Easter Term
[2016] UKSC 15
On appeal from: [2015] EWCA Civ 1112
| JUDGMENT |
In the matter of N (Children)
before
Lord Neuberger, President
Lady Hale, Deputy President
Lord Kerr
Lord Wilson
Lord Carnwath
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
13 April 2016
Heard on 17 March 2016
Appellants Respondent (London (JN and EN) Borough of Hounslow) Henry Setright QC Roger McCarthy QC Martha Cover Mark Twomey Michael Gration
| (Instructed by Hanne & | (Instructed by London |
Co) Borough of Hounslow)
Respondent (AM - Mother)
William Tyler QC
Malcolm MacDonald
(Instructed by Lawrence &
Co Solicitors)
Respondent (ZN - Father)
Frank Feehan QC
Dorian Day
(Instructed by Hecht
Montgomery)
Interveners (Written Submissions Only)
1st Intervener (AIRE
Centre)
Deirdre Fottrell QC
Lucy Sprinz
Michael Edwards
(Instructed by Herbert
Smith Freehills LLP)
2nd Intervener (Family
Rights Group)
John Vater QC
Edward Devereux
Mehvish Chaudhry
Dr Rob George
(Instructed by Goodman
Ray LLP)
3rd Intervener (The
International Centre for Family Law, Policy and
Practice)
David Williams QC
Jacqueline Renton
(Instructed by Kingsley
Napley)
LADY HALE: (with whom Lord Neuberger, Lord Kerr, Lord Wilson and
Lord Carnwath agree)
1. The issue in this case is whether the future of two little girls, one now aged four years and two months and the other now aged two years and 11 months, should be decided by the courts of this country or by the authorities in Hungary. Both children were born in England and have lived all their lives here. But their parents are Hungarian and the children are nationals of Hungary, not the United Kingdom. Under article 8.1 of Council Regulation (EC) No 2201/2003, concerning jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in matrimonial matters and the
matters of parental responsibility, known as the Brussels II revised Regulation (“the
Regulation”), the primary rule is that jurisdiction lies with the courts of the member
state where the child is habitually resident. That would be England in this case. However, an exception is made by article 15, under which those courts can transfer the case to a court in another member state with which the child has a particular
connection, if that court would be “better placed” to hear the case, or part of it, and
the transfer is in the best interests of the child. These children have a particular connection with Hungary, as it is the place of their nationality. The issue, therefore, is the proper approach to deciding whether a Hungarian court would be better placed to hear the case and to whether transferring it would be in the best interests of the children.
2. The context in which these questions arise is important. Free movement of workers and their families within the European Union has led to many children living, permanently or temporarily, in countries of which they are not nationals. Inevitably, some of them will come to the attention of the child protection authorities, because of ill-treatment or neglect or the risk of it. In the past, the courts
in this country might assume that they…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the matter of N (Children) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] UKSC 15
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Supreme Court was the proper approach to the "best interests" evaluation required by article 15.1 of the Regulation when deciding whether to transfer a case to another member state. The Court held that the "best interests" requirement is not limited to questions of forum but should also consider the short and long term consequences for the child of the transfer itself.
The Court found that the High Court judge had taken the wrong approach by not considering the impact of transferring the case on the girls' welfare and future options. The Court concluded that it would not be in the best interests of the children to transfer the case to Hungary, as it would remove them from their current foster home and preclude one possible outcome that may be in their best interests.
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and set aside the transfer request, ordering that the case be returned to the Family Division of the High Court to be decided as soon as possible. The Court emphasised the importance of considering the children's welfare and background when determining the most appropriate outcome for them.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi