| WILLS' TRUSTEES |
| v. |
| CAIRNGORM CANOEING AND SAILING SCHOOL LIMITED |
The defenders are a company incorporated in 1969, of which the sole director and principal shareholder is a Mr Freshwater. The principal activity of the company is the running of courses in canoeing and sailing. These provide both instruction and recreation to visitors to the area and make a useful contribution to the amenities available for the many people who take holidays on Speyside. The defenders' headquarters are at Loch Insh, a loch, the inlet and outlet of which are the Spey, situated many miles up stream from Knockando. The defenders have a contractual arrangement with the Forestry Commission, the proprietors of Loch Insh, under which, in return for an annual payment, they are permitted inter alia to put a restricted number of canoes, sailing boats etc. on to Loch Insh. In carrying out their canoeing courses the defenders have made a practice of taking parties of pupils on trips of varying lengths and duration down the river. Sometimes these have involved passing through the Knockando stretch. Mr Freshwater estimated the frequency of trips as far as Aberlour, a few miles downstream of Knockando, at six to ten times a year. The defender's season for canoeing is confined to about twelve weeks in the Summer. The Spey is suitable for canoeing and is visited for that purpose by canoeists from all parts of Britain. Some of these, like the defenders' parties, are in well organised and controlled groups, which endeavour to cause as little disturbance to other interests as possible, while others are less particular in this respect.
The Spey is one of the finest salmon angling rivers in the country and many of the private beats, including the Knockando stretch, fetch considerable rents and are highly assessed for rating. Part of the salmon angling on the river is rented by one or more local angling associations.
As was no doubt inevitable with the growth of canoeing, differences have arisen between the canoeing and angling interests. In 1970 meetings took place at which both canoeing and angling interests were represented and at which the possibility of working out an acceptable modus vivendi was discussed, but little progress was made as there was a fundamental difference as to the starting point of any negotiations. Representatives of the canoeing interests maintained that the public had a right in law to canoe down the Spey, while the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Wills' Trs v Cairngorm Canoeing and Sailing School Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1976] UKHL 8
- Decision Date