Michaelmas Term
[2022] UKPC 44
Privy Council Appeal No 0030 of 2020
JUDGMENT
Bobette Smalling (Appellant)
v
Dawn Satterswaite and others (Respondents) (Jamaica)
From the Court of Appeal of Jamaica
before
Lord Hodge
Lord Briggs
Lord Hamblen
Lord Burrows
Lord Stephens
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
17 November 2022
Heard on 21 June 2022
Appellant
Andrew Mitchell KC
Caroline P Hay KC
Nigel Parke
(Instructed by Andrew Mitchell KC Litigator/Agent)
1st Respondent (Dawn Satterswaite)
Terrence F Williams
Isat Buchanan
John Clarke
(Instructed by Simons Muirhead & Burton LLP)
2nd and 3rd Respondents (Janet Ramsay and Paulette Higgins)
Ian G Wilkinson KC
Lenroy Stewart
Jhawn Graham
Khadine Hylton
(Instructed by Axiom DWFM)
LORD STEPHENS (with whom Lord Hodge, Lord Briggs, Lord Hamblen and Lord Burrows agree):
1. Introduction
- This appeal raises an important question as to whether a search and seizure warrant issued under section 115 of the Jamaican Proceeds of Crime Act 2007 (“POCA”) for the purposes of investigating criminal conduct occurring on or after 30 May 2007 can nevertheless authorise the search for and the seizure of information or material that came into existence prior to 30 May 2007.
- Counsel for Dawn Satterswaite (“the first respondent”) submitted that because a person can only be charged under POCA for offences committed on or after 30 May 2007, any search or seizure in respect of her must be limited to information or material arising on or after 30 May 2007. This submission was rejected by Straw J at first instance, in her judgment dated 17 September 2015 ([2015] JMSC Civ 183) but was accepted in the Court of Appeal (Phillips, F Williams and P Williams JJA) in the judgment of Phillips JA dated 20 December 2019 with which the other justices agreed ([2019] JMCA Civ 43). The Court of Appeal held that material and information prior to 30 May 2007 could not be obtained on foot of a search and seizure warrant issued under section 115 of POCA. As a result, the Court of Appeal ordered that any documents, which predated 30 May 2007 and had been seized by Detective Sergeant Bobette Smalling (“the appellant”) upon the execution of the warrant, must be returned forthwith to the first respondent and Janet Ramsay and Paulette Higgins (“the second and third respondents”).
- On 23 June 2020 Her Majesty granted special leave to appeal to the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in relation to the question set out in paragraph 1 above and granted a stay of execution of the Court of Appeal’s order regarding the return of the documents.
- The appellant, Bobette Smalling, is a Detective Sergeant of Police assigned to the Major Organised Crime and Corruption Agency (“the MOCA”). The MOCA is a branch of the Jamaica Constabulary Force that targets major criminals and their facilitators. For the purposes of Part VI of POCA, headed “Investigations”, the appellant is both an authorised financial investigator and an appropriate officer.
- Mr Andrew Paul Hamilton…
2. Factual Background
(a) The appellant
(b) Andrew Hamilton
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Smalling v Satterswaite & Ors (Jamaica) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] UKPC 44
- Decision Date