Zafar v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CRI-2013-404-341 [2014] NZHC 722

BETWEEN

BEHESHTA ZAFAR

Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Respondent

Hearing: 8 April 2014

Counsel:

J Harder for Appellant
H Musgrave for Respondent

Judgment:

8 April 2014

ORAL JUDGMENT OF FOGARTY J

Solicitors:

Public Defence Service, Auckland

Meredith Connell, Auckland

ZAFAR v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2014] NZHC 722 [8 April 2014]

[1]      This is an appeal against sentence.  The principal issue is whether or not the District Court Judge when sentencing was in error when rejecting an argument that a sentence of 85 hours of community work was disproportionately severe, being the test in s 8(h) of the Sentencing Act.

[2]      The appellant had pleaded guilty to three charges of making a false statement, contrary to s 127 of the Social Security Act and one charge of making a wilful admission contrary to s 102 of the same section, the Social Security Act.  The total overpayments amounted to the sum of $17,639.60.  The particular context was that she was in employment when she applied for, and was granted, a sickness benefit in July 2011.   She had recommenced work for a home and hospital approximately a week and a half before she applied for a sickness benefit.   She was interviewed regarding the matter, immediately owned up and pleaded guilty.

[3]      The sentencing was first considered by Judge Kiernan in the District Court on

6 November.   The Judge had information about the appellant’s medical condition. She had essentially three medical conditions.  She had episodes of abdominal pain for which she had had her gall bladder removed in 2010 but the pain has continued, together with a liver dysfunction which has not been resolved.  The overall diagnosis is uncertain.  The second problem was she has been suffering from migraines and, thirdly, she has been on antidepressants for depression.  Although the Court does not know the details, it would appear that she has suffered stresses of one sort or another before coming to New Zealand, which have probably contributed to her ill health.

[4]      At the first sentencing hearing, Judge Kiernan was very sympathetic to her medical   condition,   and   impressed   by   her   immediate   acknowledgement   of wrongdoing.  Judge Kiernan crafted a term of community work of 85 hours which she thought was just over the number of hours for which she could make a basic work and living skills direction so that 80 hours of it could be converted to basic work and living skills.   This essentially is taking a course in budgeting and basic skills.  She thought in this case it would be the appropriate penalty.

[5]      Shortly after she completed that sentence, the probation officer drew to the attention of Mr Harder and counsel for the informant that s 66(b) of the Sentencing

Act 2002 sets a ceiling of 20 per cent of the total number of hours under the sentence spent in basic work and living skills.  The matter was taken back before the Judge and she then…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zafar v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 722
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Zafar v Ministry of Social Development is an appeal concerning the sentencing of the appellant, Behehta Zafar, who was found guilty of making false statements under the Social Security Act. Zafar was sentenced to 85 hours of community work by the District Court. Zafar's appeal against her sentence was heard in the High Court of New Zealand, Auckland Registry. Zafar's counsel argued that the sentence of 85 hours of community work was disproportionately severe under section 8(h) of the Sentencing Act, which requires the court to consider whether the sentence is disproportionately severe.

The court considered whether the District Court was in error when imposing the sentence of 85 hours of community work, particularly in light of Zafar's medical conditions. Zafar's medical history includes abdominal pain, liver dysfunction, migraines, and depression. The court weighed the District Court's initial decision, which took into account Zafar's medical conditions and her immediate admission of guilt, against the statutory limit on the proportion of community work that can be converted to basic work and living skills training. Despite this limit, the District Court did not alter the sentence, believing it was appropriate given Zafar's circumstances.

The High Court concluded that the District Court's decision to maintain the 85-hour sentence was appropriate. The court found that the sentence was reasonable and did not consider it disproportionately severe, even after accounting for Zafar's medical conditions. The High Court rejected Zafar's appeal and affirmed the District Court's sentence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established