R (Wilkinson) v Inland Revenue Commissioners

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
HOUSE OF LORDS SESSION 2004–05
[2005] UKHL 30

on appeal from: [2003]EWCA Civ 814

OPINIONS

OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL

FOR JUDGMENT IN THE CAUSE

Regina v. Her Majesty’s Commissioners of Inland Revenue (Respondents) ex parte Wilkinson (FC) (Appellant) ON THURSDAY 5 MAY 2005 The Appellate Committee comprised: Lord Nicholls of Birkenhead Lord Hoffmann Lord Hope of Craighead Lord Scott of Foscote Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood HOUSE OF LORDS OPINIONS OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL FOR JUDGMENT IN THE CAUSE Regina v. Her Majesty’s Commissioners of Inland Revenue (Respondents) ex parte Wilkinson (FC) (Appellant) [2005] UKHL 30

LORD NICHOLLS OF BIRKENHEAD

My Lords,

1. I have had the advantage of reading in draft the speech of my

noble and learned friend Lord Hoffmann. For the reasons he gives, with
which I agree, I would dismiss this appeal.

LORD HOFFMANN

My Lords,

Introductory

2. The appellant Mr Wilkinson is a widower. His wife died on 23 June 1999. If he had been a widow, he would have been entitled to a widow’s bereavement allowance by way of deduction from his liability for income tax under section 262 of the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988 (“ICTA”):

“(1) Where a married man whose wife is living with him dies, his widow shall be entitled?

(a)

for the year of assessment in which the death occurs, to an income tax reduction calculated…[etc]

(b)

(unless she marries again before the beginning of it) for the next following year of assessment, to an income tax reduction calculated…[etc].

There was no similar allowance for widowers.

3. After the death of his wife, Mr Wilkinson learned that other widowers had been complaining that the tax law was unfairly discriminatory. In 1997 Mr Christopher Crossland petitioned the European Court of Human Rights, alleging that the law infringed article 14 read with article 8 of, and with article 1 of the First Protocol to the Convention. The Government did not contest the admissibility of his claim and in September 1999 it reached a friendly settlement by which it paid Mr Crossland £575 (the value of the tax reduction to which he would have been entitled) and his costs. It did the same when a Mr Fielding petitioned on 17 June 1997.

4. At the time when Mr Crossland and Mr Fielding petitioned, the Human Rights Act 1998 had not yet come into force. Even if section 262 of ICTA infringed Convention rights, they would have had no claim in domestic law. But after the 1998 Act came into force on 2 October 2000, Mr Wilkinson wrote to the Inland Revenue making a claim for an allowance under section 262. He said that having to pay tax is something which affects a citizen’s “peaceful enjoyment of his possessions” within the meaning of article 1 of the First Protocol. Article 14 therefore requires that in matters of taxation there shall be no discrimination on grounds of sex. The refusal of an allowance was therefore an unlawful act (or failure to act)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R (Wilkinson) v Inland Revenue Commissioners and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] UKHL 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R (Wilkinson) v Inland Revenue Commissioners, the House of Lords was called upon to consider whether the Commissioners of Inland Revenue were required to provide a bereavement allowance to widowers, as they did for widows, in light of the Human Rights Act 1998. Mr. Wilkinson, a widower, sought to claim an allowance under section 262 of the Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988, which provided for such an allowance for widows but not for widowers. The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the statute in light of the Human Rights Act, the powers of the Commissioners under the Taxes Management Act 1970, and the implications of section 6(2) of the Human Rights Act.

The Lords determined that the statute could not be interpreted to include widowers within its provisions for widows, as the language and context of the Act clearly indicated a contrary intention. Furthermore, they held that the Commissioners lacked the statutory power to grant extra-statutory allowances to widowers that would have created a new entitlement not granted by Parliament. Consequently, the Commissioners were protected from liability under section 6(2)(a) of the Human Rights Act. The Lords also noted that if the Commissioners had possessed such power, they would still have been protected by section 6(2)(b) as they were merely giving effect to the statutory provisions as written.

In terms of just satisfaction, the Lords concluded that Mr. Wilkinson was not entitled to damages as the proper remedy under the Human Rights Act would have been for Parliament to abolish the allowance for widows altogether, leaving Mr. Wilkinson no better off than he would have been had the allowance not existed. Finally, the Lords rejected the argument that the Commissioners' actions constituted an irrational or unfair abuse of power, affirming that they were acting within their lawful authority.

In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed, affirming the decision of the Court of Appeal. The Commissioners were not required to provide a bereavement allowance to widowers under the existing statutory framework and were protected from liability under the Human Rights Act.