| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA615/2019 [2020] NZCA 229 |
| BETWEEN | ZINDIA LIMITED |
| AND | MARLBOROUGH DISTRICT COUNCIL |
| Court: | Brown and Collins JJ |
Counsel: | Q A M Davies and J S Marshall for Applicant |
Judgment: | 11 June 2020 at 2.30 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
The application for leave to appeal is granted on the following question of law:
Did the High Court Judge err when she construed the meaning and scope of Consents U120345.1 and U120345.6?
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Collins J)
Zindia Ltd (Zindia) seeks leave to appeal a High Court decision overturning the Environment Court’s cancellation of an abatement notice.[1] The Marlborough District Council (the Council) issued the notice, alleging that Zindia was in breach of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the Act). The abatement notice was issued on the basis that Zindia’s commercial harvesting of a forest in Queen Charlotte Sound did not comply with the relevant regional rule and s 9 of the Act.
[1]Zindia Ltd v Marlborough District Council [2019] NZEnvC 30 [Environment Court judgment]; and Marlborough District Council v Zindia Ltd [2019] NZHC 2765, (2019) 21 ELRNZ 364 [High Court judgment].
A second appeal from a decision of the Environment Court requires leave of this Court, and can only be granted if the appeal engages a question of law and:[2]
(a)where the appeal involves a matter of general or public importance; or
(b)where a miscarriage of justice may have occurred or may occur unless the appeal is heard.
Background
[2]Resource Management Act 1991, s 308; and Criminal Procedure Act 2011, s 303.
Zindia operates a forestry block in Queen Charlotte Sound pursuant to resource consents issued by the Council. Believing that commercial harvesting of forestry was not permitted by the resource consents it had granted, the Council issued an abatement notice directing Zindia to cease harvesting the forest and not recommence its operations.
The Environment Court found that the resource consents did encompass harvesting and cancelled the abatement notice.[3] The Council appealed to the High Court.[4] Doogue J considered seven questions of law raised by the Council and concluded that the Environment Court had erred in its interpretation of the scope of the resource consents. In allowing the appeal, she reinstated the abatement notice.
The application for leave
[3]Environment Court judgment, above n 1, at [71].
[4]Resource Management Act, s 299.
In its application for leave to appeal to this Court, Zindia has proposed the appeal proceed in relation to the following questions of law:
(a)Is the interpretation of a resource consent a question of law?
(b)Is a resource consent, when expressed as an exemption from a particular rule, properly viewed as permission to undertake an activity?
(c)Did the High Court err in not referring the case back to the Environment Court to address outstanding questions not addressed in the Environment Court?
(d)Did the High Court err…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Zindia Limited v Marlborough District Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NZCA 229
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal found that the second, third and fourth questions did not warrant leave being granted as they did not raise matters of sufficient general or public importance or point to a miscarriage of justice. However, the Court found that there was a legitimate question of law raised by the first proposed question of law. The Court concluded that the proposed appeal involved a quintessential question of law, as recognised by the fact that the High Court Judge reached her conclusions when answering three questions of law that arose from the Environment Court decision. The Court was not satisfied that the proposed appeal involved a matter of general or public importance, as the issue raised was likely to be confined to the interests of the parties. However, the Court found that there was a genuine risk that a miscarriage of justice may occur unless the appeal was heard, as if the High Court Judge erred in her approach to the interpretation of the resource consents, this would have deprived Zindia of its appeal on the correct understanding of the consents.
The Court granted the application for leave to appeal on the following question of law: Did the High Court Judge err when she construed the meaning and scope of Consents U120345.1 and U120345.6? The Court of Appeal will now hear the appeal on this question of law.
No orders were made regarding the final outcome of the appeal, as the Court of Appeal had only granted leave to appeal on a specific question of law. The appeal will now proceed to the Court of Appeal to determine whether the High Court Judge erred in her interpretation of the meaning and scope of Consents U120345.1 and U120345.6.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated in the Environment Court, where Zindia Limited successfully challenged the abatement notice issued by the Marlborough District Council. The Council appealed to the High Court, which allowed the appeal and reinstated the abatement notice. Zindia Limited then applied for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The Court of Appeal considered the application for leave to appeal on the basis of questions of law raised by Zindia Limited, ultimately granting leave to appeal on a specific question regarding the interpretation of the resource consents.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the High Court Judge err when she construed the meaning and scope of Consents U120345.1 and U120345.6?
2. Is the interpretation of a resource consent a question of law?
3. Is a resource consent, when expressed as an exemption from a particular rule, properly viewed as permission to undertake an activity?
4. Did the High Court err in not referring the case back to the Environment Court to address outstanding questions not addressed in the Environment Court?
5. Did the High Court err in not referring the case back to the Environment Court in order to give effect to concessions made by the Council in the High Court?
Held
1. The Court granted leave to appeal on the question of whether the High Court Judge erred when she construed the meaning and scope of Consents U120345.1 and U120345.6.
2. The Court did not rule on whether the interpretation of a resource consent is a question of law.
3. The Court did not rule on whether a resource consent, when expressed as an exemption from a particular rule, is properly viewed as permission to undertake an activity.
4. The Court did not rule on whether the High Court erred in not referring the case back to the Environment Court to address outstanding questions not addressed in the Environment Court.
5. The Court did not rule on whether the High Court erred in not referring the case back to the Environment Court in order to give effect to concessions made by the Council in the High Court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal considered the application for leave to appeal a High Court decision overturning the Environment Court's cancellation of an abatement notice issued by the Marlborough District Council. The Council alleged that Zindia Limited was in breach of the Resource Management Act 1991, based on its commercial harvesting of a forest in Queen Charlotte Sound. Zindia sought to appeal the High Court decision, focusing on several questions of law. The Court of Appeal analysed the proposed questions of law and determined that the second, third, and fourth questions did not meet the criteria for granting leave, as they did not involve matters of general or public importance nor did they indicate a potential miscarriage of justice. However, the first question, concerning the interpretation of the consents, raised a legitimate question of law. Although the issue was unlikely to be of general or public importance, there was a risk of a miscarriage of justice if the High Court Judge had indeed erred in interpreting the consents. Therefore, the Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal on the specific question of whether the High Court Judge erred in construing the meaning and scope of Consents U120345.1 and U120345.6. This decision highlights the importance of correctly interpreting resource consents, which are essential legal instruments governing land use and activity in New Zealand. The Court of Appeal did not rule on the other questions of law presented in the application for leave to appeal, as they did not meet the criteria for granting leave.