Hilary Term
[2017] UKSC 33
On appeals from: [2014] EWCA Civ 1574, [2016] EWHC 397 (QB) and
[2016] EWHC 855 (Ch)
| JUDGMENT |
Times Newspapers Limited (Appellant) v Flood (Respondent) Miller (Respondent) v Associated Newspapers Limited (Appellant) Frost and others (Respondents) v MGN Limited (Appellant)
before
Lord Neuberger, President
Lord Mance
Lord Sumption
Lord Hughes
Lord HodgeJUDGMENT GIVEN ON
11 April 2017
Heard on 24, 25 and 26 January 2017
Appellant (Times Respondent (Flood) Newspapers Ltd) Richard Rampton QC James Price QC Ms Kate Wilson William Bennett (Instructed by Bates Wells (Instructed by Edwin Coe & Braithwaite LLP) LLP) Appellant (Associated Respondent (Miller) Newspapers Ltd)
Gavin Millar QC William McCormick QC Ben Silverstone James Laughland (Instructed by Reynolds (Instructed by Simons Porter Chamberlain LLP) Muirhead and Burton) Appellant (MGN Ltd) Respondents
(Frost and ors)
Lord Pannick QC Hugh Tomlinson QC Jamie Carpenter Simon Browne QC
Jeremy Reed
(Instructed by Reynolds (Instructed by Atkins Porter Chamberlain LLP) Thomson) LORD NEUBERGER: (with whom Lord Mance, Lord Sumption, Lord
Hughes and Lord Hodge agree)1. Each of these three appeals involves a challenge to an order for costs made by a High Court judge against a newspaper publisher after a trial. In two of the appeals, Flood v Times Newspapers Ltd and Miller v Associated Newspapers Ltd, the trial involved an allegation that the newspaper had libelled the claimant; in the third appeal, Frost and others v MGN Ltd, the trial involved allegations that the newspaper had unlawfully gathered private information about the claimants by hacking into their phone messages. In each case, the newspaper publisher lost and
was ordered to pay the claimants’ costs, and in each case the newspaper publisher
contends that the costs order infringes its rights under article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. In Flood v TNL, the newspaper publisher also argues that the order for costs made against it was outside the ambit of what a reasonable judge could have decided.
2. In all three cases, the proceedings against the newspaper publisher had been brought by claimants who were able to take advantage of the costs regime introduced by the Access to Justice Act 1999 and reflected in the provisions of the relevant Civil Procedure Rules then in force, in particular CPR 44. It is the provisions of this
regime (“the 1999 Act regime”) which found the basis of the contention that article
10 is infringed. The 1999 Act regime has now been largely replaced by a new regime, and, although the new regime has no bearing on the awards of costs in the present cases, it is of some relevance to the issues which have to be considered. Accordingly, I shall start by briefly describing the 1999 Act regime and its aftermath. I will then summarise the facts of each case before turning to the issues. I will deal first with the article 10 issues which apply in all three cases, and I will finally discuss the issue specific to Flood…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Frost and others (Respondents) v MGN Limited (Appellant) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] UKSC 33
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the Strasbourg court's decision in MGN v UK, which held that the costs regime infringed the newspaper publisher's article 10 rights, should be applied domestically. The court concluded that, while the Strasbourg court's decision was not binding, it should be taken into account by domestic courts. However, the court decided not to follow the Strasbourg court's decision in this case, as it would result in a more substantial injustice to the claimants.
The court also considered whether the costs orders should be amended to exclude the defendants' liability for the claimants' success fees and after-the-event insurance premiums. The court concluded that, while the defendants' article 10 rights were engaged, the claimants had a legitimate expectation that they would be able to recover these costs, based on the law as it stood at the time they entered into their legal agreements. The court held that it would be unjust and contrary to the rule of law to deprive the claimants of this expectation.
Finally, the court considered whether it should make a declaration of incompatibility under section 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998 in relation to the costs regime. The court concluded that it would not be appropriate to do so, as the regime had been superseded by other legislation and the issue did not need to be considered in detail to dispose of the appeals.
The court dismissed all three appeals.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi