IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2014-419-355 [2016] NZHC 2178
BETWEEN YIELD ASSET MANAGEMENT
LIMITED Plaintiff
AND
WINDSOR PARK LEASING LIMITED Defendant
Hearing: On the papers Counsel:
M M Edwards and N P Tetzlaff for Plaintiff
P J Morgan QC for DefendantJudgment:
14 September 2016
JUDGMENT OF WHATA J
This judgment was delivered by me on 14 September 2016 at 4.00 pm, pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date: ………………………….
Solicitors: Gaze Burt, Auckland
Lewis Law, Hamilton
YIELD ASSET MANAGEMENT LTD v WINDSOR PARK LEASING LTD [2016] NZHC 2178 [14 September
2016]
[1] This is a costs judgment.
[2] Yield Asset Management Limited (Yield) is a property management company. Windsor Park Leasing Limited (Windsor) owns properties on Stanley Street. In about November 2011, Yield was assigned the management contract for the Stanley Street properties. In April 2014, Windsor sent a notice of termination to Yield. Yield did not accept that the notice was valid. It claimed management fees to September 2014, being the end date of the management agreement. Windsor claimed that the agreement was properly terminated and also raised an affirmative defence, based on breach of fiduciary duty, claiming that Yield attempted to take a secret profit from a real estate agent.
[3] At the hearing it became tolerably clear that Yield had not been entirely transparent with Windsor about its dealings with a real estate agent. There was evidence that Yield told Windsor that a real estate agent had an entitlement to a fee on the leasing of its property while at the same time telling the agent that it had no or a partial entitlement only. Yield was in the process of negotiating a split fee with the agent when Windsor terminated the management agreement. The effect of a split fee, if carried to fruition without Windsor’s approval, would have been that Yield may have received a secret profit to which it was not entitled. After discussion with Counsel about this evidence, Yield discontinued the proceedings.
[4] Windsor now claims indemnity costs on the basis that Yield’s claims never had any prospect of success given the clear evidence of an attempt to obtain a secret profit.
Legal frame
[5] Both parties agree that Yield is liable for costs. The key issue is quantum. It is also common ground that indemnity costs may be awarded where the trial is not completed and the claim lacked any merit. As Kós J put it in N-Tech Ltd v Abooth
Ltd:1
1 N-Tech Ltd v Abooth Ltd [2012] NZHC 1167 at [108].
It follows from these authorities that increased or indemnity costs may be awarded on the basis of lack of merit, in a case where the trial is not completed, only where the lack of merit is both obvious and incontrovertible. So clearly so that there is no reasonable possibility that the Court might form a different view with the benefit of all the evidence and closing submissions. No difficult…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Yield Asset Management Limited v Windsor Park Leasing Limite... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NZHC 2178
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the evidence and the arguments presented by both parties. It was evident from the proceedings that Yield had not been entirely transparent about its dealings with the real estate agent. Yield had told Windsor that the agent was entitled to a fee, while simultaneously negotiating a split fee with the agent, which would have resulted in Yield receiving a secret profit. Given this evidence, Yield discontinued its proceedings. Windsor sought indemnity costs, arguing that Yield's claims were baseless due to the clear evidence of an attempt to obtain a secret profit. The court agreed that indemnity costs may be awarded when the claim is not completed, and the claim lacked any merit.
The court found that Yield's claim was seriously damaged after cross-examination, but the defence case was not incontrovertible. Yield's claim for a 100% leasing fee was weak due to the clear evidence of the real estate agent's role in securing the tenancy. However, Yield's claim for a 30% fee was arguable, as was the claim for the management fee for early termination. Consequently, the court ordered Scale 2B costs plus disbursements in favour of the defendant. No award of costs was made on the application for costs.