Dunnachie v Kingston-upon-Hull

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read
  1.   I have had the advantage of reading in draft the speech of my noble and learned friend Lord Steyn. For the reasons he gives, with which I agree, I would allow this appeal.
  2. LORD STEYN

    My Lords,

  3.   This appeal raises an important point on the proper construction of section 123(1) of the Employment Rights Act 1996. Section 123 provides for the making of a compensatory award for unfair dismissal. It reads, so far as it is material, as follows:
    "(1) Subject to the provisions of this section and sections 124 [,126, 127 and 127A(1), (3) and (4)], the amount of the compensatory award shall be such amount as the tribunal considers just and equitable in all the circumstances having regard to the loss sustained by the complainant in consequence of the dismissal in so far as that loss is attributable to action taken by the employer.

    (2) The loss referred to in subsection (1) shall be taken to include -

      (a) any expenses reasonably incurred by the complainant in consequence of the dismissal, and

      (b) subject to subsection (3), loss of any benefit which he might reasonably be expected to have had but for the dismissal.

      (3) The loss referred to in subsection (1) shall be taken to include in respect of any loss of -

      (a) any entitlement or potential entitlement to a payment on account of dismissal by reason of redundancy (whether in pursuance of Part XI or otherwise), or

      (b) any expectation of such a payment,

      only the loss referable to the amount (if any) by which the amount of that payment would have exceeded the amount of a basic award (apart from any reduction under section 122) in respect of the same dismissal."

Omitting the opening words of qualification in section 123(1), which are not directly relevant, the question is whether this provision allows compensation to be awarded for non-economic damage. An employee, who claims to have suffered humiliation, injury to feelings and distress, as a result of a constructive dismissal, argues that properly construed section 123(1) allows for the recovery of non-pecuniary heads of loss. The employer argues that section 123(1) only permits recovery of pecuniary loss. This is the central dispute of statutory construction before the House.

  •   The ultimate genesis of section 123(1) of the 1996 Act was section 116(1) of the Industrial Relations Act 1971. For present purposes the re-enactment of section 116 by Schedule 1, para 19, of the Trade Union and Labour Relations Act 1974, by section 76 of the Employment Protection Act 1975 and by section 74 of the Employment Protection (Consolidation) Act 1978 are not material. Section 116(1) of the 1971 Act provided:
    • ". . . the amount of the compensation shall . . . be such amount as the Court or tribunal considers just and equitable in all the circumstances, having regard to the loss sustained by the aggrieved party in consequence of the matters to which the complaint relates, in so far as that loss was attributable…
    CaseChat AU logo

    Keep reading for free

    Create a free CaseChat account to read Dunnachie v Kingston-upon-Hull and more:

    • Read every judgment in full
    • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
    • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
    • Download judgments as PDF or Word
    Continue with Google

    One click creates your free account or signs you in.

    By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

    Details
    Case
    [2004] UKHL 36
    Decision Date

    CaseChat Overview and Summary

    Orders

    Orders of the court

    Background

    Background to the litigation

    Evidence

    Evidence Before The Court

    Decision

    Reasons for decision

    Ratio Decidendi

    Legal Principle Established