Rivnu Investment Ltd & Anor v United Docks Ltd & Anor (Mauritius)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Trinity Term

[2017] UKPC 24

Privy Council Appeal No 0038 of 2015

 

 

 

JUDGMENT

 

 

Rivnu Investment Limited and another (Appellants) v United Docks Limited and another (Respondents) (Mauritius)

 

From the Supreme Court of Mauritius

 

before

 

Lord Mance

Lord Clarke

Lord Carnwath

Lord Hughes

Lord Hodge

 

 

 

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

 


27 July 2017

 

 

Heard on 26 June 2017

 

 

Appellants

Salim Moollan QC

Peter Webster

Angelique Desvaux de Marigny

(Instructed by Blake Morgan)

 

Respondent (United Docks Ltd)

Rishi Pursem SC

Nadeem Lallmamode

Bilshan Nursimulu

(Instructed by Carrington and Associates)

 

 

LORD MANCE:

Introduction

1.                   This appeal turns on clause 11 in an agreement dated 30 June 2006 between four shareholders in the second respondent, Axys Group Ltd (“Axys”) (then called ACMS Holding Ltd). By clause 11, each granted to the others an option to purchase all or part of its shares “should there be any change in [its] shareholding structure …, resulting in the loss of the controlling interest of the shareholder(s) which/who currently hold(s) such controlling interest in the said party”. Following a re-organisation, the four shareholders were at the date of the agreement, the first appellant, Rivnu Investment Ltd (“Rivnu”), the second appellant, Portfolio Investment Management Ltd (“PIM”), Compagnie Desmem Ltée (“Desmem”) and the first respondent, United Docks Ltd (“UDL”). The first three companies each owned 20%, while the fourth owned 29.15% of the shares in Axys. Together they therefore owned some 89% of the shares in Axys on 30 June 2006. Desmem later amalgamated with Compagnie d’Investissement et de Développement Ltée (“CIDL”), and is a co-respondent to the appeal.

2.                   Axys was the holding company of ACMS Ltd, a relatively small company incorporated in 1996 and involved until 2006 in financial advisory and consultancy services and pension fund administration services. UDL is in contrast a large company with extensive interests additional to its interest in Axys. It had some 1,900 shareholders. However, on the evidence (recited more fully below), the position until June 2006 had been that “very low attendance” at annual general meetings meant that three of its shareholders - Promotion and Development Ltd (“P & D”), owning 11.65% of Axys’s shares, Anglo-Mauritius Assurance Society Ltd (“AMASL”), owning 6.62%, and La Prudence Mauricienne Assurance Ltée (“La Prudence”), owning 6.51% - “usually represented a very large majority and most substantial percentage of the members present and voting and in fact had appointed the then board of directors of UDL”. UDL’s 12 person Board was chaired by Mr Jean Piat and the chief executive officer was Mr Michel Rivalland.

3.                   On 18 July 2006 the position changed. A director of, and a major shareholder holding some 22% of the shares in, La Prudence was Mr Dominique Galéa. He was also the chair, and the major shareholder holding 89% of the shares in, Ducray Lenoir (Investments) Ltd (“Ducray Lenoir”). Ducray Lenoir was in turn party to a joint 50/50 venture in Horus Ltée (“Horus”) with Harel Frères Ltd (through the latter’s wholly owned subsidiary, Harel Frères Investments Ltd), whose managing director and most senior…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rivnu Investment Ltd & Anor v United Docks Ltd & Anor (Mauri... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] UKPC 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established