Competition and Markets Authority (Respondent) v Pfizer Inc and another (Appellants)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read
Easter Term
[2022] UKSC 14
On appeal from: [2020] EWCA Civ 617

JUDGMENT

Competition and Markets Authority (Respondent) v Flynn Pharma Ltd and another (Appellants)
Competition and Markets Authority (Respondent) v Pfizer Inc and another (Appellants)

before

Lord Hodge, Deputy President
Lord Sales
Lord Leggatt
Lord Stephens
Lady Rose

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON
25 May 2022

Heard on 22 and 23 February 2022

Appellants (Flynn Pharma Ltd and Flynn Pharma (Holdings) Ltd)
Daniel Jowell QC
Tom Pascoe
(Instructed by Macfarlanes LLP)

Appellants (Pfizer Inc and Pfizer Ltd)
Mark Brealey QC
Tim Johnston
(Instructed by Clifford Chance LLP (London))

Respondent (Competition and Markets Authority)
Sir James Eadie QC
Rob Williams QC
David Bailey
Rupert Paines
(Instructed by Competition and Markets Authority)

1st Interveners (Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry (ABPI) and British Generic Manufacturers Association (BGMA))
(written submissions only)
Daniel Piccinin
(Instructed by Bristows LLP (London))

2nd Intervener (Office of Communications (Ofcom))
(written submissions only)
Josh Holmes QC
Jessica Boyd
(Instructed by OFCOM)

3rd Intervener (Solicitors Regulation Authority Ltd (SRA))
(written submissions only)
Andrew Tabachnik QC
Ruth Keating
(Instructed by Solicitors Regulation Authority Ltd)

4th Intervener (Oakridge Farms Ltd)
(written submissions only)
Charles Streeten
(Instructed by Woodfines LLP (Milton Keynes))

LADY ROSE: (with whom Lord Hodge, Lord Sales, Lord Leggatt and Lord Stephens agree)

1.INTRODUCTION

  1. The appellants in these proceedings were successful in an appeal which they brought before the Competition Appeal Tribunal (“the CAT”) under section 46 of the Competition Act 1998. In that appeal they challenged a decision adopted by the Respondent (“the CMA”) fining them for an infringement of competition law.

  1. The CAT allowed the appellants’ appeal in part, set aside part of the CMA’s decision and remitted the decision to the CMA for reconsideration. On the appellants’ application for their costs of the appeal, the CAT made an order that the CMA pay the appellants a proportion of those costs. The Court of Appeal in the judgment now under appeal before this court set aside the CAT’s costs order and directed that there be no order as to costs. The Court of Appeal held that the CAT had erred in ordering the CMA to pay the appellants’ costs because it had disregarded a principle derived from a line of cases starting with Bradford Metropolitan District Council v Booth [2000] 164 JP 485. That principle was, the Court of Appeal held, that where, as here, a tribunal’s power to make an order about costs does not include an express general rule or default position, the starting point is that no order for costs should be made against a public body that has been unsuccessful in bringing or defending proceedings in the exercise of its statutory functions.

  1. The appellants now appeal to this court arguing that the Court of Appeal was wrong to hold that the CAT’s discretion as to what costs order to make was constrained by any such principle. They argue that there is no such principle and that what is established by the case law is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Competition and Markets Authority (Respondent) v Pfizer Inc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] UKSC 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal brought by Flynn Pharma Ltd and Flynn Pharma (Holdings) Ltd (Flynn) and Pfizer Inc and Pfizer Ltd (Pfizer) (the appellants) against a decision of the Court of Appeal (CMA v Flynn Pharma Ltd and another [2020] EWCA Civ 617). The appellants challenged the Court of Appeal’s decision to set aside an order of the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) which had awarded the appellants a proportion of their costs of their appeal against a decision of the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) fining them for an infringement of competition law. The CAT had awarded the appellants costs on the basis that, as the successful party, they were entitled to recover their costs of the appeal. The Court of Appeal held that the CAT had disregarded the principle that, in proceedings by or against a regulator in the exercise of its statutory functions, the default position is that no order for costs should be made against the regulator, except for good reason. The Court of Appeal substituted an order for no costs.The appellants argued that the Court of Appeal had erred in concluding that there was such a principle. They argued that the only principle was that, in exercising its discretion, a court or tribunal should take into account the risk that there will be a chilling effect on the conduct of the public body if costs orders are routinely made against it in those kinds of proceedings, even where the body has acted reasonably in bringing or defending the application.The Court held that the Court of Appeal had been wrong to hold that there was a general principle that a court or tribunal exercising such a discretion should adopt as its starting point that it will not make an order for costs where the unsuccessful respondent is a public body defending a decision it has taken in the exercise of its functions in the public interest unless there is some good reason to do so; the lack of success not being of itself a good reason to depart from that starting point. The Court held that there was no generally applicable principle that all public bodies should enjoy a protected status as parties to litigation where they lose a case which they have brought or defended in the exercise of their public functions in the public interest. The principle supported by the Booth line of cases was, rather, that where a public body is unsuccessful in proceedings, an important factor that a court or tribunal exercising an apparently unfettered discretion should take into account was the risk that there will be a chilling effect on the conduct of the public body if costs orders are routinely made against it in those kinds of proceedings, even where the body had acted reasonably in bringing or defending the application. The Court held that the CAT had been entitled to apply the starting point it had established in the earlier Eden Brown decision and that the CAT’s assessment as to the appropriate starting point in Eden Brown was consistent with what the Court of Appeal said in BT v Ofcom (Business Connectivity). The CAT had undertaken precisely the task that was remitted to it by the Court of Appeal in BT v Ofcom (Business Connectivity). The Court held that the CAT was entitled to conclude that the substantive legislative framework and the applicable procedural provisions relevant to assessing the starting point in Competition Act cases did not point towards a different answer.The appeal was allowed. The Court of Appeal’s order for no costs was set aside and the CAT’s order awarding the appellants a proportion of their costs of the appeal was restored.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established