Paul and another (Appellants) v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust (Respondent)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read
Hilary Term
[2024] UKSC 1
On appeal from: [2022] EWCA Civ 12

JUDGMENT

Paul and another (Appellants) vRoyal Wolverhampton NHS Trust (Respondent)

Polmear and another (Appellants) v Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust (Respondent)

Purchase (Appellant) v Ahmed (Respondent)

before

Lord Briggs
Lord Sales
Lord Leggatt
Lord Burrows
Lady Rose
Lord Richards

Lord Carloway

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
11 January 2024

Heard on 16, 17 and 18 May 2023

Appellant - Paul
Robert Weir KC

Laura Johnson KC

(Instructed by Shoosmiths LLP (Birmingham))

Appellant - Polmear
Henry Pitchers KC

Oliver May
(Instructed by Wolferstans LLP (Plymouth))

Appellant - Purchase
David Tyack KC

Esther Gamble

(Instructed by Talbots Law Ltd (Stourbridge))

Respondents
Simeon Maskrey KC

Charles Bagot KC

Charlotte Jones

(Instructed by Browne Jacobson LLP (Birmingham) and Bevan Brittan LLP (Bristol))

LORD LEGGATT AND LADY ROSE (with whom Lord Briggs, Lord Sales and Lord Richards agree):

  1. Introduction

  1. We all die and, when we do, the fact or manner of our deaths may cause harm to other people. Often such harm is readily foreseeable. We all know that the death of someone’s child, or of their partner, or of a young child’s parent, will cause grief and suffering and can have prolonged and profound effects on physical and mental health. Death may also have damaging, even ruinous, financial consequences for family members or others who were dependent economically on the deceased.

  1. Under the common law the rule was that “in a civil court, the death of a human being could not be complained of as an injury” by another person: Baker v Bolton (1808) 1 Camp 493 (Lord Ellenborough); Admiralty Comrs v SS Amerika [1917] AC 38. This is still the general rule. The same rule applies where the victim does not die but is severely injured. Essentially, the common law does not recognise one person as having any legally compensable interest in the physical well-being of another. The law affords compensation to the victim but not to others who suffer harm in consequence of the victim’s injuries or death, however severely affected they may be: see eg D v East Berkshire Community Health NHS Trust [2005] UKHL 23, [2005] 2 AC 373, paras 102-105.

  1. There is a statutory exception, introduced by the Fatal Accidents Act 1846 (9 & 19 Vict c 93) and now contained in the Fatal Accidents Act 1976, which gives certain dependants of a person whose death is caused by a wrongful act, neglect or default the right to sue and recover damages from the person who (if death had not ensued) would have been liable to the deceased. Originally such damages were only recoverable to compensate dependants for financial loss resulting from the death. Since 1991, when a new provision was added to the 1976 Act, a spouse or partner or parents (if the child was an unmarried minor) of the deceased can recover damages for bereavement whether or not they were dependent on the deceased; but these damages are limited to a fixed sum…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paul and another (Appellants) v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trus... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] UKSC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Paul and another (Appellants) v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust (Respondent), the Supreme Court considered whether a doctor can owe a duty of care to family members of a patient to protect them from harm caused by witnessing the patient's death or injury resulting from medical negligence. The claimants, who witnessed the death of their father or daughter due to the alleged negligence of the defendants, sought compensation for psychiatric injury caused by the experience. The key issue was whether the rules developed for claims arising from accidents apply to cases of medical negligence. The Court of Appeal had held that the claims could not succeed, relying on an earlier decision that required the claimant to witness the accident or its immediate aftermath. The Supreme Court, however, found that this requirement was not supported by the relevant authorities and was inconsistent with the reasoning in those cases. The Court concluded that the death of the primary victim, caused by medical negligence, could be the relevant event for the purposes of a claim by a secondary victim. As such, the appeals were allowed, and the claimants were entitled to succeed because foreseeability and the control or proximity factors were satisfied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.