Cream Holdings Ltd & Ors v. Banerjee & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
  1.   The Human Rights Act 1998 introduced into the law of this country the concept of Convention rights. Section 12 made special provision regarding one of these rights: the right to freedom of expression. When considering whether to grant relief which, if granted, might affect the exercise of the Convention right to freedom of expression the court must have particular regard to the importance of this right: section 12(4). Additionally, section 12(2) set out a prerequisite to the grant of relief against a person who is neither present nor represented. The court must be satisfied the applicant has taken all practicable steps to notify the respondent or that there are compelling reasons why the respondent should not be notified. Further, section 12(3) imposed a threshold test which has to be satisfied before a court may grant interlocutory injunctive relief:
    'No such relief [which might affect the exercise of the Convention right to freedom of expression] is to be granted so as to restrain publication before trial unless the court is satisfied that the applicant is likely to establish that publication should not be allowed.'

  •   On this appeal your Lordships' House is concerned with the meaning and application of the word 'likely' in this provision.
  •     The factual context

  •   The context in which this question arises on this appeal is as follows. The plaintiffs in this action are the Cream group of companies. These companies began as the Cream nightclub in Liverpool in 1992 and then expanded and diversified their business. They opened other clubs elsewhere and began to stage large events such as dance festivals. Now they also carry on a substantial business franchising their brand name and logo and merchandising clothes and other items. They are an important business in Liverpool featuring both on general news pages and financial pages of newspapers.
  •   The first defendant, Chumki Banerjee, is a chartered accountant. She was the financial controller of one of the companies in the Cream group for three years from February 1998 to January 2001. Before then Ms Banerjee worked for a firm of accountants and was responsible for dealing with the Cream group's financial affairs between 1996 and 1998. The second defendant, which I shall refer to simply as the 'Echo', is the publisher of Merseyside's two long-established and leading daily newspapers, the 'Daily Post' and the 'Liverpool Echo'.
  •   In January 2001 Cream dismissed Ms Banerjee. When she left she took with her copies of documents she claims show illegal and improper activity by the Cream group. She passed these to the Echo with additional information. She received no payments for this. On 13 and 14 June 2002 the Echo published articles about alleged corruption involving one director of the Cream group and a local council official. On 18 June 2002 the Cream group sought injunctive relief to restrain publication by the newspaper of any further confidential information given it by Ms Banerjee.
  •     The proceedings

  •   The defendants admitted the information was confidential. Their defence was that disclosure was in the public…
  • CaseChat AU logo

    Keep reading for free

    Create a free CaseChat account to read Cream Holdings Ltd & Ors v. Banerjee & Ors and more:

    • Read every judgment in full
    • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
    • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
    • Download judgments as PDF or Word
    Continue with Google

    One click creates your free account or signs you in.

    By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

    Details
    Case
    [2004] UKHL 44
    Decision Date

    CaseChat Overview and Summary

    AI summary not yet generated for this case.

    Orders

    Orders of the court

    Full text does not contain this section.

    Background

    Background to the litigation

    Full text does not contain this section.

    Evidence

    Evidence Before The Court

    Full text does not contain this section.

    Decision

    Reasons for decision

    Full text does not contain this section.

    Ratio Decidendi

    Legal Principle Established

    Full text does not contain this section.