Concord Trust v Law Debenture Trust Corporation Plc

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read
  1.   I have had the advantage of reading the opinion of my noble and learned friend Lord Scott of Foscote. I agree with it. For the reasons given by Lord Scott I would make the order which he proposes.
  2. LORD HOFFMANN

    My Lords,

  3.   I have had the advantage of reading in draft the speech of my noble and learned friend Lord Scott of Foscote. For the reasons he gives, with which I agree, I would make the order which he proposes.
  4. LORD HUTTON

    My Lords,

  5.   I have had the advantage of reading in draft the opinion of my noble and learned friend Lord Scott of Foscote. I agree with it and for the reasons which he gives I would make the order which he proposes.
  6. LORD SCOTT OF FOSCOTE

    My Lords,

    The Issues

  7.   This appeal requires two issues to be decided. The first is a short point of construction of Condition 12 of the terms ("the Bond Terms") applicable to a Eurobond issue of _510 million 2 per cent bonds ('the Bonds') which fall due for payment in December 2005. The Bonds were issued in 1999 by Elektrim Finance BV ("Elektrim Finance") and guaranteed by Elektrim Finance's parent company, Elektrim SA. When it is not necessary to distinguish between the two companies I will, for convenience, refer to them together as "Elektrim". In November 2002 the Bonds were restructured, the principal sum outstanding being increased to the _510 million. The Bond Terms, as amended, were set out in the 2nd Schedule to a Trust Deed dated 15 November 2002. The parties to this Trust Deed were Elektrim and the Law Debenture Trust Corporation plc ("the Trustee"). The Bonds are marketable securities, traded internationally. There is no contractual privity between Elektrim on the one hand and the bondholders on the other hand. The covenants by Elektrim for payment of the principal sum and interest due on the Bonds were covenants entered into with the Trustee (see clauses 2, 7 and 8 of the Trust Deed). Concord Trust holds some 10 per cent in value of the Bonds.
  8.   Condition 12 of the Bond Terms provides that:
    "The Bond Trustee at its discretion may, and if so requested in writing by the holders of at least thirty per cent in principal amount outstanding of the Bonds or if so directed by an Extraordinary Resolution of the Bondholders shall (subject in each case to being indemnified to its satisfaction), give notice to the Issuer and the Guarantor that the Bonds are, and they shall immediately become, due and repayable at their relevant redemption value, together with the accrued Interest Amount as provided in the Bond Trust Deed, upon the occurrence of any of the following events ("Events of Default") … ".

  •   Fourteen potential "Events of Default" were described. The second of them included a failure by Elektrim "to perform or observe" any of its obligations under the Bonds or the Trust Deed (see para.(ii) of Condition 12). However a proviso to Condition 12 has the…
  • CaseChat AU logo

    Keep reading for free

    Create a free CaseChat account to read Concord Trust v Law Debenture Trust Corporation Plc and more:

    • Read every judgment in full
    • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
    • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
    • Download judgments as PDF or Word
    Continue with Google

    One click creates your free account or signs you in.

    By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

    Details
    Case
    [2005] UKHL 27
    Decision Date

    CaseChat Overview and Summary

    AI summary not yet generated for this case.

    Orders

    Orders of the court

    Full text does not contain this section.

    Background

    Background to the litigation

    Full text does not contain this section.

    Evidence

    Evidence Before The Court

    Full text does not contain this section.

    Decision

    Reasons for decision

    Full text does not contain this section.

    Ratio Decidendi

    Legal Principle Established

    Full text does not contain this section.