Zondag and Zondag v Zondag

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA334/2007
CA558/2007
[2008] NZCA 321

BETWEENBERRY ZONDAG AND MEI ZONDAG


Appellants

ANDHERMANUS JOHANNUS GERARDUS ZONDAG


Respondent

Hearing:23 July 2008

Court:Hammond, Chisholm and Miller JJ

Counsel:B Zondag in person for Appellants


D M O'Neill for Respondent

Judgment:27 August 2008 at 2.15 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A.       THE APPEALS ARE DISMISSED.

B.The appellants must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Chisholm J)

[1]       These appeals arise out of an extraordinarily bitter dispute between two brothers (and the wife of one of them) in relation to the sale of land and the erection of a house and associated infrastructure.  Although these were not necessarily all full days, the dispute occupied a total of 22 hearing days in the High Court and gave rise to a substantive judgment of 144 pages, as well as a lengthy judgment on costs and interest. 

[2]       Numerous issues have been raised by the appellants in relation to both judgments.  To a large extent they are attempting to challenge every finding that is unfavourable to them.  It is significant that when making his opening statement to us Berry Zondag acknowledged with reference to the substantive judgment that “virtually the entire judgment turns on findings of credibility”.  We will have more to say about that later. 

[3]       In this judgment we will refer to the appellant Berry Zondag as “Berry” and the respondent Hermanus Zondag as “Hans”. 

Background

[4]       In 1992 Berry and his wife, Mei, emigrated from the Netherlands to New Zealand.  For most of his career in the Netherlands Berry had been involved with a computer company, ultimately serving as its managing director.  Before that he had gained diplomas in architecture and law from universities in the Netherlands and had spent some time working in the construction industry.

[5]       After emigrating to New Zealand Berry and his wife purchased a 300 acre block of land near Thames and subdivided it into ten lifestyle lots (the subdivision).  They built a house on Lot 7 for themselves and began to design, build and sell houses on the remaining lots.  Since arriving in New Zealand Berry has completed a law degree. 

[6]       Hans practised as an actuary in the Netherlands and established an actuarial consultancy firm in that country.  After selling his interest in that firm, and having visited Berry and Mei in New Zealand during 1998 and again in 1999, Hans became interested in emigrating to New Zealand with his family. 

[7]       It was proposed that Hans would buy lot 6 in the subdivision and that Berry would build a house for him on that lot.  Hans alleges that after he received approval to immigrate to New Zealand in September 2000, his brother agreed to design and build a house and associated infrastructure on the lot for a fixed price plus extras and variations.  Berry, on the other hand, alleges that the arrangement was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zondag and Zondag v Zondag and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NZCA 321
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, the appeals of Berry Zondag and Mei Zondag against the decision of Nicholson J in the High Court were dismissed. The appellants challenged numerous findings of fact and law made by the trial Judge, as well as the costs judgment. The primary issue was whether there was a fixed price contract for the construction of a house on a property, and if Hans Zondag had overpaid Berry Zondag and Mei Zondag. The Court of Appeal found that the trial Judge's findings of fact, particularly on credibility, were not capable of being overturned and that the Judge's conclusions on the substantive and costs judgments were correct. The appeals were dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 1992 Berry and his wife Mei emigrated from the Netherlands to New Zealand and purchased a 300-acre block of land near Thames, which they subdivided into ten lifestyle lots. They built a house on Lot 7 for themselves and began to design, build, and sell houses on the remaining lots. In 2000, Hans, Berry's brother, became interested in emigrating to New Zealand and purchasing Lot 6 in the subdivision. Hans and Berry entered into an agreement for Berry to design and build a house on Lot 6 for Hans. The terms of the agreement, however, were disputed, with Hans claiming a fixed price agreement and Berry contending a cost-plus arrangement. By August 2001, when Hans and his family arrived in New Zealand, the house on Lot 6 was completed, but there were issues with the car park and septic tank placement. Berry and Mei proposed to transfer 327m2 from Lot 7 to Lot 6 to resolve the issue, but Hans claimed they had agreed to transfer 1,676m2. The dispute escalated, and on 8 October 2002, Hans issued proceedings in the High Court seeking specific performance of the alleged agreement to transfer 1,676m2. Berry and Mei responded by alleging that Hans owed them a further $296,040.73 for the design and construction of the house and infrastructure. Hans requested a full accounting, and after reviewing the documents, concluded that he had been overcharged and that Berry and Mei owed him $381,305. The relationship between the parties deteriorated sharply.

Hans amended his pleadings by adding six additional causes of action and caveated Lot 7. A failed attempt at mediation was followed by numerous interlocutory hearings. The trial before Nicholson J commenced on 19 July 2005 and was not completed until 25 January 2006 due to disruptions and deficient time estimates. On 19 June 2007, Nicholson J issued his substantive judgment, and on 28 September 2007, the judgment as to costs and interest followed. Both parties appealed against the substantive judgment and costs judgment, leading to this appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Court err in making many of its findings on the basis of "oral allegations and credibility only" without considering later amendments to the documents underpinning the finding of dishonesty?
2. Were pertinent issues about credibility findings properly pleaded by the plaintiff, and did the Court fail to accurately consider issues about Hans' credibility?
3. Did the Court err in concluding that there was a fixed price contract with provision for variations and extras, and that Hans was entitled to have the overpayment returned to him?
4. Was it open to the Court to grant relief on the ground of a mistaken payment?
5. Did the Court err in concluding that there was an enforceable agreement for the boundary adjustment and that there had been part performance?
6. Was the Court's approach to awarding costs on a proportionality of trial success basis appropriate, and did it correctly apply the relevant principles?

Held
1. The Court held that it was not open to it to overturn the trial Judge's findings of credibility based on oral allegations and documentary evidence, and there was no breach of natural justice in the proceedings.
2. The Court found that pertinent issues about credibility findings were properly pleaded by the plaintiff and the Court accurately considered the issues about Hans' credibility.
3. The Court held that there was no error in concluding that there was a fixed price contract with provision for variations and extras and that Hans was entitled to have the overpayment returned to him.
4. The Court held that it was open to grant relief on the ground of a mistaken payment.
5. The Court held that it was open to conclude that there was an enforceable agreement for the boundary adjustment and that there had been part performance.
6. The Court held that the approach to awarding costs on a proportionality of trial success basis was appropriate and the Judge correctly applied the relevant principles.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by acknowledging the well-established principle that appellate courts should only interfere with a trial Judge's findings of fact in exceptional circumstances, as they are better placed to assess the credibility and reliability of witnesses. The Court found no sound basis to overturn the trial Judge's findings of credibility, particularly given the documentary evidence of dishonesty by Berry. The Court rejected Berry's contentions that the Judge failed to consider later amendments to the documents underpinning the credibility findings or that pertinent issues about credibility had not been properly pleaded. The Court also found that the Judge had carefully considered the credibility of both brothers.
The Court turned to the substantive judgment, starting with the primary issue of the construction of the house. The Court found that the Judge's conclusions in relation to the fixed price contract with provision for variations and extras, and the overpayment, were open to him and based on the evidence. The Court rejected Berry's argument that estoppel applied, as it was not pleaded and the facts did not support it. The Court also found no error in the Judge's approach to determining the allowance for variations and extras and in concluding that Hans was entitled to a refund of the overpayment.
The Court considered the remaining grounds of appeal against the substantive judgment and found them to be without merit. It found that the Judge was entitled to conclude there was an enforceable agreement for the boundary adjustment and that there had been part performance, to vary the easement to include the driveway encroachment, and to reject the counterclaims. The Court also found no error in the costs judgment, including the award of costs on a proportionality of trial success basis.
The Court's reasoning demonstrated a clear understanding of the principles governing appellate review of findings of fact, the objective approach to contract interpretation, and the equitable remedy of restitution for mistaken payments. The ratio decidendi is that appellate courts should defer to trial Judges' findings of credibility unless shown to be clearly wrong, and that equitable relief for mistaken payments is available where the payor made the payment in the mistaken belief that it was justified by the contract terms.