Stone & Rolls Ltd (In Liq) v Moore Stephens (a firm)

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read
HOUSE OF LORDS SESSION 2008–09
[2009] UKHL 30

on appeal from:[2008] EWCA Crim 1740

OPINIONS

OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL

FOR JUDGMENT IN THE CAUSE

R v Islam (Respondent) (on appeal from the Court of Appeal Criminal Division)

Appellate Committee

Lord Hope of Craighead


Lord Walker of Gestingthorpe
Baroness Hale of Richmond
Lord Mance
Lord Neuberger of Abbotsbury

Counsel

Appellants:  Respondent:
David Perry QC Cheryl Drew
Mark Sutherland Williams Abdul Gofur
Charlotte Hadfied (Instructed by Crescent & Co)

(Instructed by Revenue and Customs Prosecutions

Office)

Hearing date:

23 MARCH 2009

ON
WEDNESDAY 10 JUNE 2009

HOUSE OF LORDS

OPINIONS OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL FOR JUDGMENT

IN THE CAUSE

R v Islam (Respondent) (on appeal from the Court of Appeal

Criminal Division)

[2009] UKHL 30

LORD HOPE OF CRAIGHEAD

My Lords,

1. This case raises a short but important point about the meaning of the expression “market value” in section 79 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (“POCA 2002”). The relevant subsections provide as follows:

“(1) This section applies for the purpose of deciding the
value at any time of property then held by a person.
(2) Its value is the market value of the property at that
time.”

The question on which the House granted leave to appeal has focussed the issue in this way:

“For the purpose of calculating a defendant’s benefit, as distinct from the available amount, in confiscation proceedings under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, must goods of an illegal nature obtained by him be treated as having no value?”

2. My noble and learned friend Lord Mance has described the facts of this case and the statutory background. I gratefully adopt his account of them, and I agree with the reasons that he gives for allowing the appeal and answering this question in the negative. I have not found the issue an easy one to resolve however, and as we are not all of the same

view I should like to set out briefly in my own words the reasons that
have led me to this conclusion.

3. Although the current provisions have become more complicated, the concepts on which the confiscation provisions in POCA 2002 are based have been part of the law for several decades. They can be traced back to the Drug Trafficking Offences Act 1986, which introduced a scheme for the making of confiscation orders against persons convicted of drug trafficking offences. A new general power to confiscate the proceeds of indictable offences other than those referred to as drug trafficking offences was introduced by Part VI of the Criminal Justice Act 1988. This was followed by a revised scheme for those convicted of drug trafficking offences in the Drug Trafficking Act 1994. Part VI of the 1988 Act and the scheme in the 1994 Act have in their turn been replaced by POCA 2002. This is a lengthy enactment which extends to 462 sections and twelve Schedules. Its length is attributable, at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stone & Rolls Ltd (In Liq) v Moore Stephens (a firm) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] UKHL 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Stone & Rolls Ltd (In Liq) v Moore Stephens (a firm) [2009] UKHL 30 involved a dispute concerning the interpretation of the term "market value" in section 79 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (POCA 2002). The central issue was whether goods of an illegal nature, such as drugs, obtained by a defendant should be treated as having no value for the purpose of calculating a defendant's benefit in confiscation proceedings. The House of Lords allowed the appeal and concluded that goods of an illegal nature should not be treated as having no value in determining the defendant's benefit.

The legal issue at the core of the case was the interpretation of the term "market value" in the context of calculating a defendant's benefit under POCA 2002. The court had to decide whether the market value of illegal goods, such as drugs, should be assessed in the context of a legitimate market or an illegitimate, black market. The House of Lords held that the market value of illegal goods should be assessed in the context of the black market, as it was the market in which the defendant would have intended to sell the goods.

The court's reasoning was based on the understanding that the market value of property should be determined by the price that a willing seller would accept from a willing buyer, regardless of whether the market was legitimate or illegitimate. The court rejected the notion that the term "market value" should be restricted to legitimate markets, as this would ignore the known facts and distort the calculation of the defendant's benefit. The court also emphasised that the purpose of the confiscation provisions in POCA 2002 was to strip criminals of the benefits of their crimes, and valuing illegal goods in the context of a black market would not be inconsistent with this purpose.

The final orders of the House of Lords were to allow the appeal, overrule the decision in R v Hussain [2006] EWCA Crim 621, and restore the confiscation order made by HHJ Collender QC. The court held that the market value of illegal goods, such as drugs, should be assessed in the context of the black market for the purpose of calculating a defendant's benefit in confiscation proceedings under POCA 2002.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established