Armbrister & Anor v Lightbourn & Anor (Bahamas)

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

    [2012] UKPC 40
    Privy Council Appeal No 0034 of 2010





    JUDGMENT

    (1) Anthony Armbrister
    (2) Cyril Armbrister (as personal representatives of the Estate of Francis Armbrister) (Appellants)
    v
    (1) Marion E Lightbourn
    (2) Robin Mactaggart Symonette (in her capacity as the sole surviving executrix of the Estate of Sheila M Mactaggart – substituted Petitioner for Sheila M Mactaggart) (Respondents)

    From the Court of Appeal of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas

    before

    Lord Walker
    Lord Clarke
    Lord Sumption
    Lord Carnwath
    Sir Stephen Sedley


    JUDGMENT DELIVERED BY
    LORD WALKER
    ON



    11 December 2012

    Heard on 29 – 30 October 2012


    Appellant
    Miss Carolyn Walton
    Miss Hannah Ilett
    (Instructed by E P Toothe & Associates)
      Respondent
    James Dingemans QC
    Timothy Evans
    (Bahamas Bar)
    (Instructed by Charles Russell LLP)
    Respondent
    James Dingemans QC
    Timothy Evans
    (Bahamas Bar)
    (Instructed by Charles Russell LLP)
       

     
    LORD WALKER:
    Introduction
  1. This is an appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas in proceedings under the Quieting Titles Act 1959, Ch 393 ("the 1959 Act"). The original application was made over 30 years ago, by a petition presented on 15 March 1982 by two sisters, Marion E Lightbourn and Sheila M Mactaggart ("Mrs Mactaggart"), who were devisees under the will of their father, Herbert Arnold McKinney ("Mr McKinney"). On 5 July 1982 an adverse claim was made in the proceedings by Frances Fintel Armbrister ("Mrs Frances Armbrister"). During the protracted course of the proceedings Mrs Mactaggart and Mrs Frances Armbrister have died, as have two of Mrs Mactaggart's personal representatives. The parties are now Mrs Lightbourn and Robin Mactaggart Symonette (the surviving personal representative of Mrs Mactaggart) as respondents in the main appeal and Anthony Armbrister ("Anthony Armbrister") and his brother Cyril Armbrister (the personal representatives of Mrs Frances Armbrister) as appellants in the main appeal. There is also a cross-appeal in which their positions as appellants and respondents are reversed.
  2. The documents before the Board were in some disarray, consisting of five agreed bundles, one bundle of documents (some from each side) which were not agreed, and a further bundle containing a notice of application filed on behalf of the appellants on 3 May 2011, together with the documents to which it relates. All except the last bundle have a single uniform system of pagination. To facilitate identification in the different bundles, page references are included in the Board's advice. With the helpful cooperation of counsel the need for argument about documents has been largely avoided.
  3. The main appeal is concerned with title to an area of land, well over 400 acres in extent, on Cat Island. Cat Island lies between the islands of Eleuthera and San Salvador (confusingly, Cat Island was itself formerly called San Salvador). Cat Island is for the most part long and narrow in shape, with its length extending from the point nearest Eleuthera at the north-west to the point nearest San Salvador to the south-east. The land in question in the main appeal, the southern half of the Freeman Hall…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Armbrister & Anor v Lightbourn & Anor (Bahamas) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] UKPC 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established