Kuwait Ports Authority & Anor v Williams & Ors (Cayman Islands)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

Michaelmas Term

[2024] UKPC 32

Privy Council Appeal No 0045 of 2023

JUDGMENT

Kuwait Ports Authority and another (Respondents)

 v

Mark Eric Williams and 2 others (Appellants) (Cayman Islands)

From the Court of Appeal of the Cayman Islands

before

 

Lord Reed

Lord Hodge

Lord Hamblen

Lord Leggatt

Lady Simler

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

28 October 2024

 

Heard on 20 June 2024

Appellants

Graham Chapman KC

Andrew Pullinger

Harry Shaw

(Instructed by Campbells LLP and Sinclair Gibson LLP)

Respondents

David Allison KC

Dan McCourt Fritz KC

Rachael Reynolds KC

(Instructed by Ogier (Cayman) LLP and Baker & McKenzie LLP (London))

Lord Hamblen:

Introduction

  1.  The Cayman Islands Exempted Limited Partnership Act (2021 Revision) (the "Act") provides for the establishment of exempted limited partnerships (an "ELP").  A limited partner in an ELP enjoys limited liability but is precluded from participating in the conduct of the business of the ELP, which is carried out exclusively by a general partner.
  2. This appeal concerns the circumstances in which a limited partner can bring a derivative action on behalf of the ELP for injury or damage done to the ELP.  This is governed by section 33(3) of the Act which provides that such an action may be brought if the general partner has "without cause, failed or refused to institute proceedings".
  3. This is the first case in which this issue has been considered.  In its decision the Court of Appeal of the Cayman Islands (Sir Richard Field, Sir Michael Birt and Sir Jack Beatson JJA) provided general guidance as to the approach to be adopted to derivative actions brought pursuant to section 33(3) of the Act and concluded that the general partner in this case did refuse or fail to institute proceedings "without cause" and that as a matter of discretion it was appropriate to allow the respondents' derivative claims to be brought.  The appellants contend that the Court of Appeal was wrong so to conclude.  The respondents cross-appeal is in respect of one aspect of the general guidance provided, namely at what point in time the section 33(3) test falls to be assessed.
  4. Factual background

  5. The Port Fund LP (the "Fund") is a Cayman Islands ELP which invested in port-related assets around the world. It was established in 2007 by KGL Investment Company KSCC ("KGLI Kuwait") which acted as the Fund's sponsor and placement agent and was also one of the limited partners in the Fund. The Fund has one general partner and eleven limited partners including KGLI Kuwait and the two respondents, Kuwait Ports Authority ("KPA") and The Public Institution for Social Security ("PIFSS"). The limited partners invested a total of US$188,152,000, approximately 65% of which was invested by the respondents.
  6. The general partner of the Fund is Port Link GP Ltd, a Cayman Islands exempted limited company (the "General Partner"). It was appointed as the sole general partner from 21 March 2007 onwards pursuant to identical limited partnership agreements between itself and the limited partners. 
  7. The first appellant ("Mr Williams") is the ultimate…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kuwait Ports Authority & Anor v Williams & Ors (Cayman Islan... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] UKPC 32
Decision Date