Michaelmas Term
[2016] UKPC 31
Privy Council Appeal No 0057 of 2015
JUDGMENT
Tex Services Ltd (Appellant) v Shibani Knitting Co Ltd (In Receivership) (Respondent) (Mauritius)
From the Supreme Court of Mauritius
before
Lord Mance
Lord Wilson
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hughes
Lord Hodge
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
10 November 2016
Heard on 17 October 2016
|
Appellant Nandkishore Ramburn SC Moorari Gujadhur Keertisha Servansingh (Instructed by M A Law Solicitors) |
|
Respondent P Maxime Sauzier SC (Instructed by ENSafrica (Mauritius)) |
LORD MANCE:
1. This appeal turns on the proper interpretation of a letter agreement dated 11 June 2007 relating to the production and delivery of cashmere pullovers made, in unusual circumstances, between Shibani Knitting Co Ltd in receivership (“Shibani”) as suppliers and Tex Services Ltd (“Tex”). The pullovers were destined for John Lewis in the United Kingdom. The issue is whether the “CMT” (literally: cut, make and trim) price specified in that agreement was inclusive or exclusive of treatment making the pullovers machine washable.
2. Originally, Shibani had contracted with John Lewis to supply John Lewis, for whom Tex were acting as agents. After going into receivership in or about late February 2007, Shibani initially assured Tex and John Lewis that its operation and deliveries would continue as normal. Its receivers were keen to maintain its business with a substantial workforce of about 1,500 people, no doubt with a view to selling as a going concern (as appears to have occurred in or about June 2007). By April 2007, however, Shibani was having difficulties with its bank in financing raw materials. Tex then agreed to provide it with finance by opening a letter of credit for £407,484 (c 25m Rupees) on 3 April 2007. Later, at meetings on 11 and 16 May 2007, Shibani said that, even with this backing, its bank was still not prepared to finance the purchase of yarn. Tex was evidently concerned to maintain the supply, doubtless concerned for its own goodwill with John Lewis. It was in these circumstances agreed by the letter dated 11 June 2007, firstly, that Tex would itself buy the yarn from the Chinese supplier, Ningbo, secondly, that Shibani would produce the order for Tex and, thirdly, that Tex would as a principal sell and export it to its client, John Lewis.
3. The letter dated 11 June 2007 was addressed by Shibani’s receivers and managers (members of Ernst & Young) to Mr Bernard Maigrot, the principal of Tex, and signed or initialled by both parties. It reads as follows:
“Your Cashmere Order for John Lewis
Further to our various endeavours to solution the problem of yarn sourcing for your order mentioned above, we have mutually come up with a plan as follows;
1. Tex will buy the yarn from supplier Ningbo Consinee in China;
2. Shibani will produce the order on a ‘CMT’ basis, knit and make-up only, plus accessories sourcing and machine washable;
3. Tex will sell and export to its client, John Lewis;
4. Tex will pay a CMT price…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tex Services Ltd v Shibani Knitting Co Ltd (Mauritius) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] UKPC 31
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
AI summary not yet generated for this case.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.