Trinity Term
[2017] UKPC 23
Privy Council Appeal No 0105 of 2015
JUDGMENT
Mediterranean Shipping Company (Appellant) v Sotramon Limited (Respondent) (Mauritius)
From the Supreme Court of Mauritius
before
Lady Hale
Lord Kerr
Lord Wilson
Lord Hughes
Lord Toulson
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
17 July 2017
Heard on 6 April 2017
|
Appellant Michel Ahnee (Instructed by Mills & Co Solicitors Limited) |
|
Respondent Priscilla Balgobin-Bhoyrul Yudish Lutchmenarraidoo Nilen Vencadasmy Kushla Juggeewon (Instructed by Sheridans) |
LORD TOULSON:
1. Under the law of Mauritius, can a party to a contract sue the other party in delict for non-performance of the contract, if the failure to perform it amounted to faute lourde?
2. In the Supreme Court of Mauritius at first instance Matadeen, J held that the answer was “no”, but her decision was reversed by the Court of Civil Appeal (Balancy SPJ and Jugessur-Manna J). Permission to appeal to the Board was granted by Balancy Ag CJ. The factual background is straightforward, but the procedural history has been less so.
Facts
3. The claim was a simple claim for damages for short delivery under a contract of carriage. The goods were a crawler crane, which the plaintiff (Sotramon), a Mauritian company, hired from a Scottish crane company. Under the terms of the hire contract the plaintiff arranged for its bank to issue a letter of credit in favour of the company in the sum of £1.2m in case it failed to return the crane by 15 September 1999.
4. The plaintiff arranged for return shipment of the crane from Port Louis, Mauritius, to Felixstowe by the defendant (Mediterranean Shipping) under a bill of lading contract. On 4 August 1999 the defendant issued a bill of lading in respect of 16 packages said to contain a complete crawler crane. The crane company was named as the consignee. The vessel arrived at Felixstowe by the due date, but, when the containers were unstuffed, a 15 ton ballast which formed part of the crane was said by the crane company to be missing. Correspondence followed between the interested parties.
5. The plaintiff’s case is that it consigned the entire crane to the defendant for shipment and that there was short delivery. The defendant’s case is that it delivered all that was consigned.
6. The contract contained a law and jurisdiction clause, which specified that all claims and disputes arising under or in connection with the bill of lading should be referred to the High Court in London and that English law should apply, subject to immaterial exceptions. It also contained a clause limiting the amount of the carrier’s liability for any loss or damage to or in connection with the goods.
History of proceedings
7. On 9 October 2000 the plaintiff issued proceedings against the defendant in the Supreme Court of Mauritius claiming damages for breach of contract. The damages included approximately £30,000 representing the cost of a replacement ballast, for which the plaintiff had become liable to the crane company, and additional hire charges which the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mediterranean Shipping Company v Sotramon Ltd (Mauritius) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] UKPC 23
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi