Yang v Chen no.5 HC Auckland CIV-2007-404-1751

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2007-404-1751

BETWEEN  LIMIN YANG AND LIU (JASMINE) YANG

Plaintiffs

ANDPAUL (YU PO) CHEN Defendant

CIV 2008-404-4287

AND BETWEEN            DACHA INTERNATIONAL LIMITED First Plaintiff

ANDROTORUA INTERNATIONAL VILLAS LIMITED

Second Plaintiff

ANDTOP INTERNATIONAL LIMITED Third Plaintiff

ANDPAUL (YU PO) CHEN First Defendant

ANDHEARD PARK LIMITED Second Defendant

ANDCHOON KHIAW CHIN Third Defendant

Hearing:         8 and 13 April 2011

Counsel:         P J McPherson and G J Luen for plaintiffs

R B Hucker and D L Lang Siu for defendants

Judgment:      3 October 2011

JUDGMENT NO.5 of ALLAN J

In accordance with r 11.5 I direct that the Registrar endorse this judgment with the delivery time of 11 am on Monday 3 October 2011

YANG V CHEN HC AK CIV-2007-404-1751 3 October 2011

Solicitors:

Hesketh Henry, Auckland Patrick McPherson Patrick.mcpherson@heskethhenry.co.nz

Paul Chen paulyupochen@gmail.com

Queen City Law, Auckland marcus@queencitylaw.co.nz luckymachee@gmail.com

R B Hucker hucker@huckerlaw.com

Introduction

[1]      This  judgment  is  concerned  with  two  separate  applications  made  by  the plaintiffs against Mr Chen in these related proceedings.   In the first application, Limin Yang and Jasmine Yang seek an order declaring Mr Chen to be in contempt of the terms of a Mareva (freezing) order made in April 2007 and the imposition of appropriate sanctions.  In the second application, the plaintiffs in the later proceeding seek an order for security for costs against Mr Chen in respect of his counterclaim.

Procedural history

[2]      This  complex  litigation  went  to  trial  in  2010.    In  my  judgment  No.2, delivered on 5 October 2010, I set out the factual background and the issues in the case in some detail.  It is unnecessary to repeat now what I said then.  But a brief explanation is required in order to place the present applications in their proper context.

[3]      In 2003, Mr and Mrs Chen established a personal and business relationship with Ms Yang, and her husband Mr Liu.  Because Mr Liu was based predominantly in China, it fell to Ms Yang, who lived in New Zealand, to liaise with the Chens (but particularly  Mr Chen)  in  the  course  of  carrying  forward  certain  joint  business activities.  Mr Chen became a director of certain companies in which Ms Yang (and for a time Jasmine) were shareholders.   Regrettably a dispute arose between the Chens on the one hand, and Ms Yang and Mr Liu on the other.

[4]      The Chens considered that in the course of various joint projects entered into by Mr Lui and Mr Chen, the latter had become beneficially entitled to certain shares and  assets  hitherto  owned  by  Ms Yang,  or  companies  in  which  she  was  the shareholder.   Thereafter, Mr Chen dealt with certain assets on the basis that they were effectively owned by him.

[5]      All of this was extensively canvassed during a long trial which commenced on 26 April 2010 and concluded on 18 June 2010.   In my judgment of 5 October

2010, I upheld the claim of Limin and Jasmine Yang, finding that, notwithstanding Mr Chen’s claim to be entitled to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yang v Chen no.5 HC Auckland CIV-2007-404-1751 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZHC 1492
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Limin Yang, Jasmine Yang, Dacha International Limited, Rotorua International Villas Limited, and Top International Limited, brought two applications against Mr Paul Chen. The first application sought a declaration that Mr Chen was in contempt of a Mareva (freezing) order made in April 2007, and the imposition of appropriate sanctions. The second application sought an order for security for costs against Mr Chen in respect of his counterclaim. The court found Mr Chen to have been in contempt of court in respect of several matters, including failing to take sufficient steps to prevent the transfer of Rotorua properties to his mother in law, procuring the sale of the Kiwi Hotel and applying the net proceeds of sale for his own benefit, authorising the application of part of the proceeds of the sale of the Greys Avenue property in favour of Heard Park Ltd, failing to ensure that Heard Park Ltd accounted to Top International for the amount of the term deposit, and failing to comply with the terms of the freezing order by omitting to disclose particulars of the bank accounts. The court dismissed the plaintiffs' application for an order for security for costs against Mr Chen in respect of his counterclaim. The plaintiffs were entitled to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established