Explanatory Statement
Issued by the authority of the Minister for Defence Personnel
Subject – Defence Act 1903
Defence Legislation Amendment (Instrument Making) Act 2017
Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 2018
The Defence Act 1903 (the Act) prescribes the control, administration, constitution and service of the Australian Defence Force.
Subsection 124(1) of the Act provides that the Governor-General may make regulations not inconsistent with the Act, prescribing all matters which by the Act are required or permitted to be prescribed, or which are necessary or convenient to be prescribed, for securing the good government of the Defence Force, or for carrying out or giving effect to the Act.
Paragraph 124(1)(gc) and subsection 124(2A) of the Act provide for the making of regulations addressing inquiries concerning the Defence Force.
Purpose of the Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 2018
The Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 2018 (the Regulations) prescribe matters providing for, and in relation to, inquiries concerning the Defence Force. Inquiries under these Regulations are not ends in themselves. Their purpose is to facilitate the making of decisions relating to the Defence Force by providing the most important enabler of a good decision—accurate, reliable and timely information.
Inquiries under these Regulations are designed to assist command in securing the proper functioning of the Defence Force; they are not about individuals as such and are not an external accountability mechanism. The legal powers and protections provided under these Regulations, such as the ability to compel the production of evidence, enable robust and thorough investigations that furnish commanders and other Defence leaders with the facts and circumstances associated with an incident or circumstance. Internal inquiries are critical to supporting informed decision-making by command about complex incidents that can affect all aspects of the Defence Force.
The Regulations provide for two flexible inquiry formats: a Commission of Inquiry and an Inquiry Officer Inquiry. The former will be used for higher level matters that are particularly complex and sensitive, while the latter will be used to inquire into more routine matters.
The Regulations replace the Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 1985 (the old Regulations), which allowed for five separate forms of inquiry: General Courts of Inquiry, Boards of Inquiry, Combined Boards of Inquiry, Chief of the Defence Force (CDF) Commissions of Inquiry and Inquiry Officer Inquiries.
The old Regulations contained detailed content regarding procedural aspects of the different types of inquiries. This had the capacity to prolong inquiries and impede the making of timely decisions by command.
In addition, some of the forms of inquiry have become redundant or obsolescent over time. For instance, General Courts of Inquiry and Combined Courts of Inquiry have never been used. While in 2016, the function of inquiring into Service-related deaths previously performed by CDF Commissions of Inquiries was transferred to the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force (IGADF) and is now conducted under the Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Regulation 2016. Additionally, some matters that had frequently been the subject of inquiries under the old Regulations are now dealt with using other fact finding mechanisms.
Overview
The Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 2018 were enacted under the Defence Act 1903, which governs the control, administration, constitution, and service of the Australian Defence Force. The primary objective of the Regulations is to prescribe matters providing for, and in relation to, inquiries concerning the Defence Force. This includes facilitating the making of decisions relating to the Defence Force by ensuring the availability of accurate, reliable, and timely information. The Regulations were introduced to address the need for a more streamlined and efficient inquiry process within the Defence Force, replacing the Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 1985, which had become overly complex and restrictive. The new Regulations consolidate five different types of inquiry mechanisms into two formats: Commissions of Inquiry and Inquiry Officer Inquiries, providing greater flexibility in internal decision-making while retaining essential protections against unfairness.
Scope and Application
The Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 2018, made under the Defence Act 1903, govern inquiries concerning the Australian Defence Force (ADF). These regulations aim to facilitate command decision-making by providing accurate, reliable, and timely information, enabling commanders to make informed decisions about complex incidents that may affect the ADF. The regulations introduce two flexible inquiry formats: Commissions of Inquiry for higher-level matters and Inquiry Officer Inquiries for more routine matters. They consolidate the previous five inquiry formats into these two, enhancing flexibility and efficiency. These inquiries are not external accountability mechanisms but are designed to assist in the proper functioning of the Defence Force. The regulations also address the abrogation of the common law privilege against self-incrimination for oral testimony, ensuring that the privilege is balanced with protections against unfair use of admissions of wrongdoing. Furthermore, the regulations outline procedures for the conduct of inquiries, powers of inquiry officials, and the protection of witnesses and officials from civil or criminal proceedings, ensuring that inquiries are conducted fairly and efficiently while safeguarding the rights of individuals involved. The regulations also detail offences related to non-compliance with inquiry procedures, unauthorised disclosures, and contempt, with penalties set at a maximum of 20 penalty units.
Key Provisions
- The Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 2018 outline the procedures and mechanisms for conducting inquiries concerning the Australian Defence Force (ADF). These regulations, made under the Defence Act 1903, are designed to facilitate the making of decisions relating to the Defence Force by providing accurate, reliable, and timely information. They establish two formats for inquiries: Commissions of Inquiry and Inquiry Officer Inquiries, which cater to different levels of complexity and sensitivity. The regulations replace the Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 1985, which allowed for five different types of inquiries, with the aim of promoting flexibility, efficiency, and accountability in internal decision-making.
- The regulations detail the appointment, conduct, and termination of Commissions of Inquiry and Inquiry Officer Inquiries, including the powers of the appointing authorities to manage these processes. They also outline the rights and protections for witnesses and officials involved in these inquiries, such as the abrogation of the privilege against self-incrimination in oral testimony provided to Commissions of Inquiries and inquiry officers, respectively. However, the regulations provide significant protections against the use of information obtained in subsequent criminal, disciplinary, and civil trials.
- Additionally, the regulations set out various offences and penalties for breaches, including failing to comply with notices, giving false evidence, and unauthorised disclosure of information. The maximum penalty for these offences is 20 penalty units. The regulations also include provisions for the protection of inquiry officials and witnesses from civil or criminal proceedings, ensuring that they can undertake their duties free from intimidation or threats.
- Furthermore, the regulations address transitional, application, and saving provisions to ensure that inquiries under the old regulations can continue and that the records of inquiries conducted under the old regulations continue to be protected. This includes provisions for the continuation of incomplete inquiries, the continued application of certain protection and immunity provisions, and the saving of directions relating to the disclosure of certain evidence.
- Overall, the Defence (Inquiry) Regulations 2018 aim to provide a robust framework for conducting inquiries that support informed decision-making by command, while ensuring fairness, efficiency, and accountability in the process.
- Area of Law
- Defence & Military Law
- Instrument
- Regulation
- Concepts
- Definitions & Interpretation
- Commencement Provisions
- Regulatory Standards
- Offence Provisions
- Civil Penalty Provisions
- Enforcement Powers