Triple Point Technology, Inc (Respondent) v PTT Public Company Ltd (Appellant)

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

Trinity Term

[2021] UKSC 29

On appeal from: [2019] EWCA Civ 230

Appellant Respondent

James Howells QC Nicholas Maciolek

Paul Darling QC

Andrew Stafford QC
Nathaniel Barber

(Instructed by Watson (Instructed by Kobre &
Farley & Williams LLP) Kim (UK) LLP (London))

LADY ARDEN: (with whom Lord Leggatt and Lord Burrows agree)

Outline of the software contract in issue, the issues on this appeal and my determination of them

1. This is an appeal concerning a software contract which provides for the implementation and provision of a software-based business system. The appeal raises general issues about a provision for liquidated damages and specific issues about the limitation of remedies under this contract.

2. The software contract (“the CTRM Contract”), dated 8 February 2013, was made between the appellant, PTT Public Company Ltd (“PTT”) and Triple Point Technology, Inc (“Triple Point”) for the design, installation (by data transmission), maintenance and licencing of software to assist PTT to carry on its business in commodity trading. Triple Point had to customise its proprietary software for commodity trading and risk management to the needs of PTT, and it was remunerated by reference to “milestones” set by the contract at which specified work had been done and steps completed. Triple Point also agreed to enter into maintenance, upgrade, replacement, online support and staff training obligations. It further agreed to enter into a perpetual licence. The terms of the Perpetual License Agreement (“PLA”), which formed part of the CTRM Contract, which was based on Triple Point’s standard form licence agreement and contained various warranties as to the quality of the software, were annexed to the main part of the CTRM Contract (“the Main Part”). There were provisions for checking that the software provided conformed to specification, ie achieved the agreed “functionality” or the purposes and range of functions that it was designed to perform: it is obvious that this was an important part of the CTRM Contract and that software defects could cause enormous financial and other harm to PTT.

3. The CTRM Contract was not, therefore, simply a standard-form contract but was tailored to the requirements of this particular project. The governing law was English law. The provisions of the Main Part provided that, in the event of inconsistency between the PLA or other annexed parts, and the Main Part, the terms of the Main Part were to prevail (article 29).

4. The parties agreed substantial limitations on the remedies available in the event of delay and so on. Liquidated damages were available for delay (article 5.3 of the Main Part). There was a non-financial remedy for certain other breaches of contract in that in specified circumstances Triple Point had an opportunity to cure the defect. If it failed to do so, damages were payable but were limited to the fees paid for the relevant work (article 12.3 of the Main Part).

5. The principal issue (“the availability of liquidated damages issue”) on this appeal is whether PTT is entitled under the CTRM Contract to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Triple Point Technology, Inc (Respondent) v PTT Public Compa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] UKSC 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns a software contract between PTT Public Company Ltd (the Appellant) and Triple Point Technology, Inc (the Respondent). The contract involved the design, installation, maintenance, and licensing of software to assist PTT in its commodity trading business. The appeal raises issues concerning the availability of liquidated damages and the limitation of remedies under the contract. The primary issues on appeal were whether PTT was entitled to liquidated damages for delays in work that was never completed, whether damages for Triple Point's negligent breach of contract were within the limitation of liability exception for negligence, and whether liquidated damages fell within the limitation of liability cap. The Court of Appeal held that PTT was only entitled to liquidated damages for completed work, that the negligence exception did not cover negligent breaches of contract, and that liquidated damages were subject to the liability cap. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal on the first and second issues but dismissed it on the third issue. The Court held that the contract's liquidated damages clause should be interpreted to provide a remedy for delay in completion, regardless of whether the work was ultimately accepted by PTT. Regarding the negligence exception, the Court found that it should be given its ordinary meaning, including damages for negligent breaches of contract. However, the Court upheld the Court of Appeal's decision that liquidated damages fell within the liability cap. As a result, PTT is entitled to recover the full amount of damages assessed by the judge without any limitation of liability.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established