Z v Complaints Assessment Committee

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

NOTE:  HIGH COURT ORDER SUPPRESSING PUBLICATION OF THE NAME AND IDENTIFYING PARTICULARS OF THE APPELLANT INCLUDING DETAILS OF HIS PRACTICE AND ITS LOCATION REMAINS IN FORCE

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA231/05 [2007] NZCA 91

BETWEEN  Z Appellant

ANDCOMPLAINTS ASSESSMENT COMMITTEE

First Respondent

ANDTHE DENTISTS DISCIPLINARY TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

Hearing:         8 November 2006

Court:            Glazebrook, Chambers and Ellen France JJ Counsel:  A H Waalkens QC and A L Credin for Appellant

J A Farish and A M Toohey for First Respondent

M Dalmer for Second Respondent (given leave to withdraw) Judgment:       22 March 2007    at 11 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant is to pay the first respondent costs of $3,000 plus usual disbursements.  We certify for second counsel.

Z V COMPLAINTS ASSESSMENT COMMITTEE AND ANOR CA CA231/05  22 March 2007

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Ellen France J)

Table of Contents

Introduction   [1] Factual background   [4] The disciplinary charges  [10] The key statutory provisions  [13] Judgment of the High Court  [20] What is the standard of proof?  [21] (i)        Submissions  [21]

(ii)    Discussion  [24] Abuse of process  [38] Result  [50]

Introduction

[1]       The Complaints Assessment Committee (“CAC”), a body established under the Dental Act 1988, has decided that a number of complaints against the appellant, a dentist,  should  be  heard  by  the  Dentists  Disciplinary  Tribunal,  the  second respondent.  The appellant says it is an abuse of process for the Tribunal to consider a number of these complaints because he has been acquitted by a jury of criminal charges arising from the same alleged conduct.

[2]      The appellant brought judicial review proceedings challenging the validity of the  CAC’s  decision.    In  a  judgment  delivered  on  6  October  2005,  Fogarty J dismissed the claim except in relation to some of the charges formulated in relation to the complaints (now reported as Z v Complaints Assessment Committee [2006] NZAR 146). The appellant appeals against the decision not to quash the remaining charges. The appellant’s case is that the criminal standard of proof or a standard very close to that should be applied to these disciplinary proceedings. If that is the standard then, he says, to hear the charges based on these complaints is an abuse of process.

(a)       What  is  the  standard  of  proof  applicable  to  these  disciplinary proceedings?

(b)       Does  the  reference  of  these  charges  to  the  Dentists  Disciplinary

Tribunal amount to an abuse of process?

Factual background

[4]      The appeal relates to disciplinary charges resulting from complaints about the appellant’s conduct by two patients, L and P.

[5]      Ms P attended the appellant’s dental rooms in September 1989.   She had some teeth extracted.  She was sedated with Hypnovel, a sedative which can cause hallucinations.

[6]      Ms L saw the appellant for the extraction of some teeth in January 2001. She was also sedated with Hypnovel.

[7]      Both  Ms  P  and  Ms  L  complained  to  the  police  saying  they  had  been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Z v Complaints Assessment Committee and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZCA 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerns the decision of the Complaints Assessment Committee to refer certain complaints against the appellant to the Dentists Disciplinary Tribunal for disciplinary proceedings. The appellant was acquitted by a jury of criminal charges arising from the same conduct. The appellant argues that a criminal standard of proof or a standard close to it should apply to these disciplinary proceedings and, if that is the standard, that to hear the charges is an abuse of process. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and found no abuse of process. The Court of Appeal concluded that the civil standard of proof was applicable to these disciplinary proceedings and that this conclusion reflected the protective purpose of the proceedings and the statutory regime. The Court of Appeal found no abuse of process because the disciplinary proceedings had a different purpose from the criminal proceedings and the appeal process was available to the appellant to challenge the outcome of the criminal proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves disciplinary charges against a dentist, referred to as the appellant, arising from complaints by two patients, Ms L and Ms P, who alleged indecent assault during dental procedures in 1989 and 2001, respectively. Both patients were sedated with Hypnovel during the procedures. The appellant was acquitted of criminal charges related to these allegations in 2002 after a jury trial. The Complaints Assessment Committee (CAC), established under the Dental Act 1988, decided that the complaints should be heard by the Dentists Disciplinary Tribunal. The appellant challenged the CAC's decision through judicial review proceedings, arguing that the disciplinary charges constituted an abuse of process due to his prior acquittal.

The appellant initially brought judicial review proceedings challenging the CAC's decision in the High Court. Fogarty J dismissed the claim except in relation to some of the charges, a decision that was reported as Z v Complaints Assessment Committee [2006] NZAR 146. The appellant then appealed to the Court of Appeal against the decision not to quash the remaining charges. The appeal was heard on 8 November 2006, and the judgment was delivered on 22 March 2007.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the standard of proof applicable to these disciplinary proceedings?
2. Does the reference of these charges to the Dentists Disciplinary Tribunal amount to an abuse of process?

Held
1. The appeal is dismissed.
2. The appellant is ordered to pay the first respondent's costs of $3,000 plus usual disbursements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the appellant's arguments regarding the standard of proof applicable to the disciplinary proceedings and whether referring the charges to the Dentists Disciplinary Tribunal amounted to an abuse of process. In relation to the standard of proof, the Court of Appeal concluded that the civil standard of proof is appropriate for these disciplinary proceedings. This was based on the nature of the proceedings as protective rather than punitive, the purpose of the disciplinary proceedings being to protect the public, and the statutory regime which contemplates a range of conduct from fitness to practice to professional negligence. The Court of Appeal rejected the appellant's argument that the criminal standard of proof or a standard very close to it should apply.

Regarding the abuse of process, the Court of Appeal found that there was no abuse of process in allowing the charges to proceed. The Court of Appeal noted that the disciplinary proceedings were not criminal or quasi-criminal, and the limited effect of an acquittal. The Court of Appeal also considered the relevant authorities and the fact that the Complaints Assessment Committee had evaluated the evidence in more detail and had rational reasons to doubt the judgment of the jury. The Court of Appeal held that the principles of double jeopardy did not apply and that the relevant factors had been carefully evaluated by Fogarty J, who applied the correct principles. The Court of Appeal agreed with Fogarty J's conclusion that there was no abuse of process in allowing the charges to proceed.