Enal v Singh & Ors (Trinidad and Tobago)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

Hilary Term
[2022] UKPC 13
Privy Council Appeal No 0102 of 2019

JUDGMENT

Sumatee Enal (Respondent)

v

Shakuntala Singh and 3 others (Appellants) (Trinidad and Tobago)

From the Court of Appeal of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago

before

Lord Briggs
Lord Kitchin
Lord Hamblen
Lady Rose
Sir Nicholas Patten

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
11 April 2022

Heard on 24 February 2022

Appellants (Shakuntala Singh, Kiran Singh, Roshini Singh and Andra Singh)
Oliver Radley-Gardner QC
Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj SC
(Instructed by Sheridans)

Respondent
Ernest H Koylass SC
Debbie Roopchand
Yuklan Koylass
(Instructed by Nera Narine (Trinidad))

 

SIR NICHOLAS PATTEN:

  1. This is an appeal by the defendants against an order of the Court of Appeal dated 12 February 2019 which set aside a deed of conveyance dated 4 January 2006 of two parcels of land at 6-8 High Street, San Fernando (“the 2006 Deed”). The deed is registered as No DE200601475095D001.
  2. The land at 6-8 High Street (“the Disputed Property”) was acquired by the late Ravidath Ramnarine Maharaj (also called Ravi Maharaj (“Ravi”)) and his sister, the first defendant, Shakuntala Singh (“Shakuntala”) as joint tenants under a deed of conveyance dated 1 July 1976 together with two other adjoining parcels of land at 2 and 4 High Street, San Fernando (“the 1976 Deed”). The second defendant, Kiran Singh (“Kiran”) is her son. The third and fourth defendants, Roshini Singh and Andra Singh, are the daughter and stepdaughter respectively of Shakuntala. Ravi was murdered on 11 January 2006. The claimant, Sumatee Enal, was his common-law wife and is the sole executrix and beneficiary of his estate.
  3. Ravi and Shakuntala are the children of Ramnarine Ramphal Maharaj (“Mr Maharaj”) who died on 11 July 2006. It is common ground that he was a successful businessman who acquired and developed a large number of properties during the course of his life. It is also not in dispute that on a number of occasions properties were purchased by his children using funds provided by Mr Maharaj and that he retained a power of attorney which enabled him to deal with or dispose of the properties. The Board shall come to the detail of this a little later.
  4. The 1976 Deed was a conveyance of the various High Street properties by the liquidator of W S Robertson & Company Ltd to Ravi and Shakuntala as joint tenants in fee simple “at the request and by the direction” of Mr Maharaj who is described in the deed as their agent and who is recorded as having paid the purchase price of $200,000.
  5. At the time of the 1976 conveyance Ravi was 34 years old. Although he came to be wealthy through his property and other business interests Ravi had qualified and practised as a doctor. In May 1964 while a medical student living in Canada he had executed a power of attorney in favour of his father (“the 1964 Power of Attorney”). This was revocable unilaterally at any time and did not apply to the three specific properties…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Enal v Singh & Ors (Trinidad and Tobago) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] UKPC 13
Decision Date