Michaelmas Term
[2012] UKSC 50
On appeal from: [2011] CSIH 30
| JUDGMENT |
Morris (Appellant) v Rae (Respondent) (Scotland)
before
Lord Hope, Deputy President
Lord Walker
Lord Sumption
Lord Reed
Lord Carnwath
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
7 November 2012
Heard on 3 October 2012
Appellant Respondent J Gordon Reid QC Roddy Dunlop QC David Logan Jonathan A Brown
| (Instructed by Campbell | (Instructed by HBM |
Smith WS LLP) Sayers Solicitors)
LORD HOPE
1. This appeal raises a question about what the grantee of a deed who has been provided with a defective title needs to establish in order to obtain a remedy under the granter’s obligation of absolute warrandice. By including a clause of warrandice in a disposition of property which he has sold to the grantee, the seller warrants his title as absolute owner of the property. But warrandice is a contingent obligation. It only comes into effect upon eviction. It has been described as an obligation to warrant the grantee against eviction of the thing sold: MP Brown, A Treatise on the Law of Sale (1821), p 240, para 329. Eviction, in the strict sense of the word, only takes place when a court order is pronounced which deprives a party of his right to continue to occupy the property. As Brown puts it, it is concerned with the loss of the subject through the enforcement of a third party’s rights by the sentence of a judge: p 258, para 353. But Scots law has never insisted upon eviction in that sense as the only pre-condition of entitlement to proceed against the granter for recourse under his obligation of warrandice. There can be eviction for this purpose if eviction is threatened and there is shown to be a competing title which will inevitably prevail in competition with that which was given by the granter to the grantee.
2. The question that this case raises is directed to the requirements that must be satisfied if the grantee’s claim for breach of warrandice is to succeed on the basis of a threat of eviction. It can now be taken as settled law that the claim will succeed if the challenge is made by the party with a competing title to the disputed subjects which is unquestionable and will inevitably prevail in competition with that of the grantee: Clark v Lindale Homes Ltd 1994 SC 210, 216. The problem that has arisen in this case is that, contrary to what was understood at the time when the grantee submitted to the threat of eviction, the party who challenged the grantee’s title did not at that time have a competing right to the property. The title to the disputed ground was vested in a third party when the threat was made. But the grantee offers to prove that the challenger would have been immediately able to secure title to the disputed ground in its favour and that no proceedings would ever have been required to establish its title to it. That assertion is disputed…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Morris (Appellant) v Rae (Respondent) (Scotland) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] UKSC 50
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue in this case was whether the appellant's claim for breach of warrandice could be successful if the party making the threat of eviction did not have a competing title to the disputed property at the time of the threat. The appellant argued that it was sufficient for the true owner of the disputed part to be able to obtain a registered title, even if it had not been registered at the time of the threat.
The court held that the obligation of warrandice is contingent upon eviction, which is a broader term that includes the loss of any part of the estate or its diminution in value due to a defect in title. The court also found that a threat of eviction could be made by a person who did not have a title to the property, as long as they had an unquestionable right to obtain one. In this case, the appellant offered to prove that JCL would have been immediately able to secure title to the disputed part in its favor and that no proceedings would have been required to establish its title to it. The court concluded that, under these circumstances, the appellant had a relevant case against the respondent.
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, recalling the Extra Division's interlocutor and restoring the temporary judge's interlocutor. The case was remitted to the Outer House for the hearing of a proof before answer. The court's decision provided clarification on the scope of the obligation of warrandice and the circumstances in which a threat of eviction can trigger the seller's liability to indemnify the purchaser.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.