Michaelmas Term
[2011] UKSC 44
| JUDGMENT |
REFERENCE - Her Majesty's Advocate v P (Scotland)
before
Lord Hope, Deputy President
Lord Brown
Lord Kerr
Lord Dyson
Lord Matthew Clarke
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
6 October 2011
Heard on 28, 29 and 30 June 2011
Appellant Respondent
| Frank Muholland QC, | Matthew Auchincloss |
Lord Advocate
Joanna Cherry QC Catherine Devaney
| (Instructed by the Crown | (Instructed by Public |
| Agent, Crown Office) | Defence Solicitors Office) |
LORD HOPE (WITH WHOM LORD DYSON, LORD KERR AND LORD
MATTHEW CLARKE AGREE)
1. On 26 October 2010 this Court issued its judgment in Cadder v HM Advocate [2010] UKSC 43, 2010 SLT 1125. It held that the Crown’s reliance on admissions made by an accused who had no access to a lawyer while he was being questioned as a detainee under section 14 of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 gave rise to a breach of his right to a fair trial, having regard to the decision of the European Court of Human Rights in Salduz v Turkey (2008) 49 EHRR 421. This was because the leading and relying on incriminating statements made by the appellant while being interviewed by the police in such circumstances was a violation of his rights under article 6(3)(c) read in conjunction with article 6(1) of the European Convention on Human Rights: see Cadder v HM Advocate, para 63.
2. The evidence that was in question in Cadder consisted of incriminating statements that the appellant made when he was being questioned while in detention at a police station. The applicant in Salduz too had been taken into custody before he was interrogated during his detention by police officers of the anti-terrorism branch of the Izmir Security Directorate. But the facts of those cases by no means exhaust the situations in which the Crown may seek to rely on answers to questions that have been put to the accused by the police. The Court now has before it four references by judges of the High Court of Justiciary which have been required by the Lord Advocate under paragraph 33 of Schedule 6 to the Scotland Act 1998. Three of them are cases where the evidence in question was obtained by the police otherwise than by questioning at a police station following detention under section 14 of the 1995 Act. The fourth is concerned with whether the ratio of the decision in Salduz extends to lines of enquiry which have been derived from answers that the accused gave to questions while he was being detained in the police station.
3. Common to all four cases is the fact that incriminating answers were given to questions put by the police when the accused did not have access to legal advice. In each case this occurred before the judgment was given in Cadder. The issue that the first three references raise is whether the decision in Salduz to which Cadder gave effect has established that anyone who has been “charged” with an offence, so that article 6…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Reference Her Majesty's Advocate v P (Scotland) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] UKSC 44
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that there is no absolute rule that evidence obtained as a result of questioning without access to a lawyer must always be excluded. The decision hinged on whether the evidence could stand independently of the accused's statements. The court noted that the European Court of Human Rights had not established such a rule, and there was no clear consensus among contracting states on the exact scope of the exclusionary rule. The court also looked at the approach in English law, where evidence derived from an involuntary statement is admissible if it can be adduced without relying on the statement itself.
Ultimately, the Supreme Court concluded that the admissibility of the evidence should be determined on a case-by-case basis, considering whether admitting the evidence would violate the accused's right to a fair trial. The court declined to answer the specific question about the admissibility of the friend's evidence, leaving it to the trial judge to decide based on the circumstances of the case.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.