Hilary Term
[2017] UKSC 12
On appeal from: [2015] EWCA Civ 540
JUDGMENT
Homes and Communities Agency (Respondent) v J S Bloor (Wilmslow) Ltd (Appellant)
before
Lord Neuberger, President
Lord Clarke
Lord Sumption
Lord Carnwath
Lord Hughes
JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
22 February 2017
Heard on 12 January 2017
|
Appellant Martin Kingston QC Richard Kimblin QC (Instructed by DWF LLP) |
|
Respondent Michael Humphries QC Alexander Booth QC (Instructed by Eversheds LLP) |
LORD CARNWATH: (with whom Lord Neuberger, Lord Clarke, Lord Sumption and Lord Hughes agree)
Introduction
1. This appeal concerns the assessment of compensation for compulsory acquisition of two parcels of grazing land, amounting in all to 26.85 acres (10.86 ha) (“the reference land”), formerly owned by the present appellant (“the claimants”). They were part of a much larger area of some 420 acres (170ha) acquired under the North West Development Agency (Kingsway Business Park, Rochdale) Compulsory Purchase Order 2002 (“the CPO”), for the development of the so-called Kingsway Business Park (“KBP”). Responsibility for payment of compensation now rests with the Homes and Communities Agency, the respondent to this appeal (“the authority”).
2. An initial claim was made for £2,593,000 compensation, on the basis that the land had significant hope value for residential development, independently of the scheme of acquisition. The authority contended that the claim should be limited to the existing use value, giving a figure (rounded) of £50,000. The Upper Tribunal agreed with the claimants in part, awarding compensation of £746,000. On the authority’s appeal, the Court of Appeal declined to accept the argument of either party, and remitted the matter to the tribunal to re-determine compensation on what it considered to be the correct basis. The valuation date was 4 January 2006, being the date when the reference land vested in the acquiring authority under a general vesting declaration.
The facts
3. The facts are set out in detail in the Upper Tribunal’s decision. A summary will suffice. The order lands lie about one mile east of Rochdale town centre, on the north-west side of the M62 motorway, close to Junction 21. The reference land, shown as Plots 13 & 14 on the CPO plan, comprises two adjoining parcels of land towards the north east part of the order lands, close to, but not immediately adjoining, a road to the south-east known as Buckley Hill Lane. The claimants relied on the prospect, in the absence of the scheme, of planning permission for residential development being permitted with access from Buckley Hill Lane through an intervening plot known as “the Nib” (also in their ownership but not subject to the CPO).
4. The area has a long planning history. Its potential for development of some form had been recognised since the 1960s. In 1999 developers published a “KBP Development Framework”, in support of an application for planning permission. The framework included a master plan within which the reference land was shown for development of various kinds (including some residential) within phase 5. Planning consents linked to the master…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Homes and Communities Agency v JS Bloor (Wilmslow) Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] UKSC 12
- Decision Date