Zyxcba Developments Limited v Auckland Council

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-2306 [2015] NZHC 1085

UNDER the Declaratory Judgments Act 1908

BETWEEN

ZYXCBA DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

AUCKLAND COUNCIL Defendant

Hearing: 18, 19 May 2015

Appearances:

M E Casey QC and A Davidson for the Plaintiff
D J Neutze and M C Allan for the Defendant

Judgment:

19 May 2015

ORAL JUDGMENT OF MUIR J

Counsel/Solicitors:

M E Casey QC, Barrister, Auckland

P Castle, Castle Brown, Auckland
D J Neutze, Brookfields, Auckland

M C Allan, Brookfields, Auckland

ZYXCBA DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED v AUCKLAND COUNCIL [2015] NZHC 1085 [19 May 2015]

[1]     At the conclusion of the first day of trial the plaintiff tabled proposed amendments to its prayer for relief and foreshadowed an application for leave to amend its statement of claim accordingly.  Argument took place in that respect this morning.

[2]      The background to that proposed amendment is as follows.  The statement of claim was filed on 2 September 2014.   That statement of claim sought by way of relief three declarations:

(i)       The vested Lots are to be valued on the basis of a zoning as Flatbush

Residential 1.

(ii)The trees and bush cover are to be separately valued and added to the value of the underlying land.

(iii)     The consent notice is to be disregarded in the valuation exercise.

[3]      At  the  first  case  management  conference  before  Bell  AJ,  the  plaintiff indicated that it may wish, in the words of the Minute of His Honour, to “refine the relief sought and also address some minor glitches in the statement of claim”. Directions were made accordingly.  Pursuant to that direction an amended statement of claim was filed on 24 February 2015.  The relief sought in the amended statement of claim was in terms that:

When valuing the land for the purposes of determining the price to be paid by  the  defendant  counsel  to  the  plaintiff  consent  holder  in  terms  of conditions 52 and 53 of the subdivision consent the valuers are to:

(i)        value  the  land  on  the  basis  of  its  value  for  reserve  purposes, including the  added  value of  the  features  of the  land  (including topography, trees and bush cover) for such purposes;

(ii)      the value of the trees and bush cover should be added to the value of the land as if it were without trees and bush cover;

(iii)      treat the consent notice D37504244.2 as adding value to the land when acquired or vested for reserve purposes.

The   Council   filed   an   amended   statement   of   defence   to   that   pleading   on

10 March 2015.

[4]      Evidence was exchanged on the basis of the amended pleadings and was complete by 10 April 2015.

[5]      The close of pleadings date was 20 April 2015.

[6]      Now, in the course of the hearing, the plaintiff seeks quite significant changes to the prayer for relief.  Its proposed new pleading is in terms that:

(1)       When valuing the land for the purpose of determining the price to be paid by the defendant Council to the plaintiff…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zyxcba Developments Limited v Auckland Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 1085
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Zyxcba Developments Limited v Auckland Council, the plaintiff sought significant changes to its relief sought during the course of a trial in the High Court of New Zealand. The plaintiff, Zyxcba Developments Limited, sought three declarations in its amended statement of claim, which the defendant, Auckland Council, opposed. The plaintiff sought a valuation of the land for the purposes of determining the price to be paid by the defendant to the plaintiff, with certain conditions attached. The Auckland Council opposed the proposed amendments, arguing that the amendments would cause significant delay and prejudice to their case.

The court considered the relevant principles governing applications to amend pleadings at this stage of the proceedings, including the interests of justice, whether the amendment would significantly prejudice the other party, whether it would cause significant delay, the merits of the proposed amendment, and the timing of the application for leave. The court found that the proposed amendments could not be viewed as minor in the context of a declaratory judgment proceeding where the wording of the proposed declarations was critical to the claim. The court further found that the proposed amendments raised new and significantly different issues that had not been signalled in the amended statement of claim or the plaintiff's evidence-in-chief, and that the Council had not had an opportunity to advance evidence in response to the new allegations.

The court declined to allow the amendment sought to paragraphs 1(a) and 1(b) of the relief. The court found that the proposed amendments raised theoretical issues that were not significantly informed by matters of evidence, and that the Council had not had an opportunity to advance evidence in response to the new allegations. The court found that the proposed amendments would be unfair to the Council and would cause significant delay. The court allowed the amendment in relation to 1(c) of the relief, finding that the changes that were foreshadowed could be adequately dealt with in submission and did not require any additional evidence.

In conclusion, the court found that the proposed amendments raised new and significantly different issues that had not been signalled in the amended statement of claim or the plaintiff's evidence-in-chief, and that the Council had not had an opportunity to advance evidence in response to the new allegations. The court found that the proposed amendments would be unfair to the Council and would cause significant delay, and declined to allow the amendment sought to paragraphs 1(a) and 1(b) of the relief. The court allowed the amendment in relation to 1(c) of the relief, finding that the changes that were foreshadowed could be adequately dealt with in submission and did not require any additional evidence. The court fixed costs as payable to the defendant in relation to the application on a 2B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established