Inntrepreneur Pub Company (CPC) & Ors v. Crehan

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read
  1.   I have had the great advantage of reading in draft the opinion of my noble and learned friend Lord Hoffmann. I agree with his analysis and conclusions and would make the orders which he proposes. His summary of the facts (already the subject of detailed recitation by Park J and the Court of Appeal: [2003] EWHC 1510 (Ch), [2003] EuLR 663; [2004] EWCA Civ 637, [2004] EuLR 693) and of the relevant materials enables me to express my reasons for concurring without repetition. Like my noble and learned friend I shall for convenience refer to the current numbering of the Treaty articles.
  2.   The sharpness of the issue between the parties to this appeal tends to conceal the bedrock of common ground which underlies the case. I think it is worth drawing attention to a number of important matters which are not contentious.
  3.   There is, first of all, no question about the importance of article 81 EC prohibiting, as incompatible with the Treaty, agreements and practices which prevent, restrict or distort competition between Member States. As the Court of Justice of the European Communities observed in Eco Swiss China Time Ltd v Benetton International NV (Case C-126/97) [1999] ECR 1-3055, para 36, and repeated in Courage Ltd v Crehan (Case C-453/99) [2002] QB 507, 521, para 20,
    "Article [81] of the Treaty constitutes a fundamental provision which is essential for the accomplishment of the tasks entrusted to the Community and, in particular, for the functioning of the internal market."

It is indeed clear that without effective competition transcending national boundaries there can be no effective common market.

  •   It is also clear, secondly, that article 211 EC imposes a duty on the Commission to ensure the proper functioning and development of the common market. That duty applies in the field of competition as in other fields, as is made clear by article 85 EC. In Stergios Delimitis v Henninger Bräu AG (Case C-234/89) [1991] ECR 1-935, para 44, the Court stressed the responsibility of the Commission for the implementation and orientation of Community competition policy, a point reiterated in Masterfoods Ltd v HB Ice Cream Ltd (Case C-344/98) [2000] ECR 1-11369, para 46. English decisions have recognised the primary responsibility of the Commission and its specialist expertise in determining competition questions: Iberian UK Ltd v BPB Industries PLC [1997] EuLR 1, 16; Coal Authority v H J Banks Co Ltd [1997] EuLR 610, 620; Morgan Stanley Dean Witter Bank Ltd v Visa International Service Association (unreported), 2 May 2001, p 7 Toulson J.
  •   But, thirdly, it is well-established that article 81 is directly enforceable. This means that national competition authorities and courts share, and have always shared, with the Commission the duty to give effect to the prohibition in article 81(1), and the legal consequences of automatic avoidance under article 81(2) have always been a matter for determination by national courts alone. Article 9(1) of Council Regulation (EEC) 17/62 conferred sole power on the Commission to make declarations of inapplicability under…
  • CaseChat AU logo

    Keep reading for free

    Create a free CaseChat account to read Inntrepreneur Pub Company (CPC) & Ors v. Crehan and more:

    • Read every judgment in full
    • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
    • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
    • Download judgments as PDF or Word
    Continue with Google

    One click creates your free account or signs you in.

    By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

    Details
    Case
    [2006] UKHL 38
    Decision Date

    CaseChat Overview and Summary

    Orders

    Orders of the court

    Background

    Background to the litigation

    Evidence

    Evidence Before The Court

    Decision

    Reasons for decision

    Ratio Decidendi

    Legal Principle Established