Die Veneris, 26° Julii, 1946
Parliamentary
Archives,
HL/PO/JU/4/3/981
Viscount
Simon
Lord
Macmillan
Lord
Porter
Lord
Simonds
Lord
Uthwatt
MERSEY DOCKS AND HARBOUR BOARD
v.
COGGINS AND GRIFFITHS (LIVERPOOL) LTD.
AND McFARLANE
Viscount Simon
MY LORDS,
In this Appeal the Mersey Docks
and Harbour Board (hereinafter
called the board), against whom a
Plaintiff named John McFarlane
has obtained judgment at Liverpool
Assizes for £247 damages
with costs on the ground of
negligence in the working of a mobile
crane belonging to the
Board, seeks to have the judgment against
the Board discharged and
to have substituted for it a judgment
in favour of McFarlane for
the same amount against Coggins and
Griffiths (Liverpool) Ltd. who
are master stevedores and who had
hired from the Board the use of
the crane, together with its driver,
for the purpose of unloading
a ship called the " Port Chalmers "
lying at the quay at
the North Sandon Dock, Liverpool. The
question in the case is
therefore whether Newall, the driver of
the crane, is to be
regarded, for the purpose of McFarlane's claim,
as employed by the
Board or by Coggins & Griffiths. Both
the Trial Judge, Mr.
Justice Croom-Johnson and the Court of
Appeal (Scott, du Parcq and
Morton, L. JJ) held that the Board was
responsible to the
Plaintiff for Newall's negligence, but the Board
contends that
Newall was not at the time of the accident and for
the purpose of
the operation in which he was then engaged a servant
of the
Appellant Board but was the servant of Coggins & Griffiths.
When the case was called on
before the House it appeared that,
in an effort to simplify
proceedings, the Board and Coggins &
Griffiths were the only
parties before us, and it was pointed out
that McFarlane, who in
the Action had sued both these parties in
the alternative, was
indifferent as to which of them was pronounced
to be liable to him
as, once he had established that his injuries
were due to Newall's
negligence, he was bound to get payment
from one or other. The
House, however, felt that it could not
proceed to hear the appeal
unless McFarlane was made a party
to it, since Your Lordships were
being asked to reverse a judgment
which he had obtained. The
Petition of Appeal was therefore
varied by adding McFarlane's name
as a Respondent and he
intimated through his solicitors
that he did not desire to take part
in the argument but was ready
to accept the decision of the House
on the question which of the
two original defendants was liable
to him.
The further facts which raise
the question to be decided can be
very briefly stated. The Board
own a number of mobile cranes,
each driven by a skilled workman
engaged and paid by it, for
the purpose of letting out the
apparatus so driven to applicants
who have undertaken to load or
unload cargo at Liverpool Docks.
The conditions upon which such
cranes…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mersey Docks & Harbour Board v Coggins & Griffiths (Liverpoo... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1946] UKHL 1
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi