Rose & Frank & Co v Crompton & Bros Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

    Die Veneris, 5° Decembris, 1924.

    sess. 1924.—[h.l.]

    ROSE AND FRANK COMPANY

    v.

    JAS. R. CROMPTON AND BROTHERS, LIMITED, AND
    BRITTAINS, LIMITED, ET E CONTRA.

    Earl of Birkenhead.

    Lord Atkinson.

    Lord Sumner.

    Lord Buckmaster.

    Lord Phillimore.




    Lord Phillimore.

    MY LORDS,

    At the conclusion of the arguments in this case, none of
    your Lordships had, I think, any doubt what our judgment ought
    to be, but as there were several points to be dealt with, your Lordships
    took time to consider how best to express your decision upon them.
    We are all still, I believe, of the same mind, and there is no reason
    for further delay.

    The appellants, Rose and Frank Company, carry on business
    in the United States as dealers in carbonising tissue paper which
    they have been in the habit of buying from England, then treating
    in some manner and selling in the perfected state.

    Their relations with the respondents James R. Crompton and
    Brothers, Limited, began as early as 1905; and there were three
    arrangements, which for the purposes of this Appeal we may assume
    to have been binding contracts, under which Rose and Frank
    Company were to be entitled to have the exclusive or nearly exclusive
    right of selling Crompton and Brothers' carbonising tissues in America,
    subject to 12 months' notice—a notice which was never given.

    In 1913, circumstances led to the relations between the parties
    bring reconsidered; and it was then for the first time brought to the
    notice of Rose and Frank Company that the respondents Brittains,
    Limited, had been interested with Cromptons in supplying the
    carbonising tissue; and thereupon the three parties entered into
    the arrangement which had given rise to the present litigation. It
    is dated the 8th July 1913, and in the earlier part of it appears to
    l)o a binding agreement under which the English companies agree
    to confine the sale of call their carbonising tissue in the U.S. and
    Canada—subject to certain defined exceptions—and Rose and
    Frank Company agree to confine their purchases of the same stuff
    exclusively to the two English companies and to do their best to
    increase their trade. The arrangement was to last for three years
    subject to six months' notice. The other supplementary provisions
    need not be stated; but towards the end of the document appears
    this remarkable clause:

    ' This arrangement is not entered into, nor is this
    ' memorandum written, as a formal or legal agreement and
    ' shall not be subject to legal jurisdiction in the Law
    ' Courts either of the United States or England, but it
    ' is only a definite expression and record of the purpose
    ' and intention of the three parties concerned, to which
    ' they each honourably pledge themselves with the fullest
    ' confidence—based on past business with each other—
    ' that it will be carried through by each of the three parties
    " with mutual loyalty and friendly co-operation."

    There is. no explanation upon the record, and no suggestion was
    made by Counsel at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rose & Frank & Co v Crompton & Bros Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1924] UKHL 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established