1514908 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

1514908 (Refugee) [2017] AATA 2962 (22 November 2017)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

CASE NUMBER:  1514908

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                  Botswana

MEMBER:Jane Marquard

DATE:22 November 2017

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicant a Protection visa.

Statement made on 22 November 2017 at 8:08am

CATCHWORDS

Refugee – Protection Visa – Botswana – Particular social group – Lesbians in Botswana – Fear of persecution – Fear of ostracism – Fear of violence – Discrimination – Claims not supported by country information – Repeated returns to home country – Level of harm not significant

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, ss 5(1), 5AAA, 91R, 91S, 36, 65, 499
Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2

CASES
MIEA v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559
Nagalingam v MILGEA (1992) 38 FCR 191
Prasad v MIEA (1985) 6 FCR 155
Applicant S v MIMA (2004) 217 CLR 387
Applicant A v MIEA (1997) 190 CLR 225
Appellant S396/2002 v MIMA (2003) 216 CLR 473
MIMA v Haji Ibrahim (2000) 204 CLR 1

MIMIA v Kord (2002) 125 FCR 68
MIAC v SZQRB [2013] FCAFC 33
SZRSN v MIAC [2013] FMCA 78
SZRSN v MIAC [2013] FCA 751
SZRUT v MIAC [2013] FCCA 368
SZRUT v MIBP [2013] FCA 1276
SZSFX v MIBP [2013] FCCA 1309

Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been omitted from this decision pursuant to section 431 of the Migration Act 1958 and replaced with generic information which does not allow the identification of an applicant, or their relative or other dependant.

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. The applicant was born in [year], and is a citizen of Botswana.

  2. She first arrived in Australia [in] July 2002 on a student TU 573 visa. She remained on student visas until [March] 2008.

  3. [In] July 2008 the applicant was granted an Interdependency (same sex) Partner Temporary UK -826 Visa. [In] August 2010 her application for a Partner (Residence) (Class BS) visa was refused.

  4. She applied for a protection visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act) [in] September 2013.

  5. A delegate of the Minister for Immigration, the Department of Immigration (the Department) refused to grant the visa [in] October 2015.

  6. The applicant attended a hearing before the Tribunal to give evidence and provide arguments, on 17 August 2017.

    CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

  7. The applicant provided the following information about her background and claims to the Department and Tribunal:

    ·She was born in Gaberone, and is a Motswana. Her mother worked in [a company], and her father ran [a] business. They are now retired, and still living in Gaberone. She has a brother and sister in Gaberone. She is not sure if her brother is working as she has not spoken to him for seven years, as she felt betrayed by him. She grew up being best friends with him. She tried to talk to him about her break-up with her partner, as she thought that he was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 1514908 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2962
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a citizen of Botswana, sought a protection visa based on her fear of persecution due to her lesbian identity. She claimed that if returned to Botswana, she would face harm from authorities and private individuals, including arrest, imprisonment, social ostracism, and violence. The dispute centred on whether her fears were well-founded and met the criteria for protection under Australian law. The case was heard by Jane Marquard.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of her membership in a particular social group, namely lesbians in Botswana. This required the court to assess the credibility of the applicant's claims, the level of harm she might face, and whether such harm was significant enough to engage Australia's protection obligations. The court also considered whether the applicant met the complementary protection criteria.

The court found the applicant to be a credible witness but was not satisfied that country information supported her claims of persecution. While acknowledging that same-sex relationships are illegal in Botswana, the court noted that the applicant had made six visits to Botswana between 2002 and 2009 to visit her children without incident. This repeated, safe return to her home country, coupled with a lack of substantial evidence of significant harm or a real chance of persecution, led the court to conclude that her fear was not well-founded to the necessary legal standard. The court applied the principles of refugee law, which require a well-founded fear of persecution, and found that the level of harm described did not reach the threshold for protection.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant attended a hearing before the Tribunal to give evidence and provide arguments, on 17 August 2017.CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The applicant provided the following information about her background and claims to the Department and Tribunal:·She was born in Gaberone, and is a Motswana. Her mother worked in [a company], and her father ran [a] business. They are now retired, and still living in Gaberone. She has a brother and sister in Gaberone. She is not sure if her brother is working as she has not spoken to him for seven years, as she felt betrayed by him. She grew up being best friends with him. She tried to talk to him about her break-up with her partner, as she thought that he was the closest person to her. She thought that he would have explained her choice of sexual preference to their parents, but he did not. His reaction was a shock to her, as he opposed her sexual choices. He said that she should be prayed for, and was possessed by demons. He said that he knew somewhere where she could go and get cleansed. Her sister is supportive, but could not be vocal about it as her parents do not support her being a lesbian;·Her family are Catholic and she is “a little partial to it”. She does go to church in Australia. When she grew up her family went to church every week;·She attended a private high school in Gaberone, and then [a college] in [a town]. She [studied] at a college in Gaberone, from [year] to [year]. After finishing her course, she studied in Australia, doing [further studies], then [a subsequent course], but she did not finish this course. She did complete a course in [another field], and now is studying [another course];·She has two children who are living with her parents in Botswana. Her son was born in [year], and her daughter was born in [year];·She identifies as a lesbian and fears harm from authorities and private individuals because she is a lesbian;·She knows a handful of lesbians in Botswana but has no close friends who are lesbians;·She first started identifying herself as a lesbian when she was at school, but she had no real definition for the feelings she had. She did not act on her sexual preference for girls, but she felt herself getting attracted to girls. Lesbianism was not a subject of conversation. There were some girls at school who she suspected might have been lesbians, but she never asked. She knew that her feelings towards girls were different to friendship, because of the emotional side of her feelings. There were girls who made her heart beat fast. She did not go out with boys at school;·It was only in 1998 or 1999 that she first admitted to herself that she had sexual preferences for women. She was approached by a [woman] at that time, and felt nervous as she did not know what her feelings were. She was in [Country 1] when she started having a relationship with this woman, and she did not think about Catholicism or her family. Around that time she visited [Country 1] often, and it was easier for LGBTI people to socialise, and meet each other there. This was her first serious relationship. The relationship was on and off for a year, as she was living in Botswana. She would visit her in [a city in Country 1]. Her girlfriend was not open about her sexual preferences. Some of their friends knew, but her girlfriend would not tell other people outside their circle of friends. They would meet up at her apartment. At that time she did not think about the law. She can’t remember what she felt about attitudes in Botswana, and did not think about what her family felt. She had heard people in Botswana talk about gay and lesbians, but most people she knew who were gay or lesbian lived in [Country 1]. The relationship ended because her parents questioned why she was always going to [Country 1]. It put a strain on the relationship, which fizzled out in time. Her parents gave her an option to move out or go to school, so she decided to go to school. She then went to Gaberone. She was at college, and around 1998 she had a boyfriend, but it “felt weird”. She was with him for three months. The interaction was very different and it did not feel as “smooth” as with a girl;·She became pregnant to this boyfriend and her son was born in [year]. She had been with him for [duration], when he was conceived. After that, when her son was [age], she saw the boyfriend again, as in between he had moved to [Country 1], and they were not an official couple. Although they conceived her daughter he was not her boyfriend. He did ask her to marry but she did not like him “in that way”. She was [age] years old, and he was [age] and it was not the life that she wanted. She is not in touch with him. When her children came to visit her in Australia, her daughter wanted to understand why her friends live with their parents, whereas her parents are separated, and she had to disclose to her that she preferred women. Her children had not seen their father when they came to Australia in 2005/6, but they did see him later and did not get along well;·She has not had other relationships with men since the relationship with the father of her children;·While she was looking after her young children she did not have other relationships with women either. She then left her children with her parents and came to Australia;·She did tell her friends in Botswana about her relationship with the women in [Country 1], and they thought it was funny. She did not tell her parents or siblings. It was not kept as a secret, but there was not much to tell. Her sister was only in primary school;·She told her parents that she was lesbian when she applied for the partner visa. At the time she did not think her mother thought about it properly and took it that she and her partner were just friends. She did not talk to her father much about it; ·After her children returned to Botswana following their visit to Australia, they told her parents about the applicant and her partner living together, sleeping in the same room and calling each other “babe”. She thinks that this was when the reality dawned on her mother. But she only had a proper conversation with her mother, after her partner broke up with her, and the applicant was distraught. They had many conversations and her mother thought that now she could get a boyfriend. She thought it was a phase the applicant had passed through. The applicant did not talk to her father, but she knows that her mother brought her father and brother to the table to discuss it. They are active and committed Catholics so they did not approve or understand, and consider lesbianism to be sinful. They thought it was a phase and she would stop when she matured;·Three weeks after she arrived in Australia, she had a relationship with a woman she met at a gay and lesbian nightclub in [a suburb]. She did not know people in [the city where she was staying] so just went to this club. It was near the [school] she was attending. She had a relationship with this woman for six months;·She had two other relationships with women before meeting her long-term partner, [Ms A]. In 2004 she met [Ms A] through a gay friend who lived [near] her house. They fell in love and began a long-term relationship. They were together for six and a half years. She met [Ms A]’s family. After three years she was granted the first stage temporary Subclass 826 visa;·She told her children about her relationship with [Ms A] when they came to Australia to visit. Her son said that he was happy if she was, and her daughter asked questions, and she does not really know how she feels;·She returned to Botswana in order to obtain a police clearance for her visa application. Before she did so, she spoke to a [a lawyer]. He told her not to tell the authorities that she was applying for a same-sex visa or they would not give her police clearance, so she said she was applying for a work-related visa;·Towards the end of 2009 she met a woman called XX while working at [a business]. They became friends and XX met [Ms A]. She later found out that [Ms A] was unfaithful to her with XX. As a result she and [Ms A] separated and ended the relationship;·Her parents were pleased that they had broken up. She argued with them and told them she would not “become straight”. They were angry and did not talk to her for seven or eight months. Eventually they regained contact as the lack of communication was difficult for her son to deal with and he encouraged them to talk to her. However, their relationship is still strained. She knows that her mother reads the Bible to her children all the time, and she fears that this is because of her sexuality. She speaks to her parents a few times a month about the children and she pays for their school fees;·Her permanent partner visa was refused as she and [Ms A] had broken up. She still applied to the Migration Review Tribunal as she was misinformed, thinking that because they had had a long relationship, she could still apply. The Migration Review Tribunal affirmed the decision in December 2012. The decision of the Migration Review Tribunal indicates that she believed that the Department had told her that she could still be eligible for a visa;·She has had other relationships with women since her break-up with [Ms A]. She met a girl at a mutual friend’s [party]. She attends lesbian clubs [where] they hold events;·She did not think of applying for protection earlier as she did not consider that she was at great risk, prior to her relationship with [Ms A]. She intended to finish her studies, and return home to a double life, visiting [Country 1] in order to socialise with other lesbians. However now her status is known by her family and children, and she could not slip under the radar. She has lived her life in Australia in a way that is tolerant and free. She does not have to try and be someone else, and will have no freedom. If she goes back, she does not think she can be in the closet and it will put the spotlight on her. She fears discrimination and judgment. She fears for her children’s safety. She would want to explain her sexual orientation more fully to them. She fears that they will tell their friends, and just generally stories will get around to their friend’s parents as well. Children can be mean, and she does not want them to be beaten up for having a lesbian mother, or being teased;·It is illegal to have same sex relationships in Botswana. The authorities would arrest and imprison her if they knew about her orientation. She also fears social ostracism; and·The applicant provided a copy of a letter from her [father], dated [in] December 2012. He stated that the relationship between father and daughter had been severed. He said that he is [religious] and preached that the life she leads is not what he likes, as men should marry women.

Decision

Reasons for decision

When asked at the Tribunal hearing if there was anything further she wished to submit or add, she said that she hopes the decision goes well. She said that she has taken a very long time to get to this place, and hoped the Tribunal would consider everything carefully.Department’s decision The Department found the applicant to be a credible witness. However the Department was not satisfied that the country sources indicated that she would be persecuted or that she met the complementary protection criteria. Furthermore, the Department noted that the applicant visited Botswana on six occasions between 2002 to 2009, to visit her children, and there were no problems during these visits. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE In coming to a decision, the Tribunal has taken into account information on the Department file, evidence before this Tribunal and independent country information about Botswana. A summary of the relevant law is set out at Attachment A.Nationality The applicant provided a copy of her passport and gave evidence that she was a citizen of, and born in, Botswana. It was clear that she was familiar with the culture and geography of Botswana, and the Tribunal accepts on the evidence before it that she is a citizen of Botswana, and that Botswana is the receiving country for the purposes of the complementary protection provisions.Findings of fact When assessing claims the Tribunal must make findings of fact in relation to the claims. In doing so, the Tribunal is mindful of the difficulties faced by refugee applicants, including issues related to the use of interpreters, nervousness and anxiety in a Tribunal environment, and stress caused by separation from home and family. There may also be memory issues resulting from the lapse of time. The benefit of the doubt should be given to an applicant who is generally credible but unable to substantiate all of his or her claims. The Tribunal is sensitive to the various cultural differences which can impact on an applicant’s responses to questioning, as discussed in the Tribunal’s ‘Guidance on the Assessment of Credibility’. All this is taken into account in these findings. Given that it is often difficult for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and/or intersex (LGBTI) people to talk about private matters concerning their sexuality, the Tribunal has also utilised the Department’s guidelines for assessing claims related to sexual orientation and gender identity.[1][1] Department of Immigration and Border Protection, “Annexure 5: Assessing Claims related to sexual orientation and gender identity” In submissions to the Tribunal, the applicant said that she had missed out on many years of seeing her children and had foregone seeing them grow. She said that she had suffered from depression and been on anti-depressants since 2012 as a result of the stress and anxiety of the process. At the Tribunal hearing she confirmed that she was not feeling depressed on that day, and was not on any medication which would impact on her giving evidence. However she stated that she had been depressed and on anti-depressant medication since 2012. The Tribunal has taken this into consideration in assessing the claims.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.