Smith (Kathleen Rose) v East Elloe Rural DC

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

    Die Lunae, 26° Martii 1956

    Parliamentary Archives,
    HL/PO/JU/4/3/1039

    HOUSE OF LORDS

    SMITH


    v.
    EAST ELLOE RURAL DISTRICT COUNCIL AND OTHERS

    26th March, 1956.
    Viscount Simonds

    MY LORDS,

    Viscount
    Simonds

    Lord Morton
    of Henryton

    Lord Reid
    Lord Radcliffe

    Lord

    Somervell of
    Harrow

    On the 6th July, 1954. the Appellant, Kathleen Rose Smith, issued a writ
    against the East Elloe Rural District Council, Mr. Pywell, the Clerk to that
    Council, and the Ministry of Health, whose functions and obligations were
    subsequently transferred to the Ministry of Housing and Local Government,
    claiming as against the Council, (a) damages for trespass to the Appellant's
    land at Hallgate, Holbeach, in the County of Lincoln, (b) an injunction against
    further trespass, and (c) a declaration that a certain Compulsory Purchase
    Order dated the 27th August, 1948, was " wrongfully made and in bad faith " ;
    against the Ministry of Health a declaration that the said Order " was
    " wrongfully confirmed . . . and in bad faith"; against the Ministry of
    Housing and Local Government that " the said compulsory purchase order
    " and confirmation of the same are in bad faith "; and against Pywell a
    declaration that " he knowingly acted wrongfully and in bad faith procuring
    " the said Order and confirmation of the same "; and as against all the
    Defendants further or other relief and damages. The Ministry of Health is
    no longer a party to the proceedings; the present Respondents are the
    Council, Pywell and the Ministry of Housing and Local Government.

    All the Respondents entered conditional appearances to the writ and
    then applied to the Master in Chambers to have the writ set aside upon
    the ground that " the writ of summons in this action is invalid for lack of
    " jurisdiction, it being provided by paragraph 16 of Part IV of the First
    " Schedule to the Acquisition of Land (Authorisation Procedure) Act, 1946,
    " that save by the procedure specified in the said Schedule, a compulsory
    " purchase order confirmed in accordance with the provisions of the said Act
    " (as was here the case) shall not, either before or after it has been confirmed,
    " be questioned in any legal proceedings whatsoever. By reason whereof this
    " Honourable Court has no jurisdiction to grant the relief sought against
    " the said Defendants". Two summonses in similar terms were in fact
    taken out, one by the two Ministries, the other by the Council and their
    Clerk, but nothing at this stage of my Opinion turns on it.

    Orders as asked by the summonses having been made by the Master and
    an appeal from them having been dismissed by the Judge in Chambers, an
    appeal was taken to the Court of Appeal. That Court in turn dismissed
    the appeal. It is clear from the judgment of the Court, which was delivered
    by Lord Justice Parker, that the main question there argued was on a point
    of construction of the Schedule which was in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith (Kathleen Rose) v East Elloe Rural DC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1956] UKHL 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established