulnerable members of her community in a belief that it would make a real difference to her community. She says that on or about [date] April 2013 she and her sister were attacked and raped by men from the authorities. During the course of the attack she was struck by a machete. Her evidence was that her brother was taken and has not been seen since. The applicant’s description of the incident during the course of the hearing was detailed and compelling. She described in detail the events that occurred and the circumstances in which her brother was taken from her home. The applicant’s evidence was that after the incident she attended a local dispensary to receive medical treatment. She did not go to the hospital as she says she was ashamed and scared due to the fact that it was authorities who were responsible for the attack on her and her brother abduction. The applicant provided a report for [Organisation 1] dated [July] 2018.[41] The report concludes that the applicant presented with sadness and distresses associated with recalling the traumatic events, intrusive memories, sleep disruption, frequent headaches and physical tension. The report states that the applicant manages well in her daily life but she experiences significant grief as a result of the separation of her family and as a result of past events, inducing the disappearance of her brother. The applicant relies on her faith in dealing with her circumstances and has suffered stress as a result of the determination of her protection visa application. [41] [Source deleted]. In addition, the country information indicates that gender based violence is prolific in the DRC and that individual who are workers for NGO’s are subjected to serious harm. The country information states that the SSF continue to unlawfully kill, beat, intimidate and arbitrarily arrest and detain domestic violence advocates and domestic NGO workers, particularly when the NGO’s reported on or supported victims of abuse by the SSF or reported on the illegal exploitation of natural resources in the east of the DRC. In this case the applicant has assisted victims of sexual assault and liaised with international community, particularly through her attendance at international conferences.[42] Accordingly the Tribunal finds that the applicant has a well-founded fear of being persecuted as a result of being a worker for an NGO (and in particular a female worker for an NGO) in the event that she returns to DRC. [42] United States Department of State, Country Reports on Human Rights Practices 2017, democratic republic of Congo, 20 April 2018 >Therefore, based on the applicants own evidence and the country information, the Tribunal finds that that the applicant was raped and assaulted as claimed. Accordingly, it finds that there is a real chance the applicant will be seriously harmed and as such does have a ‘well-founded’ of persecution in the event that she returns to the DRC. Applicant imputed political opinion The applicant claims that as part of her role with [Organisation 1] she became aware of many instances where women had been harmed by prominent male members of the community. He evidence was that in or about 2011 she began receiving threats demanding that she stop assisting the plight of women in her community. She says that many other employee in the foundation also received threats. Nevertheless, she continued to work with [Organisation 1] in the belief that she would make a difference to her community. The country information states that authorities sometimes detain journalists, activists and politicians when they publically criticize the government.[43] In addition, registration of NGO’s by the authorities is often a burdensome process designed to impede that activities of NGO’s that are seen to be acting against the government interests.[44] In this case the applicant was an active member of [Organisation 1] in assisting women who have the victim of domestic violence and as a result of activities against women by the authorities. The applicant had been an advocate against such violence against women in the DRC within the International community at conferences in [Country 3], [Country 1] and Australia. As such she is likely to attract the attention of the authorities upon her return to DRC. The fact that applicant has been in Australia and sought protection means that she will be seen as working against the government and come under the scrutiny of the authorities and be detained in the event that she returns to DRC. [43] Op Cit @ p.13[44] Op Cit @p.18As such, based on the available country information the Tribunal finds that there is a real chance the applicant will be seriously harmed by reason of her imputed political opinion in the event he returns to DRC. Accordingly, the Tribunal finds that there is not a real chance the applicant will be seriously harmed by reason of his mental condition as a result of his return to Pakistan. Therefore having considered the applicant’s claims singularly and cumulatively, the Tribunal finds that that there are substantial grounds for believing that, as a consequence of being removed from Australia to DRC, there is a real chance that the applicant will suffer serious harm.The Tribunal is therefore satisfied that the applicant does satisfy the criterion set out in s.36(2)(a) for a protection visa and as such he is a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees Convention. Applicant’s complementary protection claimThe applicant claims that, without conceding in any way his claims under the Refugee Convention, that the same factual matrix may invoke Australia’s protection obligations under complementary protection criteria pursuant to s.36(2)(aa) of the Act. Accordingly, the Tribunal has also considered the application of s.36(2)(aa) to the applicant’s circumstances. That is, the Tribunal has considered if the applicant faces a real risk of significant harm from the authorities on return his return to DRC on the basis that she works for a NGO in DRC and her imputed political opinion.For the reason set out above the Tribunal accepts that there is a real risk the applicant will suffer significant harm in the event she returns to DRC. Having considered her evidence and the available country information the Tribunal accepts her claims and finds that there is a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm pursuant to section 36(2A) of the Act by reason that she works for an NGO in DRC (and in particular as a woman) as well as for her actual or imputed political opinion.At no stage did the applicant advance any other reason, such as his race, nationality or religion, in her written or oral claims that the applicant is owed Australia’s protection obligations. The Tribunal therefore finds there are no more residual claims, including based on the applicant’s accepted circumstances, to be considered.Having regard to all the circumstances and findings above, considered individually and cumulatively, the Tribunal finds that there are grounds for believing that, as a necessary and foreseeable consequence of the applicant being removed from Australia to Iran, there is a real risk he will suffer significant harm as required by s36(2)(aa).CONCLUSIONSFor the reasons given above, the Tribunal is satisfied that the applicants are people in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (together, the Refugees Convention, or the Convention).Having concluded that the applicant does meet the refugee criterion in s.36(2)(a), the Tribunal has considered the alternative criterion in s.36(2)(aa) and is satisfied that the applicants are people in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations under s.36(2)(aa).The second, third fourth and fifth applicants satisfies s.36(2) on the basis of being a members of the same family unit as people who satisfy s.36(2)(a) or (aa) and who hold a protection visa. Accordingly, the applicants do satisfy the criterion in s.36(2).DECISIONThe Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the applicant satisfies s.36(2)(a) of the Migration Act.Jason PennellMember